N.Y. Gov ‘Debate’ Turns Into Comedy Central

Circus-Like Atmosphere, As Cuomo, Paladino Overshadowed

Updated 10/19/2010 7:41 a.m.

HEMPSTEAD, N.Y. (CBS 2/WCBS 880/ 1010 WINS) — It’s tough to pick a winner from Monday night’s first — and likely only– debate in the race for New York governor.

The front-runners found themselves upstaged at Hofstra University by five fring candidates — some spouting a series of bizarre one-liners.

LISTEN: 4 reports from WCBS 880’s Steve Scott
LISTEN: 1010 WINS’ Terry Sheridan reports from Hofstra

As CBS 2’s Marcia Kramer reports, the race for governor looked more like the race for a circus ring leader.

In a new poll released Monday, 70 percent of New Yorkers said they are unhappy with the dysfunction in Albany. And this debate probably did nothing to change their minds.

Call it a seven-ring circus.

Jimmy McMillan, of the “Rent Is 2 Damn High” Party, had the same answer to everything from rotten bus and subway service to no jobs and high taxes.

And then there was Manhattan madam Kristin Davis, who said she provided hookers for Eliot Spitzer, who answered a question about the about the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

cuomo paladino N.Y. Gov Debate Turns Into Comedy Central

Paladino (L), Cuomo (R) (AP Photo/Kathy Kmonicek)

“The key difference between the MTA and my former escort agency is that I operated one set of books and my former agency delivered on-time, reliable service,” Davis said.

The answer might have been tongue in cheek, so to speak, but Davis also called for the legalization of marijuana to raise $2.5 billion to cut the deficit and rejected business taxes.

“Businesses will leave the state quicker than Carl Paladino in a gay bar,” Davis said.

No, it wasn’t comedy night at the improv. It was the one and only time New Yorkers got to see Democrat Andrew Cuomo and Republican Carl Paladino, plus five third party candidates, debate the pressing issues facing our state.

Libertarian Warren Redlich, who reportedly wants heroin made available to addicts by prescription, offered this solution for creating jobs.

“The money that we waste there comes out of your pockets. Give us 300 bucks and we can do it with a pizza and a six-pack once a month,” Redlich said.

Freedom Party candidate Charles Barron said the way to solve the budget crisis was simply to tax the rich.

“It’s easy to be a political bully and take it out on the poor,” Barron said.

And as for Cuomo and Paladino, they never bothered to answer some of the troubling charges made against them, charges that Cuomo takes special interest money and that Paladino lacks the temperament to be governor.

Instead, they offered platitudes.

“I think the question in this race is who can actually do it? Who can get it done?” Cuomo said.

“My critics, they want to say I’m angry. No, I’m passionate about saving New York,” Paladino said.

Larry Levy is a professor of political science at Hofstra.

“I actually think the minor party candidates did serve a purpose. I mean some of it had a circus air to it. Some were clearly trying to make very, very particular point, but if you didn’t have some of these guys nobody would talk about housing. Nobody would be talking about progressive tax systems,” Levy said.

After the debate some called for another one, to which some would say only if they agree to run it on Comedy Central.

More from Steve Scott
  • http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2011/08/05/jimmy-mcmillan-rent-is-too-damn-high-candidate-faces-eviction/ Jimmy McMillan, 'Rent Is Too Damn High' Candidate, Faces Eviction From East Village Apartment « CBS New York

    […] who spiraled to national fame following a wild gubernatorial debate and is now planning a run for president, has told his lawyer to file a counter claim for […]

  • benoch

    The entire political arena has become a joke. Christine O’Donnell today was a great example. Basil Marceaux from Tennessee. I think desperate times bring the crazies. I considered Christine, Basil, and McMillan and what they have in common http://wp.me/pnJXN-2F

  • Mogen David

    Even after the “comedy show”, I still believe Paladino is the best bet for real change. When politicians are in too long, the stench starts and gets progressively worse with time. “Crazy Carl” is a change for the better, and as a businessman, I would give him my vote. After all, it can’t be any worse with him and a fresh face in Albany would be refreshing!

  • http://axisofright.com/2010/10/19/didnt-you-hear-the-rent-is-too-damn-high/ Didn’t you Hear? The Rent is Too Damn High! | Axis of Right

    […] the rest of debate was quite a circus, marginalizing both Cuomo and Paladino through McMillan and a Madam whose most memorable line was […]

  • Slizzo

    this is great. the GOP and DNC suck holes belong up there with the rest of the wackjobs. they are just as insane.

  • http://www.capitolreportnewmexico.com/?p=1902 “The Rent is Too Damn High Party” in NY: The birth of a populist movement « Capitol Report | New Mexico

    […] At last night’s New York gubernatorial debate, among the mainstream candidates on the stage appeared a well-coiffed gentleman who’s running […]

1 2
blog comments powered by Disqus
Giving Tuesday
Charles Osgood Event

Listen Live