02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

News

Teachers Union Furious As NYC Releases List Of Layoffs

Mayor Wants Albany To Let Him Pink Slip Based On Performance

View Comments
In this Jan. 3, 2011 photo, Stephanie Forcer teaches her class at P.S. 262 in New York during a tour by Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Cathie Black. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

In this Jan. 3, 2011 photo, Stephanie Forcer teaches her class at P.S. 262 in New York during a tour by Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Cathie Black. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)

John Montone

Reporting John Montone

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) – A plan for possible teacher layoffs was generating plenty of anger Monday. The City Department of Education released a list of thousands of teachers who’ll get the axe unless Albany kicks in more cash.

EXTRA: List Of Proposed Teacher Layoffs (Excel Document)

WCBS 880′s Rich Lamb: Bloomberg would welcome a check from the UFT


1010 WINS’ John Montone: Bloomberg says we have to downsize intelligently


The doomsday list details the worst case scenario under the mayor’s current plan to make deep cuts to education. It shows exactly how the planned 6,000 teaching jobs will be eliminated.

Around 1,400 positions will simply go unfilled but 4,600 teachers will be formally laid off. Nine schools will lose up to 70 percent of their teachers. Other schools would be untouched.

Almost no subject will go untouched, with art, gym and music likely taking the hardest hits.

 Teachers Union Furious As NYC Releases List Of Layoffs

Michael Mulgrew, UFT President, tells CBS 2 the layoffs will be catastrophic for education in NYC. (credit: CBS 2)

Are the cuts necessary? Leave a comment below

“I don’t know how that process would go. It’s a very scary thing,” said teacher Roberta Rowner back on Feb. 17.

Under the current “last-in-first-out” policy, schools that are new or have recently added a newer crop of teachers will be the hardest hit.

However, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg was pushing for a change, lobbying lawmakers in Albany to allow him to lay off teachers based on performance rather than seniority,  getting rid of teachers who meet several criteria including an unsatisfactory rating and high absentee rates.

“We’re not trying to hurt anybody. I would love to have more teachers in the classroom rather than fewer,” the mayor said on Feb 17.

The teachers unions were fiercely fighting any change to the seniority system.

“We’re looking at a list that is absolutely designed to cause a lot of fear and panic in schools and communities trying to pit teachers against teachers and community against community, and it’s something that is not needed,” said Michael Mulgrew, president of the United Federation of Teachers.

1010 WINS’ John Montone: UFT President Michael Mulgrew calls the layoffs unnecessary


WCBS 880′s Mike Xirinachs: Mulgrew to Mayor Bloomberg: “Knock it off!”


Monday turned into a war of words between Mulgrew and Bloomberg. In the morning outside P.S. 126, Mulgrew accused the mayor of fear mongering and playing politics with the children of New York.

“Knock it off,” Mulgrew said. “Stop playing games, stop politically maneuvering for your own reasons and work with the teachers of this great city.”

“We are not, we are not going to allow the mayor to divide us,” Mulgrew told CBS 2′s Marcia Kramer. “We will speak truth to silly, silly, silly political tricks so that someone can do things in Albany that are very, very bad for all of the children and the people and the working families of New York City.”

Bloomberg later fired back saying, “Any time he wants to write us a check to close what is now a $600 million deficit I’d be happy to cash the check and say thank you, then we still would have to find more money to keep the 6,000 teachers that we’re assuming we’ll downsize,” Bloomberg said.

Related: State Budget Threatens Funding For Students At New York School For The Deaf

The layoffs will be especially hard at one Brooklyn school where half the staff could be pink slipped, reports Kramer.

As she went from class to class at P.S. 682 in Bensonhurst on Monday Principal Josephine Sportella-Giusto said she is haunted by the fear that half the teachers in her school won’t be there next fall unless seniority rules are changed.

It would just cause havoc among our entire school community. Our parents are invested in our teachers. Our teachers know all the students by first and last names we are a tight community,” Sportella-Giusto said.

The principal’s problem is that when her school opened two years ago half the educators she hired were new teachers, either just out of school or making career changes. They have little seniority.

One of those whose jobs would be lost is Theresa Nguyen, who gave up a marketing career and spent her summer taking special training to teach autistic kids here.

“It doesn’t seem right and it would be very unfortunate, both for the children and for myself. This is actually a second career for me and this is a love that I have. I chose to go into teaching because I have a love of children and to be able to teach them,” Nguyen said.

Angry at the idea of teacher layoffs? Happy seniority may be altered? Tell us in the comments section below.

View Comments
  • bill

    This country is heading toward a real class war thanks to the billionaires like Bloomberg. The problem is that there are so many mindless morons out there who actual believe the pablum that the Bloombergs spout. If you don’t believe me, look at how popular Ronald Reagan is today.

  • Greg Boyle

    Greg
    Is it any wonder why we can’t compete with other countries from around the world in regards to education? Whenrver thare is a fiscal shortfall in the buget our education system is always the first to take a hit.Mean while we have these empty suits in the City Council making a base salary of about $112000. a year plus perks for a part-time job and they alone get to vote on their own pay raise.This is why Johnny can;t read!

  • SAL FERRARA

    WHAT THE HELL IS GOING IN THIS WORLD, THE MAYOR OF NEW YORK NEED’S
    TO GET REAL AND BACK OFF, LETTING GO OF TEACHERS, NYPD, NYFD
    WHAT WE NEED IS A BETTER MAYOR, HE REALLY HATES THE TEACHER’S.
    I THINK WHEN HE WAS A CHILD NONE OF THE TEACHER’S DID NOT LIKE HIM.
    I ONLY HAVE TWO WORDS FOR THE MAYOR “GET OUT”

  • Sick of Bloomberg

    You know what, I am a teacher and I have had it. For over 20 years I have beaten my head against the wall to try andfind ways to help your kids. Now, some snot nosed crook named Bloomberg comes along and decides he knows better. Fine, fire us all, and you and he can teach all your children. Let’s see how great you do. Call us in 10 years, let us know how it’s going. If you want us back, the salary will be 3 times what it is now. You union and teacher bashers deserve Bloomberg. You all smell the same: BAD.

  • MMR

    Amazing! And yet, the bankers and Wall Street are all free! Tax cuts for the wealthy have been extended and A-Rod only has to pay $1200 in property taxes. Something is definitely wrong with this picture. You knew when they started opening up these charter schools that Public Education was slowly being destroyed!

  • angelina

    Why are educators the first to go. Why not ask the politician to do some sacrificing once in a while they have the best medical care in the country make decent money. I don’t see politicians sacrificing a thing. What selfish people they are. They are elected to represent us the people not their own pockets. There is something wrong with this picture……

  • zeppel mudder

    He has the nerve to call himself the education mayor. Not one of his chancellors came from the rank and file, they all needed waivers. From the outset, you might not think so, but his plan was to de-educate the students of the city. Just closing schools, was not the answer. That’s why half the students cant tell you anything, about how the gov’t is structured, no technical, or vocational education., and he wants to call himself the education mayor, thats why he wanted mayoral control. A sorry excuse for a mananger, and worse as a mayor.

    • bob

      High school janitors making 100K a year.Great .In many countries teachers are making 10K a year.Here janitors make 10 times more.

  • R

    If the achievement of the students was only based on the teacher’s hard work then go with a new system. If you have a lack of parental participation in not only academic matters, but also in behavioral matters then you will have a poorly performing class no matter what teachers do. Student achievement is not only based on our work, but also the work of parents and the children themselves. You can say it is blaming the victim, but the only constant factors in a child’s education are the child and their parent. Each teacher only has them for less than a year, and if they come with problems that teachers have to solve as well as teach them new material, they will achieve just so much. The parents are the child’s first teachers. Teachers are not the only ones responsible for what and how a child learns, and they should not fear losing their job each year based on the performance of the children.

  • Arbiter of Sanity

    The billionaires among us want us to turn on our teachers and all unionized workers so they can make even more–tax cuts for billionaires, lay off teachers. This country has gone insane.

  • frank perr

    the best thing to do is a 10% cut in all things inc. all employees,starting at the top. to me that would be the fair thing to do. but it’s not a fair world when the mayor is a millionaire, now is it?

  • ellie

    The problem here is who decides which teachers should go, the principal who doesn;t like you or the male principal who only wants young and cute in his school.

    • NotMyProb

      Young and cheap is more like it. Higher paid teachers will be the “first out” under this plan. If anyone thinks that money isn’t driving this issue, they’re fooling themselves. This is not about what is best for the kids.

  • Jay

    Why do we have to lay off the teachers? Whyis education always the first to go and then people wonder why our youth is so troubled? They need to lay off all those useless city workers like the ones that left us with unplowed streets in December. I had a visit from a DEP inspector last week that gave me a duh moment. I said to myself that’s why the city’s crying broke because they have these complete yahoos on the city’s payroll.

  • a teacher

    Im a teacher and I hate the seniority system. I am not in trouble of losing my job, however, I have watched many of the best teachers get let go while mediocre and horrible teachers get to keep their jobs. I understand tenure is to protect us from an administrator that doesnt care for you or doesnt like it when they cant get you in the sack( Lord knows there are plenty of those), but it needs to be reworked. Some of the teachers are there for summers of and the pension and it makes hard working teachers who spend a lot of their own money sick. It is time to change the system!

  • Robert Gillies

    Todays kids are very hard to handle so we should keep the teachers who are the best at it. What we need in the schools is more discipline so the teachers who stay have to be really tough or else the kids will just run over them.

  • Stan

    If the teacher is doing a good job, why fire them. Instead, get rid of the lousy teachers and give the kids the best avalible. They deserve it (a good education).

  • Porgie Tirebiter

    This is sad, but what is going on in NY, Wisconsin, California, etc, etc, etc…it is what it is. We cannot bleed the taxpayers dry anymore. All politicians from both sides of the aisle have kicked the can down the road as far as it can go. It is time to suck it up and do what we have to do. It is time for the U.S. to show some of the backbone that created this country and realize that all publically funded jobs need to be reviewed, and some ‘essential’ ones will have to go. Folks…we honest, truly, can’t ignore it anymore…are BROKE. Can’t borrow anymore. The feds won’t bail out the states, the states won’t bail out the counties or cities. IT truly is the end of the cash cow line.

    This has always been the flaw in the lib/democratic vision of government. In their ideololgy they just assumed that government could magically grow ever bigger. Well, it cannot.

    • Jacob Funk

      Are you a teacher? If not you should not be talking so big, since they too pay their taxes. And by the way they paid a lot to become teachers, did’nt they?

    • Robert Gillies

      I am not a Republican but you are right. There is not an unlimited amount of money available and we are reaching the point where we are broke.

  • bill

    This has nothing to do with the quality of teaching. He wants t save money by getting rid of the higher paid teachers. So if it has nothing to do with money then the same amount of teachers will be laid off by quality of teaching and not tenure. 4600 gee i wonder how many will have time on? Bloomberg Liar? Answer Yes.

    • Miss n

      Ding ding ding! Getting rid of senior teachers means not having to pay out in pensions and health insurance.

  • Barre Flynn

    This reminds me of Bloomberg’s remaking of Lower Broadway where he took one lane of traffic out and made a bus lane of one of the others. Result, a major traffic Jam. It reminds me of Coney Island. He swiped the life out of Coney Island and replaced it with Corporate Presence. Now he will take away parts of education that are important in a child’s development. I don’t like Bloomberg and resented his paid slaves coming to my home during the election time.

  • pat

    THERE IS NO BLOOMBERG BUDGET CRISIS ONLY A BLOOMBERG BUDGET INCOMPETENCE. IT’S TIME TO RECALL BLOOMBERG BEFORE IT’S TO LATE.

  • pat

    RECALL BLOOMBERG, RECALL BLOOMBERG, RECALL BLOOMBERG

    BEFORE HE DESTROYS THIS CITY AND DRAGS US ALL BACK TO THE 19 th CENTURY.

  • cptsoap

    Kids in the US don’t learn anything anyway. Give them all Iphones and let them read.

  • sk

    lets lay off more teachers.. and still complain how bad the schools are. by closing more schools, laying off teachers, funding etc. we are making the schools worse. We are facing budget crisis taht no one is able to us out of. One big solution: more parents need to get off the streets and work. We have hardworking earners who are paying for other parents to send their kids to school. No one seems to address the bigger problem that is effect on the NYC city schools.

  • Teacher

    YCYTeachers rock. I am a teacher and I agree…get rid of the bad ones and keep the good ones…seniortiy or not. But here’s the thing: what’s constitutes a “good” or “bad” teacher? Is it ONE standardized state exam? Or is it a combination of things to get a fair judgment of the teacher? And how exactly will this evaluation be done…over the course of several years? Several months? Several minutes?

    • Bcorp

      Teacher- Come on be honest. The students and the rest of the teachers know who are the good teachers and who are the bad ones. To not face the reality is folly, if you as a teacher are not perceptive enough to evaluate your peers you should not be in this profession.

      • TeacherSouthBX

        Yes, I agree with what you’re saying Bcorp, we might know who are the good teachers and who are the bad teachers but how do we create a guideline to evaluate that>

  • Mark Silvers

    Let’s cut everything equally, get rid of ALL entitlement programs, farm subsidiaries, oil subsidaries , cut 5% from all (police, fire, etc) rather than protecting some. If we’re going to feel the pain, let it be spread equally. This is for city,state,federal.

    • jesus cristos

      This is the answer. Your solution is the right way to go-even on the federal
      level.
      No more foreign aid to other countries is one place to start.
      Cap salaries of individuals to who make too much like sports figures, actors,
      dentists, lawyers, etc.
      If we capped all salaries, that would solve the problem since the middle class
      would have more money to spend by not having to pay these outrageous fees.
      Who says a lawyer should be paid $500 an hour. Is there a law that says that
      and who says a ballplayer should get $10 million a year. Salary caps are
      needed for all jobs: Sports, Wall Street, medical profession, etc. If these people
      do not like it, there is no where to go in the USA and they would have to go
      abroad.

      • Bcorp

        That’s exactly where many of them would go. So if you came up with some great idea, fantastic one, like the absolute cure for cancer. I ask would you then not want to profit huge from this? Perhaps start your own business manufacturing the product, hiring thousands of people, or just keep it to yourself because it would be pointless to do so because of the limit you could make? This concept of being successful is what made America as strong as it was.

    • Jacob Funk

      Mark, I am a Canadian and have been a teacher for 14 years. At present I am not a teacher. Considering the education they need to have and the stress that they live with every school day I know that teacher are not over paid. Why always punish the “middle class and give more to the multi millionares!

  • Unions-Blah!

    Go to the Times Herlad Record for Southern Orange County, NY and go to page 11 of todays (Monday 2/28/11) and read the article about NYC teachers and pay and Union duties, can them all!!!!!!! Enough is enough. To all you Union people in the public sector, get it though your thick skulls you work for us, the taxpayers!!!!!!!!! We are your bosses, we own you butts!

    • MYOB

      Buddy you couldn’t do thier jobs for one day. I work in a school. I know what these teachers have to put up with. Yeah we work for you. Damn hard.

    • Devenio

      @Unions-Blah! You ignorant fool. Unions are the reason you work an 8 hour day and not a 20 hour day. Unions are he reason you have a fair wage. Unions are the reason you have health care. Unions are the people. Unions are a collective of working people who have a voice in the goings on in the country. The corporations would love to get rid of the voice of the people. Its the only way the average Joe can have a say on the government. Also, do you really think unions are the ones who made these cities broke?

      • Trishe

        YES!!!! UNION ARE THE CAUSE!!!

    • jesus cristos

      Police are part of unions as well.
      How about canning all police.
      So, if they all quit and you get mugged- have a nice mugging.

      • Homie

        Not all police are in the union genius

1 2 3
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video