02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

News

NYC Council Proposal: Agents, Prove Traffic Tickets Are Legit

Speaker Quinn Takes Aim At Parking Situation; Bloomberg Mum

View Comments
Parking Meter (credit: CBS 2)

Parking Meter (credit: CBS 2)

stan

Reporting Stan Brooks

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) – With bike lanes and pedestrian plazas popping up everywhere, drivers feel like an endangered species in New York City.

But the City Council wants to change that, starting with a novel idea that could reduce the number of tickets traffic agents give out, reports CBS 2’s Marcia Kramer.

What if a traffic agent actually had to prove that every ticket he or she gives out is legitimate?

You think it’s a fantasy?

Not to Council Transportation Chair James Vacca, who said Tuesday its time to reverse what he says is the anti-driver bias of the Bloomberg administration.

“We want a picture taken of the actual offense. We want that traffic agent to document with a picture exactly what was the offense,” Vacca said.

Noting that the number of traffic summonses have nearly tripled under Mayor Michael Bloomberg, Vacca is questioning whether all of them are strictly legit.

“We have people who work two jobs who are now being required to take time off from those jobs to go fight traffic tickets that are bogus to begin with,” Vacca said.

At her state of the city speech, Council Speaker Christine Quinn also suggested easing alternate side of the street parking regulations to create more parking, and a law to prohibit agents from issuing tickets to drivers who momentarily step away from their vehicles to pay the meters.

“A $65 parking ticket, it seems like a small problem until you’re $65 short for your rent,” Quinn said.

“It’s a real pain in the neck sometimes,” said Kashif Brahim of Marine Park.

 NYC Council Proposal: Agents, Prove Traffic Tickets Are Legit

Bike Lane (credit: CBS 2)

“If you don’t find a Monday park, you got to park on the Tuesday side. You got to get up at 9 a.m. and then if you don’t find a Thursday you got to park Tuesday and, it’s just ridiculous,” said Tony Filiciano of Chelsea.

Parking has only become more complicated over recent years since Mayor Michael Bloomberg introduced numerous pedestrian plazas and controversial bike lanes throughout many key areas.

Taking on what she calls the City’s effort to nickle-and-dime drivers, Council Speaker Christine Quinn is unveiling a series of “driver-friendly” initiatives aimed at making parking a bit easier.

1010 WINS Reporter Stan Brooks with ideas for parking tickets and meter maids


Among the ideas Quinn is floating during Tuesday’s State of the City speech is a proposal that would reduce the number of alternate-side parking days in some neighborhoods. Streets that received the highest cleanliness rating two years running would have the option to scale back street cleaning from two days a week to just one.

What do you think of the parking situation in the City? Sound off in our comments section below

“You would actually be able to find parking on the side, that’d be perfect,” said Cindy Santiago of East Elmhurst.

However, some non-drivers are more critical. “A lot’s happened in the City lately and it’s cleaned up a lot and I don’t know if I would sacrifice it or not,” said Robert Minicki of Haledon, N.J.

Quinn was also targeting meter maids. Currently they can and do ticket any cars that don’t have a receipt on the dashboard, even if the driver is stepping away to pay the meter – no exceptions, no warnings.

“I had an experience with a traffic cop. I’m sitting in my car and I still get a ticket,” said Kashif Brahim of Marine Park.

Under the new proposal, ticket agents would have to tear up tickets on the spot for drivers who show a valid receipt.

After the recent push to make the City more bike-friendly, some drivers say its about time they get a break as well. “They got their break. I think drivers deserve a break too,” said Anthony Aviles of Chelsea.

Quinn is also pitching an online resource that would point drivers to open parking spots and alert them to street closures.

A spokesperson for Mayor Bloomberg said the City already has a pilot program for reducing alternate side parking in Brooklyn and the Bronx.

The relatively new push to spread the bike lanes further across the boroughs is only fueling the deep divide between drivers and bikers.

Yolanda Lopez of the Bronx is no fan of the the new pro-bike regulations. “I hate it with a passion,” she said.

“They put up a new sign, I make a wrong turn, I get a $90 ticket and points on my license. Nothing’s happening to these guys,” said Kate Helpern of the Lower East Side.

View Comments
  • Bob

    To eliminate road congestion for public buses, delivery trucks and ambulances, there needs to be MORE barricaded and safe bike lanes. The City needs to take any measure to get cars off the roads. Trucks and bikes are not a good combo since trucks have blind spots. The City simply cannot sustain population growth of the City and the exponential growth in the number of cars on the road.

  • rob

    Until the day bikers pay for parking and all the freaking dollars to the state and city of NY I’d respect their opinions. But as of now they have no jacks nor any rights to be spewing their opinions. They’re bunch of freeloaders trying to make rules for NYC. Until they pay their fair share of the fees we’re paying right now then they can say whatever they want. But as of now they ain’t jacks. It’s like going into a bar trying to order a bottle of wine with no money. What a joke.

    • eveostay

      Cyclists pay income and property taxes, which is where the money for “free” on-street parking comes from. Since they don’t wear out the roads, they probably are the only ones who aren’t being subsidized by others.

      • johnny

        Really? And drivers don’t pay income and property taxes? NYC and other states just roll out garbage laws to extract money out of regular people through fines and other “hidden fees” simply for owning a vehicle. I agree, cyclists should be held to the same standard in following traffic laws and fined accordingly when they endager peoples lives.

        Two can play this game.

      • Woody

        Johnny, Read it again. Nobody said drivers don’t pay property and income taxes.

        Rob’s bs charge was that bikers do not pay taxes. Of course bike riders pay property and income taxes. But the problem is, for our taxes, we don’t get any “free” (taxpayer-subsidized” parking spaces big enough to hold a Hummer. Instead we get free-loading drivers who think we should get nothing for the taxes we pay.

    • StedyRuckus

      Last i checked, car drivers have free use of the roads and free 8′x10″ plots of public space in which to store their vehicles. Stop hating on bicycles, its about as low-impact as it gets.

  • Homie

    Why not get rid of those free parking anywhere plaques issued to city workers?

  • johnny

    I’m all for reducing or elminating alternate side parking. Most streets don’t need it and feel it’s just a ploy to hand out tickets to unlucky drivers who forget to move their vehicles.

  • Cassidy

    This article seems to me to be completely misguided. Manhattan does not have a parking problem, it has a car problem. Too many people driving in too little space. I’m all for tolls on the east river bridges. I’m also in favor of congestion charges; a fee for driving into the section of Manhattan below 59th st, for example. Really, when it comes down to it, I’m in favor of banning cars as private transportation from Manhattan completely. The time when the rest of us New Yorkers let the car-driving minority dictate the terms is over.

    • DanTe

      The problem is not too many cars. The problem is too many people. And people causes the most pollution and death. Want to solve the problem? Retire all those people in Manhattan.

    • Suzie

      I say no more trucks in Manhattan, no more deliveries in Manhattan, no exceptions in Manhattan

      • karlson

        Ok Suzie – no more trucks in Manhattan? You better get used to not getting any deliveries in your borough and that includes food delivered to your food store, be it bodega or supermarket. Get yourself used to driving to one of the outer burbs to do all your shopping.

        Get real.

      • SAN MAN FROM QUEENS

        HEY SUZIE LONG ISLAND WILL GLADLY ACCEPT YOUR BUSINESS AND TAX DOLLARS

      • Devenio

        Oh Suzie. Poor little stupid Suzie. Do you plan to go to the Brooklyn to by food and clothes and whatever you consume everyday? How do you think all that stuff gets there? The magic delivery elves?

    • Nancy

      Something like 80% of the public space in Manhattan is…ROADS! So no wonder they are an obvious place to use as plazas. Cars don’t belong in Manhattan…People do! And the 2 just dont mix

    • Joe R.

      I’m with you 100% on banning cars from Manhattan. They’re totally unnecessary there given the extensive public transit network. It would reduce congestion for delivery trucks, buses, and emergency vehicles. While we’re at it, let’s require every vehicle used in NYC to be zero emissions by 2020. It’s bad enough the congestion and dangers motor vehicle use causes. The foul air adds insult to injury.

  • Rich Scorce

    I don’t buy Quinn’s ideas for a NY minute. She is pandering for votes and has been Bloomie’s lap dog for all these years.

  • mobi

    Listen folks! These are the stats, facts, rants even; I should not all this but . . .

    Fact: People with cars are in the minority in this city and their cars take up an unfair amount of space.

    Fact: Cars kill between 200 to 300 people a year in this city which is about 200 to 300 times more than bicycles.

    Fact: Car congestion (not bike congestion) costs $13 billion each year.

    Fact: Most cars are huge and take up way too much space. If you do not think they are huge just look at them; even try to pick one up.

    Fact: Cars make the city filthy. Go follow underneath the Brooklyn Queens Expressway, take lots of pictures; show them to your friends to laugh hysterically at all those beautiful zoom zoom zoom car commercials in the pristine countryside straight out of George Orwell’s 1984. Oh yeah, lots of companies that make cleaners, air purifiers, etc. would probably go out of business in this city — I am not sure this is a fact because of trucks, no. 6 heating oil, etc — if there was no car-caused filth.

    Fact: Cities are made to solve the transportation problem by bringing everything close together. Just go outside the city and see how far apart everything is.

    Fact: There are much better, safer, more practical & less costly ways to get around the city than using cars.

    By-the way; attend the event at the New York Academy of Science March 2 on transportation resilience and climate change to find out how transportation systems based on cars will respond to ongoing and accelerating inevitable extreme weather events to come; do remember that little blizzard a while back.

    Fact: Last year about 850,000 cars were put on the streets of Beijing China. This year there is a lottery limiting the number to 240,000. Take a guess why!

    Fact: The high price of food globally has in part been caused by the devastating heat wave in Russia last summer and in part because ethanol is being produced instead of food; and, subsequent accelerating starvation rates. If that massive heat wave had been centered over Chicago the food crisis would be much worse now since the United States produces a lot more food for global consumption and the equivalent amount lost to the heat would have been a lot greater.

    “The great thing about science is that it works even if you don’t believe in it.”
    — Neil deGrasse Tyson, astrophysicist, American Museum of Natural History

    • bf

      Fact: Bloomberg did not get his way with congestion pricing. So, Fact, He cluttered the streets with bike lanes so very few people could ride to work with smelly sweat all over them. Fact many cars and trucks service people in the city like cabs and delivery trucks. Think before you twist the facts

      • Cuckoo McGoo

        FACT: I ride my bike 5 miles to work every day from BK to manhattan, and I show up smelling like roses. Maybe a bike ride is too strenuous for you, fat ass, but its all the more reason to get on one.

  • Bill

    Are you kidding? I own a car and I live on the Upper East Side. It’s some of the most valuable real estate in the world, and I can park right in front of my building for FREE! You can’t do this in most cities. I keep expecting this perk to go away especially considering the budget crunch, and one day it may, but in the meantime NYC is awesome for parking!

  • Roger

    There should be no free parking – and I say that as a resident who parks my car on the street. Most cities require residents to have a permit to park on the street in their neighborhood (only) Why not Manhattan?

    This will free up spots while still catering to residents who will pay a reasonable annual fee. There should be only commercial parking in streets with commercial store fronts so that deliveries can be made easily and without blocking traffic.

    There is then sufficient space for trucks, bicycles, pedestrians and car owners in the city (like myself!) will pay a market fee for the space we take from others.

    Sounds fair to me; I honestly don’t know what the city does not implement. How can anyone argue with it

  • Judy

    On Sunday, we parked on 8th Street between 5th and University. We walked a half-block to the munimeter, put the reciept in the car, went to dinner. When we returned, there was a ticket on the car and the time was one minute after the timestamp on the munimeter reciept. The metermaid printed out the ticket while we were at the munimeter, but didn’t put it on the car until we had placed the reciept on the dash and walked away. What a coward! We are not going to pay this.

    • Tommy

      yes you are !!!

    • karlson

      The meter maid nazis! How they can get away with this is not to be believed.

      • Allan

        (Ignore report comment. I hit the wrong button accidentally.) My friend just got a ticket when he still had two minutes left on the meter when he returned to his car. He paid it because he didn’t want to bother fighting it. How could he prove there was time left? This isn’t the first time it happened. I read about a person who confronted a meter maid wanting to know why he received a ticket when there was still five minutes left. The meter maid told him that he didn’t think anyone would return within the 5 minutes.

    • Michael H.

      Mail in a copy of the MuniMeter ticket with the disputed parking ticket and you should be able to get it dropped.

1 2
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video