NY Man Jailed After Bringing Beer To DWI Hearing

MONTICELLO, N.Y. (CBSNewYork/AP) — Perhaps he was using it as evidence … against himself?

A 49-year-old  Sullivan County man was sent to jail without bail Monday after authorities said he showed up an hour and a half late for a court hearing on a felony DWI charge. If that wasn’t bad enough, Keith Gruber was intoxicated and was carrying an open can of Busch beer and had four more cans in a bag when he went through the courthouse security check, police said.

Gruber, of Swan Lake, appeared Monday before Sullivan County Judge Frank LaBuda, who asked him if he enjoyed his “liquid lunch,” The Middletown Times Herald-Record reported. Gruber said he did, then said he was sorry. LaBuda sent him to jail with no bail.

Gruber, who has prior DWI convictions, was arrested on Dec. 27 in the town of Liberty and was out on $30,000 cash bail.

Can you believe a man brought beer to his DWI court hearing? Comment below


One Comment

  1. Cowboy Roy says:

    I grew up with this guy. He is an incredible guitar player, and has more talent in his pinky than most of us do in our whole body. I hope he works through it. There are others that deserve prison more.
    Get out quick Bro!

  2. kendra says:

    i hate to say it but that man has a very serious condition of alcohalisem and that is just plain old sad…..cause he really has a very serious poroblem and the judge needs to send him to rehab not jail cause that is not going to help him in any way shape or form as you can clearly see…

    1. ml says:

      He has been to rehab many times…sad …he is a very, very, very talented guitarist. He just can’t leave alcohol alone. 30 days in rehab and he will drink as soon as he is out. I hope someone will really try and help him as he can’t seem to control this. He is a very nice guy and somewhere he deserves to get better. It is true what Cowboy Roy said about his talent. He has played with MAJOR bands but the drink always brings him down.

  3. serenity says:

    Being a recovering Alcoholic of 15 years at one time behavior like this seemed perfectly normal. In his sick mind he probably thought no one would even notice. The key word here is SICK and thats what the true problem is here. Throwing him in jail is what most peoples first thought usually is in what should be done with him, but don’t sick people go to doctors? hopefully this will be the straw that allows him a moment of clairity and this mentally sick soul will be aloted his due chance at RECOVERY lets try saying a prayer instead of prosicute good day to all!!

  4. Anonymous says:

    A standard condition of bail in a DWI case is drug and alcohol conditions. Consuming alcohol openly in front of the Judge presiding over a case is an obvious violation of that condition and the Judge had every right to put him in jail.

  5. DR. MENGLE,GOT TWINS? says:


  6. Warren Shelmidine says:

    It was a hearing not a trial…………..late , drunk thus unable to assist in his defense, judge had every right to throw his ass in jail till such time he is sober enough to participate in his defense.

  7. Warren Shelmidine says:

    First no one found him guilty of anything it’ wasa hearing. If he was intoxicated in the courtroom then the Judge has the right and duty to have him held w/o bail till such time he is sober enough to assist in his defense.

  8. Viper says:

    If it was legal for the guy to purchase beer it’s a travesty of justice to imprison him for consuming his purchase. Accordingly murder is then legal as long as it’s not done in public. States are run by hypocrites who milk the populace with their “legal” lotteries but don’t allow gambling. Just another example of Uncle Sam holding you by the balls.

  9. Alan Foos says:

    He could get a good government job in Montana.

  10. Sir Omar says:

    This is what happens when black people have access to crack. Take away his crack and his freedom and save the lives of countless citizens in poor neighborhoods.

    1. Omar, FTW says:

      Your mom doesn’t mind having access to my crack, yo.

  11. C. Sheen says:

    I need to party with this guy

  12. 1608 says:


  13. Skip says:

    fresh as in you are an idiot omar

  14. JudgeJoeBrown says:

    File for a retrial on the grounds the defendant was impaired and not able to understand the gravity of the charges levied against him.

  15. Sal says:

    Busch beer? White Trash

    1. Sal says:

      Sorry, that was redundant.

  16. harlem going h.a.m. says:

    he’s an accident waiting to happen, crash dummy in the flesh

  17. Market says:

    His actions where a Silver Bullet (for lack of better words) to send him to jail. Exactly where he wanted to go. Three full meals a day, roof over his head and medical care. Not so stupid if you ask me. But hey, I just work for a living, what do I know !

    1. Market is a liar says:

      If you work y r u posting comments at 3:16 PM on Tuesday?

      1. Skip says:

        not everyone works 9 to 5 moron

      2. RAncid says:


  18. Kory Stone says:

    How stupid! It not just white people OMAR.

    1. Kory is a halfwit says:

      Kory, I can’t be sure but I think Omar might just be joking. Lighten up.

  19. BigEz says:

    @ Omar – your such a funny guy. You should consider becoming a comedian. Your material is so fresh and original.

    1. Omar says:

      Fresh as a summer’s eve, or fresh as in “Dag, yo, that girl is fresh!”?

  20. joe smoothie says:

    A nice cold beer sounds pretty good now

  21. badman says:

    sometimes life seems like one big episode of The Simpsons

  22. Mr. Armenia says:

    Wait, this guy can’t be white, can he?!

  23. Mike says:

    Did you miss this part ? Gruber, who has prior DWI convictions, you worry about what the Judge said How about we get him off the road before he kills someone or him self.

    1. Mike is illiterate says:

      If a secod grader wrote this incoherently I would have them try again.

      1. Richard Cabeza says:

        Secod grader? Try again, Mr. Literacy

      2. Skip says:

        And who gave you the authority to have one of your classmates try again?

  24. Ima Soused says:

    I said this years ago: price of beer is too damn high!

  25. Moral Truth says:

    The judge had no right talking this way.
    The judge is violating Mr. Gruber’s civil rights and that’s the moral truth.

    1. C.J. says:

      A lot of times judges abuse their authority.

    2. Moral Truth is clueless says:

      Exaclty what was improper about the judge’s comment?

  26. seriously? says:

    lock him up for good and take away his license before he kills someone!

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE