cbs-2 wcbs-880 wfan 1010WINS-logo_header

Yankees

Keidel: Yankees’ Rafael Soriano Is No Mariano

Share this
9 comments
Rafael Soriano (credit: Nick Laham/Getty Images)

Rafael Soriano (credit: Nick Laham/Getty Images)

By Jason Keidel
» More Columns

45 saves have an odd echo in a hollow dome in a football state. Not the same theater or theatrics of any 8th inning in New York. The cap can be a little tight when you don the “NY” on your dome.

Rafael Soriano is learning this. And the early signs don’t speak well of his vital signs. From Carl Pavano to Bobby Bonilla, we could list at least 50 otherwise fine players who grappled with the Big Apple.

Unless a doctor diagnoses otherwise, the problem with Soriano isn’t his body but rather his brain. On top of his bombs on the bump he’s already bailed on the media (and his team) by ducking out the back door after he blew a game a few weeks ago. Brian Cashman, who didn’t want Soriano, allegedly corrected the problem. But he should not have to.

Beyond the pressure of saving games, a task too tall for many talented pitchers, Soriano is saddled with each inning being italicized in the Bronx, as opposed to that lemon of a park named after orange juice, freckled with about 15,000 fans every night. With all due respect to the Rays – who have won over 90 games with a microscopic payroll – there’s only a fraction of the friction when playing in Tampa.

Soriano is learning that we burn the back of baseball cards when entering New York, as deeds west of the Hudson are hardly precursors to pitching in pinstripes. Few players – like Derek Jeter and Rivera – are able to bask in Broadway’s glow without burning in its glare.

He can make this moot by getting hot in May and beyond. But when a club asks the aristocracy to drop two grand on courtside seats they expect a return on the investment. Three outs are not too much to ask for a man making too much money for his role. He can embrace his role or roll over. He’s chosen the latter so far, and a 7.84 ERA and 1.94 WHIP makes him a whipping boy, particularly at his wage.

Soriano is not making $10 million for saves as much as serendipity. Had the Yankees not whiffed on Cliff Lee and Andy Pettitte not gone out to pasture, they wouldn’t have looked twice at Soriano because they wouldn’t need him. Yet he’s pitching as though the burden of all the team’s offseason misfires are on him.

The Yankees hope to party like it’s 1996, truncating games to six innings from their starters while their nuclear bullpen slams the door. Sounds great when it works. Since baseball has gelded the starting pitcher, essentially saying six innings is all a young man can throw despite a century of evidence to the contrary, there’s an inordinate premium on premium relievers. Soriano was supposed to be a luxury, a toy for the Steinbrenner war chest already overflowing with overpaid players. But he’s making us miss Kerry Wood (2.17 ERA and 1.08 WHIP this year), whom the Yanks could have signed for less than half the price ($1.5 million pitching for Cubs).

Soriano has a simple job: get three outs in one inning. Not even the ninth inning. The consensus was that he took the job because no one can take the immortal Mariano Rivera’s place in the pen. That’s true. And he’s also making closer’s cash. But it may also say something about his mettle, that you can count on him when the games don’t count.

Yes, it’s April, a mutinous month of rain and cold. But it gets cold in October, too, and even colder for the setup man if he doesn’t settle down.

Feel free to email me: Jakster1@mac.com

www.twitter.com/JasonKeidel

Can Soriano handle the NYC heat? Let us know in the comments below…

Share this
9 comments

9 Comments

bk

Just let Cashman do his job.

April 29, 2011 at 2:46 pm

Kurt Spitzner

That is what the issue was here with Soriano as Cashman clearly did not do his homework or listen to his peers when making this awful decision.Had he done his job then Soriano would not be an issue right now and thats a fact!

April 30, 2011 at 4:51 am

dp

Terrible signing.

April 29, 2011 at 11:44 am

JK

Everyone talked about how great his deal was because he can opt out. Do you think someone else, after seeing this, will pay him more than $10 million next year?

April 29, 2011 at 10:32 am

Kurt Spitzner

NO WAY ON GOD’S GREEN EARTH!AND IF SOMEONE DOES THEN ALL THAT SHOWS IS NOBODY IN BASEBALL HAS LEARNED ANYTHING FROM THE PAST AND IT SERVES THEM RIGHT ALTHOUGH ITS THE FANS WHO ALWAYS SUFFER THE WORST!

April 29, 2011 at 10:46 am

JK

He just looks shaken as soon as he hits the mound. This isn’t Tampa.

April 29, 2011 at 11:23 am

Kurt Spitzner

PS I THINK TEAMS WOULD SIGN FRANKIE FLOWERS BEFORE THEY WOULD SIGN SORIANO,ANY DAY!

April 29, 2011 at 10:50 am

Kurt Spitzner

PS CAN SORIANO HANDLE THE NYC HEAT? I THINK NOT! IF HE CAN’T HANDLE THE 8TH HOW WELL WILL HE FARE IN THE 9TH??????DOESN’T BODE WELL IN MY OPINION….

April 29, 2011 at 10:20 am

Kurt Spitzner

TOO MANY OVERPAID CRY BABIES HAVE COMPLAINED THAT THEY ARE USED TO THE ADRENALIN OF THE 9TH INNING AND THEREFORE EVEN THOUGH THEY ARE PAID A KINGS RANSON CANNOT MUSTER UP THE STRENGTH OR INTESTINAL FORTITUDE TO DO WHAT THEY SHOULD BE PROUD TO IN THE FIRST PLACE.THEN YOU ADD NY TO THE EQUATION IT JUST SEEMS TO BLOW MOST PLAYERS CLEAN OUT OF THE WATER ALTOGETHER.
AS FAR AS REPLACING MARIANO RIVERA GOES ALL I CAN SAY IS GOOD LUCK WITH THAT!

April 29, 2011 at 10:17 am

Listen Live!

Yankees Radio Network

wcbs yankeesradionetwork Yankees Radio Network
WCBS 880 – Home of the Yankees Radio Network
Listen to every Yankees game on WCBS 880

NY Yankees Audio

Brian Cashman - With Mike Francesa

Mike Francesa February 20, 2012

Yankees GM Brian Cashman talks Spring Training with Mike

Sweeny Murti - With Mike Francesa

Mike Francesa February 20, 2012

Sweeny Murti joins Mike with a Yankee Report

Mariano Rivera Meets the Media

WFAN February 20, 2012

The Yankees closer speaks to the media for the first time this spring and hints that he may retire after the season.

Kim Jones with Joba Chamberlain

WFAN February 14, 2012

The Yankee reliever talks about his health and gives some advice to Jeremy Lin about instant fame in New York City.

Brian Cashman - With Mike Francesa

Mike Francesa January 25, 2012

Yankee GM Brian Cashman talks with Mike about the latest Yankee news

Jorge Posada - With Mike Francesa

Mike Francesa January 24, 2012

Former Yankee Jorge Posada announced his retirement, and he joined Mike shortly after

Steve Somers with Sweeny Murti

Steve Somers January 7, 2012

Sweeny breaks news about the future of Jorge Posada with Steve.

Sweeny Murti - With Mike Francesa & Kim Jones

Mike Francesa December 7, 2011

Sweeny Murti joins Mike & Kim with a Yankee Report from Winter Meetings

Jon Heyman - With Mike Francesa & Kim Jones

Mike Francesa December 7, 2011

WFAN/CBSsports.com's Jon Heyman joins Mike & Kim from the Winter Meetings

Sweeny Murti - With Mike Francesa

Mike Francesa December 5, 2011

Sweeny Murti joins Mike with a Report from Winter Meetings
More Yankees Audio

MLB Headlines

Yankee Stadium Guide

yankeestadium 140x93 Guides to NY Stadiums

Visiting The House That Steinbrenner Built? Here is a guide to help make the most of your trip.