02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo
Holiday Weekend: Traffic & Transit | Travel Guide Forecast | Monuments | Listen Live: 1010 WINS | WCBS 880

News

Muslim Summit Planned Over Ground Zero Mosque

View Comments
NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 11: People demonstrate against allowing a mosque near Ground Zero at a rally in lower Manhattan on September 11, 2010 in New York, New York. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

NEW YORK – SEPTEMBER 11: People demonstrate against allowing a mosque near Ground Zero at a rally in lower Manhattan on September 11, 2010 in New York, New York. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

NEW YORK (CBS 2 / WCBS 880/1010 WINS/ AP) – A summit of Muslim organizations is planned for the weekend in New York City to address the rise of anti-Muslim sentiment linked to a proposed Islamic center near ground zero.

It isn’t clear whether the group will emerge with a firm endorsement of the proposed center. The meeting’s primary purpose is to talk about ways to combat religious bigotry.

But Shaik Ubaid of the Islamic Leadership Council of Metropolitan New York says he has a growing sense the that project is being embraced as a cause.

He says some American Muslims who initially reacted cautiously or with indifference to the center are now rallying around the plan because they feel their faith is under attack.

The meeting will take place as some supporters of the center are encouraging its backers to add prayer space for other religious groups.

It was clear from the speech he gave at the Council on Foreign Relations on Monday that Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf intended to cast himself as a moderate Muslim and a proud New Yorker.

“I vote in elections, I pay taxes. I pledge allegiance to the flag. And I am a Giants fan,” Rauf said.

But, as CBS 2′s Marcia Kramer reports, he lost the support of many New Yorkers when he said the spot near ground zero where he wants to put his mosque and cultural center is not hallowed ground.

“It is absolutely disingenuous as many have said that that block is hallowed ground, with strip joints around the corner with betting parlors. Let’s clarify that misperception,” Rauf said.

But there are some who say it is the imam who has the “misperception.”

“I think that may be where he differs with the American people and the people of New York City. It is indeed hallowed ground as much as Gettysburg or Pearl Harbor or Auschwitz,” state GOP leader and member of the Council on Foreign Relations Edward Cox.

Construction worker Andy Sullivan helped pull bodies out of the pit and lost many friends on 9/11.

“To me it is a cemetery. I would never think of building something on top of a cemetery,” Sullivan said.

The imam tried to make it seem like he was open to changes.

“We are exploring all options. Everything is on the table,” Rauf said.

The imam’s wife, Daisy Khan, had the same message.

“Give us some time to make the right decision. We are New Yorkers. We are Muslims. We want to be part of rebuilding lower Manhattan and we just need some time to make the right decision,” Khan said.

But it didn’t seem like the imam was about to fold his tents and not build his mosque.

“This is an opportunity that we must capitalize on so that those who preach moderation will have a mega-horn to preach and to teach,” Rauf said.

Some say the imam won’t announce any new decisions until after the November elections. 

LISTEN:
CBS News’ Pamela Falk analyzes Monday’s remarks
1010 WINS’ John Montone reports from the Council On Foreign Relations
WCBS 880′s John Metaxas on the emotional level of this post-9/11 debate 
WCBS 880′s Ginny Kosola on the Imam’s weekend comments

The proposed Islamic center has become a flashpoint for worldwide debate about Islam’s place in America nine years after the Sept. 11 attacks. Controversy has colored the fall campaign season and cast a a shadow on this past weekend’s commemoration of the attacks, with supporters and opponents of the mosque project both holding rallies nearby.
   
Rauf says a project meant to foster understanding has become unduly mired in conflict and what he describes as misconceptions of a fundamental clash between Islamic and American values. The Kuwait-born imam used his own life story as an example, saying that his own faith had been shaped by the sense of choosing one’s identity that American society provided, compared with the predominantly Muslim society from which he emigrated in 1965.
   
He said Monday that the Islamic center’s organizers were surprised by the uproar and might not have pursued it had they known what was coming.
   
“The events of these past few weeks have really saddened me to my very core,” he said, lamenting that the project had been misunderstood, clouded by stereotypes, and “exploited” by some to push personal or political agendas.

Meanwhile, a new Quinnipiac University poll says 70 percent of American voters believe Muslims have the right to build a mosque and cultural center near ground zero in Manhattan, but 63 percent say doing so would be wrong.
   
The poll released Monday also says only 38 percent of registered voters surveyed said they have a favorable opinion of Islam, while 40 percent have an unfavorable opinion.
   
Half of those surveyed say mainstream Islam is a peaceful religion, not one that encourages violence against non-Muslims.
   
Voters also disapprove of how President Barack Obama is handling the New York mosque controversy, 44 to 31 percent.
   
The poll surveyed about 1,900 registered voters nationwide from Aug. 31 to Sept. 7 and has a sampling margin of error of plus or minus 2.3 percentage points.

(TM and Copyright 2010 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2010 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

View Comments
  • mike

    I agree he should build a Mosque. In Iran.

  • SeaBee

    I see a fundamental problem for the Muslims. They cannot, within Islam, insure the building because whatever happens is “inshallah” (the will of God). Those who oppose the building will, given the opportunity, destroy it. The Muslims will, eventually, run out of money.

  • Rich

    Mr. Obama tells Muslims has the right to build Mosque, but he never reminds Muslims that you need to give other religion the same right, If you really want to help Muslim, pls teach them to give

  • Luz Vega-Hidalgo

    S what are the protestors protesting. There has been a mosque, in the same place where a new one is being planned for the last 23 years. We Christians in the U.S. have had our share of wacko terrorist, and Christian churches go up all the time.

  • MIke_88

    Let’s say they build the mosque. Saddened American’s will no doubt march down to the mosque every 9/11 filled with emotion to protest.

    This will lead to muslim protesting to defend their religion. Clashing in the streets will begin and it will never end. There will be violence, there will be death, all in the name of a peaceful, caring religion called Islam.

    The same peaceful religion that hijacked three planes and crashed them into the hearts of the American people saying we will always kill more of you.

    With the government and corporate greed sinking American way of life at an alarming rate, there will soon be enough American’s ready to give their lives at home fighting muslims for their country as a muslim friended president allowed the door to be opened for their agenda to prosper.

    Muslim’s will deny this, but if you look around it has happened everywhere else. If a muslim claims they are peaceful and loving, after reading the koran you will find they are a failed muslim.

    • jp

      You act as if there aren’t any Christian terrorist groups, Jewish terrorist groups, White terrorist groups, etc. What about the mosques being protested around the country, thousands of miles away from Ground Zero? If this was completely about ground zero then it would be understandable, but it’s not.

  • Lets build

    This mosque was built in 1970 and it is not exactly on ground zero. Mosque has been there way before 911. As a new yorker and a Muslim all i will say is both Muslim and non Muslim have lost their lives during 911 and I’m not going to let some dumb haters and some radical group completely distort the view point of my religion.

  • jp

    Here are a couple of things that I hope will clarify a few things.
    1. If the media didn’t blow this way out of proportion, the only people that would know about this mosque would be those who live in the local community.
    2. For those of you like Kim who believe this is a “victory mosque”, this place is going to have a 9/11 memorial room, a restaurant, culinary school, gym, pool, and basketball courts. All of these are open to the community. “Yeah, that’s the way we’ll stick it to the Americans. Let’s give them a recreational center.”
    3. In the 9 years after 9/11, no one has wanted to purchase that old building or many other buildings near it. Would you rather it sit there unoccupied forever?

  • James

    Some Islamic countries dont allows Christians or other religions to build their worship places. But it is so funny that they want to send their money to build a mosque in NY city. My dear Muslim brothers and sisters, pls do first and then you tell others. You need to stop just receiving pls learn to give as well.

  • observer

    meaning of secularism in islam:
    i asked a muslim why he needs secularism when almost all muslim majority countries are islamic. he explained that only islam can guarantee true secularism. . he sincerely believed islam and sharia brings true freedom and human rights superior to all present religions /philosophies and jurisprudence. so it is good for all when islamic rule is established and it is the foremost duty of muslims to engage in JIHAD to establish that islamic rule.

  • Mohammed Abdul Aziz

    “It is absolutely disingenuous as many have said that that block is hallowed ground, with strip joints around the corner with betting parlors. Let’s clarify that misperception,” Rauf said. Adding, “a terrorist indoctrination mosque will not detract from the mix.”

  • BS Meter

    So? what happened with the Slumlord-angle in Union, NJ today? is our media going to pretend that aspect of this person (along with the non-rent paying developer as reported earlier this week in NY papers)? are we now subject to misdirection, because that doesn’t meld nicely with what we’re supposed to believe about this 13-story mega-mosque supposedly being planned for some sort of harmony?..

  • KARL LAGERFELD

    where’s the money? let them have a floor in the freedon tower

  • Ella

    Building a mosque in a place where Muslim fundamentalists killed people is the height of insensitivity. It’s equivalent to building a pro-Nazi monument in Jerusalem. Some things should just not be done.

  • Yusaf

    Thank you all Haters

    Its because of you that Islam is the fastest growing religion in USA and Europe.

    Really, its not a taunting comment. I really am thank full

    Many of the people i know entered Islam just because of hearing all of the haters when they say bad stuff about Islam .

    Keep up the good work

    • DanTe

      And a

      Allah’s Ma Licks ‘Em

      to you too, Yusaf.

  • Dbag

    The fact that the Imam does not consider the site to be “hallowed’ because strip clubs and betting parlors are in the vicinity speaks volumes. Muslims feel that their religion is under attack because people are expressing their opinions? Nine years ago, our country was attacked. I watched people jumping to their deaths rather than burn to death. Innocent people who wanted nothing more than to go to their jobs and earn a living. That day I learned everything I needed to know about the peaceful religion of Islam. Build it someplace else. This country was built on American, not Muslim values. Think Islam is a peaceful religion? Think it’s sad ’cause most Americans don’t want the Mosque built near Ground Zero? Find someone whose loved one never came home 9 years ago. Ask them what they think is sad.

  • FCKISLAM

    @Ahmed
    ===YOUR KORAN BOOK IS A DEVIL BOOK!!!…YOU USE THE WORD OF GOD TO KILL PEOPLE !,GIVE PAIN TO THE FAMILY OF THE MUSLIM VICTIMS EVERY WHERE IN THE WORLD….ISLAM ARE TERORIZE BECAUSE ALLAH IN YOUR BOOK IS DEMON !!!DO NOT EVER SAY SALAMAYKOM AGAIN ..THERE IS NO PEACE IN YOUR RELEGION !!!

    • Atak Al Hajam

      U SAID FCK MUSLIM, MAY BE U NEVER READ QOR’AN BEFORE (THN U LIE TO MAKE PROVOCATION FOR YOUR CONCERN ONLY); OR U READ ON TH NEGATIVE THINKKING ?? IF U READ QUR’AN (ARABIC LITERATE I AM SURE YOU’RE NOT CAPABILITY). IF U READ QU’AN TRANSLATED ON YOUR NATIVE LANGUAGE, U WILL FOUND THAT TH QUR’AN EXPAINED TO MANKINDS, THT TH ONLY DEVIL & HIS FOLLOWER REJECTED ALLAH ORDER (i.e Al Qur’an too)…SAME WITH YOUR NONSENSE ARGUMENT. NAUDZUBILLAH MIN DZALIK.

  • Anti-allah

    There are a plethora of mosX in manhattan. This is clearly an attempt to draw media attention, stir up some trouble and pour some salt in our wounds. The people behind this are using OUR freedoms and laws against us.
    Now they are organizing a rally to defend their beliefs? We were attacked on the very same ground that they plan to march and build on for our beliefs and laws. The people who want to see this go through have absolutely no regard for OUR beliefs and laws. “Peace loving muslims?” This project and debate are not exactly promoting peace and goodwill. I witnessed the celebrations outside the mosX of NYC on 9/11/01 and the weeks following. These “peace loving muslims” were out in the streets revering in the despicable actions of their “brothers.”
    If you are so peace loving then go celebrate your peace in any of the multitude of mosX scattered throughout Manhattan and the rest of the boroughs for there are PLENTY of them. Peace loving my ass!!!!!

  • peace be upon you

    Stop misrepresenting Islam over terrorism.

    • DanTe

      Yes “peace”. Stop lying about mu-slimes. Here’s some FACTS.

      FACT: Everywhere where there are mu-Slimes, sh-!t happens.

      China — sh-!t happens
      (suicide bombers that kill little children and run amok with metal pipes in the streets)

      India — sh-!t happens
      (mu-slimes burned 100s of hindus alive in packed trains and burned villagers alive while they slept)

      Middle East — sh-!t happens
      (suicide bombers that kill little children)

      Russia — sh-!t happens
      (suicide bombers that kill women and children in crowded theaters)

      South East Asia — sh-!t happens
      (mu-slime thugs who kidnap teachers, school children, nurses, priests for ransom, than murder them all)

      Europe — sh-!t happens
      (suicide bombers that kill little children)

      USA — 9/11 happened

      Goes to reason, no mu-slimes, no sh-!t.
      All these camel turds understand is violence and lies anyway. I say we oblige them by killing them all and than lie about how sorry we are.

      Islam. It’s a disease. And like any other infestations of boils, pox and pestilence, it should be eradicated. You don’t talk to diseases. You eradicate them like you did polio.

      And some bleeding heart imbecile here will post that it’s just a few individuals that are murderous, just like any other society. But than conveniently forgetting about the Fact that it happens worldwide and by a LOT MORE than just a few individuals. And they also continues to blank out of their empty heads the worldwide mu-slime jubilee celebrations as people burned on 9/11.

  • John

    a summit to address the fact that there may be anti muslim feelings..

    not to discuss the possibility that you may have chosen the wrong location.

    poor muslim victims.

  • KIM

    It’s really a sad day when people who have openly attacked this country causing thousands of casualties are permitted to build on what we consider to be sacred ground.
    Mind you, they are permitted to build and do build basically everywhere that they want to- they are not denied freedom of religion.
    But they insist on this spot because of the very factthat is causes us great pain.
    any questions?

  • Madelyn

    Enough with this already. Why not consider allowing this buildingto be considered officeally part of ground zero.

    A piece from one of the planes crashed through the roof of this site.

    isn’t that enough to see it’s hallowed ground to us?

    It’s like talking to a wall.

    move the mosque to somewhere else.

  • proud agnostic

    The mooslims are savages.Always were.Always will be.How many churches and synogouges in there country?

    • nul_01

      There are numerous churches in my town… in fact my neighbours both at right and left side of my house are christians and roman catholics… there is only one synagog here
      Nul – Indonesia

      • DanTe

        Here’s a hint “nul_01″: If you have to lie to make your point. Then you have no point.

        Allah’s Ma Licks ‘Em

  • Ahmed

    Protest against bigotry tomorrow. Build the mosque! Allah Akbar

    • DanTe

      Can we fly a plane into it? In the proud mu-slime tradition?

    • MIke

      Build it and after the next terroist attack it will be destroyed like all other mosques in this country.

  • C. Allison

    If the people who want to build the mosque are genuine in their feeling towards America than surely the decent think to do would be not to cause America any more upset, and to just drop the project.

    • Nissiam

      How can you say that? actually there is a lot and this is a proud moroccan jew, born and raised here, studied undergrad in europe, grad in US and back to my country so i can tell you that u wrong, this is not a religious war, this what some people want to believe in, we need to stop this whole thing, and americans as the first economic and military power can help in that. stop this whole racial religious thing, the fight is just political and economical and strategic (middle east conflict) and as a jew i am not sure israel did good in this 60 year conflict. Please read history and travel a bit before saying stuff like this otherwise the world will end up in a huge war.

      • Nissiam

        This message was meant for proud agnostic. Sorry and have a nice day

  • Jane

    Daisy Khan is asked for a response in the piece below. Her repsonse will be telling.

    Urgent: Feminist Icons Needed (That means you, Ms. Steinem) (http://open.salon.com//blog/nyframed/2010/09/17/urgent_feminist_icons_needed_that_means_you_ms_steinem)

1 2
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video