Fantasy Phenom Semifinalist Videos, Week 3

Round 2 of WFAN’s Fantasy Phenom contest was in full effect this past Monday at Buffalo Wild Wings in the Monmouth Mall in Eatontown, NJ.

Each semifinalist was given 2 minutes to rant about a chosen topic. One lucky contestant from this group will be chosen to participate in the Fantasy Phenom final round on August 27th at Bar A.

Watch the videos:

Joseph-Mets Need to Start Over

Pat-World Series Homefield Advantage

Robert-New York Jets’ Front Office

Ahnder-The Jets Woes

Frank-The Revis Saga Continues

Gregg-Rivalry? What Rivalry?

Chris-Mets Fans, Give Up Hope

Kerel-A Mets Positive Note

David-Coughlin on the Hot Seat

Daniel-The Mets Screwing Up Again


One Comment

  1. Kelly K. says:

    HANDS DOWN Anhder was the best one of them all…lots of enthusiasm and a GREAT personality…exactly what is needed for a radio talk show. He knows what he’s talking about and has the personality to make WFAN a success…you can just tell that the caller’s and people listening would love him…I’d definitley listen…CHOOSE ANHDER!!!!!!!

  2. markset says:

    The kid Joe was the best no doubt. Ive been following the whole competition and the other guys had me falling asleep. Joe was hilarious and as a Met fan I agree with all his opinions.

  3. Jen mac says:

    Joe was definately in my opinion the best natural born speaker. The others were boring, Joe was hilarious kept it interesting.

  4. markset says:

    Ive been following this competition from the beginning and I think the kid Joe was definatly the best one. I saw all the auditions and most of the other guys had me falling asleep. Im a met fan and agree with his views. He happens to be very funny also and I think he got a great radio voice. Im glad he mentioned the show scrappers and I happened to catch the show tonite on spike and it was hysterical

  5. Keith S. says:

    Joe gets my vote; he was informative and knowledgable and kept my interest. Although I’m a big time Yankee fan, I would have to agree with his comments and I wouldn’t mind hearing more from Joe.

  6. Glenn says:

    Anhder really nailed it about the long suffering Jets fan’s mindset. Anhder was very relexed and has a great radio voice.

  7. mark set says:

    joe was def the strongest presence out of the bunch. THE rest of the guys lost my attention and had me sleeping, Joe was funny and love his veiw on the mets. He also mentioned scrappers which i was able to catch on spike tonite and loved it.. very funny show. check it out

  8. Tina Markland says:

    Joe…was the BEST…his was very informative and new exactly what he was talking about. He was a PURE NATURAL, and would do a great job..Also, has a great radio voice…GO JOE

  9. Tina says:

    Joe was by far the best….Great voice and very informative. Also, very passionate about baseball and his feelings about the METS…..Joe, I would enjoy listening to you on the radio daily….

  10. sammy e says:

    Joe is great! Complete entertainment. He has the voice and knowledge to be a sucess. Any other choice than Pipi would mean and slump in listeners and stale air time.

  11. Jennifer says:

    Love Joseph…his points, his voice & overall his persona!

  12. Rossana says:

    Joe Pip is THE BEST! He knows what he’s talking about!!!!!!

  13. sal says:

    i have to say joe pipi looks like he has control of the show he has the look … and he really knows what hes talkin about joe pipi good luck you look great .. good work

    1. kelly says:

      look has nothing to do with it when you are on the radio!!!! personality counts and thats anhder…i just watched them all

  14. Denise says:

    Joe was definitely the best. great passion and energy. Go Joe!!!!

  15. briz says:

    Joe pipi was awesome. Knows a lot and speaks from the heart.

  16. Jdogs says:

    Joe was awesome, thats what the FAN needs.. a passionate, intelligent,real, host who isnt afraid of speaking his mind… you should def hire joe

  17. anthony angelo says:

    joe pipi has my vote. has a great new york radio voice.

  18. Reel Wahoo says:

    Kerel had purpose and meaning. He told you why and inspired you to still root for the Mets. Go Kerel, Wright and Davis.

  19. Lisa says:

    Joe was the best! He was very comfortable with speaking on the topic, he kept my attention the whole time and he was entertaining too. Team Joe!

  20. Joe D. says:

    Joey B was by far the most informative of all the rants. He is a true METS fan. Good Luck.

  21. Rich says:

    I thought Kerel was in control of his two minutes and had a great radio voice.

  22. allistar says:

    Joe was the best…great voice great energy!!!!! I want more!!!!!

  23. Gee Emm says:

    Joe was the only one who showed real passion … Didn’t seem like an audition .. He got my vote

  24. diana says:

    Joe was awesome.. the best one up there. vote for joeeee!!!!!

    1. A-Train says:

      why…..because he has a new york accent and a hundred fans saying “vote for joe”?

  25. joe says:

    i think jow sounded the best and was the most confident.. he also spoke about something that was important rather then a preseason game… i think joe should be the new manager of the mets!

  26. joe says:

    WOW this guy joseph hit it right on the head and he sounds good to maybe the mets need you joe !!!!

  27. Josh says:

    I really found myself agreeing with all of what Gregg had to say. Shut up, it’s preseason.

    Oh, by the way, Giants own NY. Huge win.

  28. chris says:

    this guy joe was def the best!!!! the rest of them sounded way too nervous and joe sounded like hes been doin it for years… vote for Joe!!!

  29. John says:

    I like Gregg a lot. Makes a good point plus backs it up with some facts. Seems pretty polished and isn’t just yelling into the mic.

  30. Dan says:

    Gregg was awesome! The others were good, but man, this guy made a lot of valid points. Could see myself listening to this guy all the time. Two thumbs up!

  31. vinny says:

    after viewing all of them i would have to say joe was the best… extremely passionate and has a great voice… i would def listen to him on the Fan

  32. Annette Guercio says:

    Joe was definitely the best. He was very passionate and kept me interested in what he had to say…definitely not boring. I would love to listen to him on a daily basis!!!

  33. shu says:

    I would have to say Gregg is the best…Best voice and makes the most sense…for real what was all the fuss about preseason…im rooting for this gregg guy I can see myself listening to him on teh radio

  34. Musky says:

    Joe breaks down the Mets the way Minaya should. Forget WFAN the Mets should hire Joe!

    1. Des says:

      Joe was the best….. Good ny voice and funny

  35. Fred Moskowitz says:

    Gregg was by far the best, He has great intensity and an obivous zest fors sports

  36. Ron says:

    pat was definitely the best

  37. Conf says:

    I thought Gregg was definitely the best. His voice is perfect for the radio and he knows his facts. There were no dull moments in either of his rants. Keep up the good work Gregg.

  38. Jared says:

    I don’t know how anyone could’ve been bored by Gregg. He was on point, enthusiastic and seemed like he truly believed in what he was saying. This kid could make it big.

  39. Raimondo says:

    Joe absolutely should be picked, colorful comments, held my interest the most, and made some excellent points on those Muts!!

  40. Matt says:

    I think Gregg did the best job out of this bunch. He was very enthusiastic about his topic, and made some great points. Hope to see him at Bar A.

  41. jwolff2 says:

    Gregg def made some real good points. why was there trash talking for a pre season game .. good work gregg im rooting for yah

  42. Jill says:

    I loved Gregg’s enthusiasm here. His youth and passion definitely came through and he’s definitely someone I’d want to listen to on the Fan.

  43. paul says:

    joe was by far the best…. he has the voice for New York Radio and i would love to listen some more

    1. A-Train says:

      Ok….now that we clearly see that this guy joe has every one of his friends….and their friends..,,and friends of their friends trying to plug votes for him……lets look at this figuratively now….ive watched ALL videos from ALL rounds….i dont know about everyone else but this guy ander dawson…….with the time he was given both times,has managed to touch on football,baseball,basketball….made all valid points and he never so much as hiccupped…..alot of guys are good…..but take a look and youll see what i mean people.

      1. Dmitry Merener says:

        I don’t think that Joseph having his friends write comments has any relevance. Bottom line is that all contestants showed the videos to their friends and have their support. The truth is that his voice is undeniably good and he has charisma. I feel that his video stays on point, shows his knowledge of sports and flashes his sense of humor. He was not the only person with a good video but I feel he was the most entertaining and I do not think that you should take away the good points by suggesting that his friends are trying to rig this contest. Everybody has an opinion but I don’t think that this negativity is necessary.

  44. PETERPIZZA says:

    i think JOSEPH PIPI WAS THE BEST informative passionate and his voice is awesome for radio my vote is for him!!!

  45. Tim says:

    I was a bit bored by Gregg, I lost focus.

    I liked Daniel, pretty solid approach.

    1. rich says:

      I agree

  46. GIl says:

    Dan is the man!

  47. JEFF says:

    After going through the videos, I think Gregg was the best. He’s got the voice for radio and can stir up controversy. He looked very comfortable with the spotlight on him.

  48. JETS2010 says:

    I like the young kid Gregg….hes got the most passion, let’s see some fresh blood in the finals

  49. Matt says:

    This guy Kerel deserves some more time. I mean for anyone to find a bright note in a dismal Mets season is a true fan!

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE