Manhattan Judge: Little Girl Can Be Sued In Bike Crash

NEW YORK (AP) — She might have been too young for grade school, but a judge says a New York City girl was old enough to be sued over a bicycle accident that happened when she was 4.

A Manhattan judge refused earlier this month to toss out negligence claims against young Juliet Breitman. She, her mother and others are being sued by the estate of a woman who said she was severely hurt when hit by bicycles that Juliet and a boy were racing down a sidewalk in April 2009.

The woman, Claire Menagh, died later that year.

Juliet was three months shy of 5. The judge says there’s no evidence a child of that age couldn’t appreciate “the danger of riding a bicycle into an elderly woman.”

Lawyers for everyone involved didn’t immediately return calls Friday night.

(Copyright 2010 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)


One Comment

  1. what really happened? says:

    Thats too bad, but what complications did this lady have? A 4 year cannot go that fast to hurt some on a tricycle …..

  2. DanTe says:

    How about suing the stupid c\/nt “mother” that was suppose to supervise the child? Bet you SOB’s would be singing a different tune if the girl biked into the city streets.

  3. billy bats says:

    maybe the judge could be removed for gross stupidity unbefitting a human being???? is anyone investigating how he is ‘involved’ with the dead womans family????

  4. NYC says:

    These people are so sick! What is the world coming to?? Whats next? Suing for looking at someone??

  5. Syosset says:

    The same thing happened to my husband’s grandma in the BX. She didn’t die, but she was plowed into by a 10-year-old on a bike. She broke her shoulder and had to have surgery. The boy was very sorry, but we didn’t sue him. It was an accident!

  6. NYC says:

    No doubt that this Judge will be over-ruled on appeal. A four year old cannot be held responsible for this.

    1. linda says:

      But her parents can be!!!!!

      1. rugbyball says:

        Ok, her parents can be and they are named in the lawsuit. So then sue the parents, leave the child out.
        What does suing a 4 y/o do but make you look like a school yard bully.

  7. mj says:

    they should take her for EVEYTHING shes got . her barbies , her care bears even her my little pony .

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Listen Live