N.J. Senators Propose New Hudson River Rail Tunnel Project

Christie Doesn't Rule Out New Idea, Says He'll Do His Research

TRENTON, N.J. (AP/ CBSNewYork) — New Jersey’s two U.S. senators are touting a proposal to build a new “Gateway Tunnel” to boost needed rail passenger services between New York City and New Jersey.

Amtrak is proposing to spend $50 million to begin preliminary engineering and design on two new rail tunnels. It said it will seek additional funds from New Jersey, New York State, New York City and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and the Port Authority. It hopes to finish the project by 2020.

EXTRAS: Overview Of The Gateway Tunnel Project | Gateway vs. Trans-Hudson

WCBS 880 Reporter Levon Putney With Comments From Senators And Reaction From Christie

1010 WINS Reporter Sonia Rincon Reports Amtrak Would Spearhead This Project

Sens. Frank R. Lautenberg and Robert Menendez, both Democrats, said in a press release that the tunnel would amount to a new Trans-Hudson rail tunnel, the monumental project that New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie canceled in October because of the expense. The two senators held a press conference with Amtrak officials Monday at Hilton Newark Penn Station.

“The Gateway Project is a vision for our future that will shorten commutes, create jobs, increase property values and grow New Jersey’s economy,” Sen. Lautenberg said.

Christie killed the plans to build a second commuter rail tunnel under the Hudson River, a project that would have been the United States’ biggest public works project if it had gone forward. The cost was an estimated $9 billion to $14 billion.

However, on Monday Christie at least sounded open-minded about the new proposal.

“We’ll see if it’s good for the taxpayers of this state. So well see. But as we sit here today, now, if they ask me for a check today, the answer is no,” Christie told CBS 2’s John Metaxas.

Lautenberg said New Jersey is facing a transportation crisis and said something needs to be done about it immediately.

“When the ARC Tunnel was cancelled, it was clear to me that we couldn’t just throw up our hands and wait years to find another solution,” he said.

“We say this new Trans-Hudson tunnel is right for New Jersey and right for the region and its future,” Sen. Robert Menendez said.

The existing 100-year old rail tunnels into midtown Manhattan are already operating at capacity during rush hour, and ridership is expected to double in the next two decades, officials said.

Representatives for the two senators said that the Gateway route would follow approximately the nine-mile path from Secaucus to New York City that had been proposed for the derailed project. But the Gateway route would connect to new tracks in Penn Station, rather than end under the city’s West 34th Street.

“We’ve run out of capacity at Penn Station and that’s where people want to get to,” Amtrak President and CEO Joseph Boardman said.

It also would allow for 13 additional NJ Transit trains per hour and eight additional Amtrak trains. The Gateway Project is expected to increase NJ Transit commuter rail capacity into New York by 65 percent. Proponents of the project would have to find federal and local funding for it.

Amtrak projects that the entire Gateway Tunnel project could be completed in 2020 at an estimated cost of $13.5 billion.

The Trans-Hudson tunnel was in the planning stages for decades. Last year, federal authorities mailed New Jersey a bill for $271 million for engineering and construction work done on the tunnel before Christie canceled the project. Christie is fighting the payment and has filed an appeal.

New Jersey residents seemed largely enthused by the idea, provided, of course, it doesn’t hit them too hard financially.

“It takes a long time to get back and forth. Another tunnel can’t hurt. Anything to help the commuter,” Bayonne resident Paul Witkowski said.

“Why not? If it makes my commute easier and faster, why not?” added Montclair’s Steven Kayode.

“I think it’s costing New Jersey way too much money, so we shouldn’t do it,” said Mary Piton of Mahwah.

(TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

More from Levon Putney

One Comment

  1. Paul Gawkowski says:

    The Gateway Project will not only benefit NJ and NY commuters, it will benefit longer distance AMTRAK riders from all over the US by improving speed and capacity on the Northeast Corridor. Hopefully, Governor Christie, the man who stopped the wheels of progress in NJ by cancelling the original HudsonRiver Tunnel Project, will be voted out of office in the next election.

  2. SamIam says:

    A new tunnel would be good if the project can be run efficiently and with cost reduction always in mind. It’s doubtful this can be accomplished in the union-favored corrupt states of NJ and NY. The taxpayers are likely to bilked of hundreds of mllions that are funnled to Democrat-favored unions, who will then launder it and return a good chunk to Democrat campaign coffers.

  3. Lord Kinbote says:

    Why do they keep naming these train stations after crooked politicians?

  4. Tom says:

    Well, it’s certainly a better plan than the disaster of a plan the ARC Tunnel Project was. Hopefully, this project goes forward. As long as the feds pay at least 90% of it. If there is money to build other countries and fight 2 wars, then there must be $10 billion to build this tunnel. The existing PRR Tunnels have been at capacity for a while and this will help Amtrak and NJ Transit.

  5. Robert Senn says:

    somone tell these two///////////////// to stop wasting our money why should we pay for it tax the peaple who work in ny ore live in ny worh in nj

    1. Jamey says:

      I live in NJ and work in NY. I spend most of the money I earn in NY in NJ.

      Tell you what, to be fair, tax only those who live in NJ and work in NY … AND anyone who receives any economic benefit from those who live in NJ and work in NY…

      You in? Yeah, that’s what I thought…

  6. Joshua says:

    Does that mean more rift raft trash from NY will be traveling into the beautiful Garden State?

    1. KPMc says:

      No, it means that New Jerseyans that party in NY after work and can’t handle their liquor have another line to throw up on at 11PM on a Friday night besides the PATH.

      Aside from sporting events and Great Adventure us NY rift raft prefer to steer clear of the Garbage State.

    2. Ed P. says:

      Joshua, have you ever taken the train? It is PACKED in the morning carrying New Jerseyans to New York City, where they all work. And it is PACKED in the evening carrying those same people home to NJ, where they spend their money they earned in NYC. It is mostly COMPLETELY DEAD all other times, because most city-dwellers don’t want to go to NJ.

  7. Larry Schwarz says:

    Does this mean the 7 train wont go to Secaucus now.

  8. Devenio says:


    1. LINDA says:


Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE