02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

News

Group Stages ‘Smoke-In’ At Brighton Beach To Protest NYC’s New Smoking Ban

View Comments
Smoking (credit: AP Photo/Peter Morrison)

Smoking (credit: AP Photo/Peter Morrison)

BROOKLYN, NY (1010 WINS) – It’s not a sit-in, but a smoke-in. Smokers intentionally broke the law by lighting up in protest of New York City’s new smoking ban.

The city’s  sweeping outdoor smoking ban went into effect Monday and prohibits smokers from lighting up in public parks, beaches and pedestrian plazas.

The group, Citizens Lobbying Against Smoker Harassment or CLASH, held the rally Saturday to protest the ban at Brooklyn’s Brighton Beach.

1010 WINS’ Terry Sheridan has more on the smokers’ demonstration.


The law was passed as a way to help prevent second-hand smoke. But Mayor Michael Bloomberg said he expects New Yorkers to be the ones enforcing the law by giving smokers a friendly reminder.

Audrey Silk of CLASH said she worries about this self-policing aspect of the ban.

“Citizen on citizen, inform on your neighbor,” Silk said. “They’re inviting hostile confrontations. I’m not encouraging violence or suggesting it or condoning it, but human nature is when you have confrontation in the street, arguments get heated and things will happen.”

If caught breaking the law, a smoker could be fined between $50 and $250.

The protest was held at 2 p.m. on the boardwalk at Brighton 6th Street.

What do you think of the protest? Sound off below in our comments section.

View Comments
  • john anthony

    i can find a place in the park that is away from people, but is alright for people talk on the cell phone so loud in restarunt or keep there dogs next to them while i eat, if the mayor is so worried about smoking than why do we have cigar bar’s and not cig bar’s people really think they are going to stop smoking, half your children smoke and you don’t even know it keep giving them money for cigs someday go to 75st and first and watch all the kids i didn’t make pick up a cig you did by not paying attention before you mind my business clean up your own backyard

  • Kenneth Brownlee

    I would ask each and every smoker how they would feel if I took
    away their pack of smokes for 12 hours,they would be insane craving
    for a smoke ,impossible to do anything but seek out a ciggie in the army
    when we interrogated a prisoner of war who smoked we knew we were in
    the catbird seat taking their cigs away and they when they went nuts craving
    the nicotine in a fit ,we lit up in front of them for the show,always from a new
    pack of Pall Mall as that red package was really looking good ,we offered
    them one smoke to talk a little and the whole packfull to tell us a lot .
    It worked,one of the oldest tools around equal to smack for a junkie.
    ,it will be banned ,one day totaly banned.

    • Michael J. McFadden

      Kenneth Brownlee wrote, “when we interrogated a prisoner of war who smoked we knew we were in the catbird seat taking their cigs away and they when they went nuts craving the nicotine in a fit ,we lit up in front of them. ”

      Interesting Kenneth. You DO realize I hope that you just confessed to a crime under the Geneva Conventions that require the provision and access to tobacco for POWs, right?

      - MJM

      • badman

        not during interrogation loser

    • justme

      I would feel fine. I can go without a cigarette for longer than 12 hours. I smoke when I feel like it.

  • Dale Auburn

    Again, my right to pollute your air outweighs your right to breathe. Deal with it.

  • M. Miuphy Keller

    To Mike J. Macfact done
    The smokers rights BS is so passe.and not
    about big brother or civil rights .
    You guys get disease that we all pay for ,you take up space
    with your stroke and cancer and hardening of the arteries from
    Tobacco at the hospital ,you force with your sad addiction all our
    health costs to go up from HMO to Nursing homes .You all bring
    on this disease to all of us ,one way or the other.
    The total ban on smoking cigarettes down the road is coming but we
    first must pray that our Governments,local and Federal make the cost
    of smoking so high that these neurotic idiots that chose to still smoke
    will be punished.,that’s the idea ,in 20 years I would bet that all use of
    Tobacco is eliminated yeah for health reasons.
    Our city has a TV commercial running that shows the continuous pain of
    having to find 1 breath for smoker suffering Emphysema the pre cursor
    of fatal lung cancer or heart attack. Morphine does not help one bit in
    advanced lung cancer pain,
    Visit those dying from smoking disease.,try the Vet’s hospital on First Avenue
    and see what other’s do .

    • littlestar

      It sure is tuff to quite, my friend. Thanks for calling me a neurotic idiot. Idiot.

      • zee

        It’s tough to quit but why does everyone else have to inhale your poison!

      • Luna Tique

        You are a neurotic addict. Idiot

      • littlestar

        Zee – we are talking about outdoor second hand smoke. It does nothing to harm you. This is in your mind, evev if you just get a small wiff of it.

    • justme

      ALL people get diseases that WE ALL pay for in one way or another. Does your city also have commercials that show what it’s like to suffer from OTHER diseases? Morphine doesn’t help in the final stages of MANY fatal illnesses, not just lung cancer.
      This IS about Big Brother. Now go get your brown shirt so you’ll be probably dressed when you go to inform on your neighbor.

  • Youvebeenhad

    I can only imagine that it is the same people who approve of this idiotic ban that are ok with granny and the kids being groped at the airport. What ever happened to NY Chutzpah?

  • Michael J. McFadden

    This has got to be one of the most blatantly irresponsible regulations and approaches to regulation enforcement that I have ever seen. For Bloomberg and the NYC DoH to call for what boils down to “Citizen Vigilante Enforcers” in a city known for having 8 million walking powder kegs should be seen as actual CRIMINAL irresponsibility. . . . . . .

    When antismoking nut jobs feel they now have they now have authority from the city to assault smokers and violence and injuries ensue, will it be the NYC taxpayers who end up having to foot the lawsuit bills that come pounding down? Fat chance that Bloomberg will pay for them out of his own pocket. . . . . .

    The health issues of outdoor smoking are nonexistent. See http://wispofsmoke.net/satire.txt to get an idea of how the studies are conducted that the wack jobs hold up to support bans like this. The littering issues on beaches (according to environmental officials in California who’ve studied the problem there) may actually NOT from the beach smokers, but from the city smoking ban in general as smokers are thrown out to the sidewalks, butts get littered and washed into the storm drains, and then wind up washing back in from the ocean. . . . . . .

    There is a reason why societies usually avoid minor regulations of life and discourage citizens from even “gently” trying to enforce such things, and as I said above, I think it’s actually criminally irresponsible for the city to have gone down this path. . . . . . . .

    Michael J. McFadden,
    Author of “Dissecting Antismokers’ Brains”

  • Dee

    For The Anti Smoking Cartel

    smoking is good for you

    http://www.forces.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=354&t=1283

  • JC

    I would have had the fire department standing by with a giant hose and sprayed water onto anyone who chose to lit up. If you idiots can pollute my air, the law should allow me to spray that dumb looking cancer stick out of your mouth. Go smoke in your own house.

    • skalley99

      And next the ban will be about perfume. I dont like the smell of cologne or perfume ,could get a ban on them.

      • Gerald Waldman

        Yup, I have asthma and I’m allergic to some perfumes, so it IS a health problem. Why should I have to feel like I’m drowning and perhaps go to the emergency room/hospital because I can no longer breath because you want to smell like something other than a human! BAN PERFUME NOW! A LAW MUST BE PASSED. Think of all the children with asthma who face this everyday! — NO, I’m not kidding. If you can ban my second hand smoke, I should be able to ban your second hand perfume!

    • t

      yes because the fire department got nothing better to do… OH.. bloomberg closing the fire departments, you think they gonna help him with the ban? shhhhiet they’re lighting it up!

      btw the cancer stick is not in your mouth and if ur on a beach or a park next to someone smoking….. MOVE or grow some

    • Gerald Waldman

      @ JC — That’ll be next, a smoking BAN in the private home! It’s all ready banned in numerous apartment buildings and co-ops. I mean THINK OF THE CHILDREN, even if you don’t have any children at home!

  • Duckie

    I say repeal the smoking ban and add another $3 a pack tax. Allow restaurants and bars to allow smoking again if they pay a $500 a week “health tax.” Solve the budget problem and find out how important it is for people to continue to use their cancer sticks in one move. That’s what I would do.

    • RichieT

      My father used to smoke two packs a day.. He quit overnight. It was because of the sales tax they put on cigarettes. It was one cent a pack. It was a tax he had the right to pay it, or not pay.

  • Paul Kohloff

    this mayor wants everything his way ,he sucks no guns no cigarettes were law abiding citizens and hes turning us into criminals. whats next ,? i guess what ever bloomy wants like sheep going to slaughter.just like the nazi’s did to the jews . he sucks

    • Lisa Fender

      I agree..I wish New York would get rid of the ass!

  • Ban Gasz

    Stopping smoking is for the children ,if yah know what i mean.
    Kids copy their family.,If tobacco were put on the market today
    it would never be a legal drug.It is time to see these smoking addicted
    nutjobs removed they can live in another state where they can blow
    smoke in each others face and cough to each other ,deep breath anyone?

  • Non Smoker Lovin it.

    Poor Ciggie puffers they are such sorry addicts they
    have to defend their drug addiction even now when the majority
    of people don’t smoke anymore or have ever started.
    Let’s make a cigarette $3 each.
    Nothing worse to see these fools doing this sucking down of smoke
    and related poisons to their lungs
    and arteries and calling it freedom ,who wrote this sad comedy?

    • littlestar

      Yes many of us are sorry addicts, you are right.

      • Luna Tique

        Yes you sorry addicts cost us taxpayers billions of dollars a year in health care and lost production yearly.

    • Gerald Waldman

      @ Luna Tique — Most smokers are taxpayers too, paying billions of dollars in cigarette taxes and sales tax per year. If we all stop today, how are you going to cover the lost taxes?

      • jayne

        Maybe you smokers should give that a try. Don’t worry. Bloomie will find a way.

  • remo

    Divide and conquer. That’s what our city’s quasi-leadership has done. To a formerly unified city: We all need to wake up and see who has blown smoke in our faces.

  • SAMMY

    I see all the alcohol lovers responding here lol
    what a joke – go drink and drive and kill someone innoccent thats ok
    Eventually, when this mayor is gone and someone with a brain realizes that alcohol is as bad as smoking and taxes it accordingly, then we will see all the SCREAMERS

    • ljm

      Seriously, this is what you come up with? How is drinking and driving okay? It’s ILLEGAL. You drink and drive and get caught and you pay dearly. See how it works? Good, lord. Are you even thinking?

      • justme

        See, Sammy, ljm is screaming and making excuses already! See how they twist your words around? Yes, it’s ILLEGAL, but people do it ANYWAY.

        By the way, NY is seriously considering raising the alcohol tax. Go to:

        evalumetrics.org/files/Estimated_Effects_of_Equalizing.pdf

        NY, according to the report, is in a fiscal crisis and needs more money. They say drinkers need to pay their fair share to help pay for the consequences of their drinking, i.e. medical costs (whoda thunk!!) This equalization tax will help NY raise several hundred million in revenue per year.

        What! Did you think NY FORGOT about you bar patrons and at home drinkers who like to kick back with a nice brew or glass of wine to relax after a hard day’s work? Nope. They’re going after YOU now. How does it feel?

  • Smoker

    SMOKE! SMOKE! SMOKE! I’LL BE THERE CHEERING THEM ON HAHAHAH LOVE IT. If you don’t like that I smoke, don’t come near me when I’m smoking. This is my body and I have every right to do what I want with it. This law is the start to a slippery slope to the government telling what you can do next in the privacy of your own home.

  • happyquitter

    they dont need to .. smokers will die early on their own anyways..remeber.. poison kills.. personally they should add more cyanide to cigs.. speeds up the process..why die a long lingering death leaving a nasty looking corpse.. go with the cyanide at least you’ll die pretty

  • pughpah

    Smokers are selfish arse holes with no regard for anybody else. Peeps are tired of inhaling 2nd hand smoke, especially those of us out there jogging or just strolling along and enjoying the sunshine and fresh air. Maybe the city should designate
    specific areas in all parks for them to smoke. smokersodysseycom

    • Joseph McLellon

      You people are Idiots, you stand a better chance at contracting asbestosis from the brake shoes on the vehicles constantly applying brakes in the city, than damage from second hand smoke. Have the exhaust of the vehicle of your choice examined, what to bet on which poses the greatest health risk? Here is a simple test preformed in W.Va. 2 chain smoking hillbillies and 2 non smoking left wing , liberal, organic nut jobs from NY city played cards in a 2 car garage with all doors closed, next morning nut jobs from NY City were angry and coughing, but all survived, Bubba and Cletas were laughing , next night we used 2 chain smokers from NY city [we already knew the end result no sense losing a couple good men from the hills, ] and the same 2 left wing ,liberal nut job non smokers, same garage, add 1 BMW idling, all doors closed, can you educated left wing nut jobs predict the outcome, they all died, what a shock. Girls it is not all about you, whats next a ban on farting in public, that can be very offensive, I have a better idea, lets ban cell phones and texing in publick, I don’t want to hear your conversation in a checkout line, it is very rude to talk on the phone while purchasing anything, text idiots get so involved in their distraction, I phone or what the F. ever, they walk out in traffic, good riddence, cause major accidents on the highway, and just generally annoy people, how ya like them apples, get your heads out girls again it is not all about you.

    • justme

      Yes, that “fresh air”, which in NY looks like a dark haze in the sky, doesn’t bother them a bit. It’s people who might be enjoying themselves that bother pughpah the most.

  • Majic

    I will make video and photo for those who smoke in
    new york city parks and beaches, to post on Utube and send
    to the city.

    • t

      amen brother

    • t

      haha! we’ll be stars guys! light em up!

      because people working for the city are nonsmokers….

    • justme

      You’d have made a perfect Nazi informer. Too bad WWII is over.

    • RumbleDoll Daly

      You are kidding, right?

  • buttsout

    What’s next, a ‘skinny jeans’ in to protest anti-skinny jeans efforts?

    http://bofadeez.blogspot.com/2011/05/new-jean-blues.html

    LAME!

  • DanTe

    I don’t mind them smoking. It’s the stupid garbage (butts) that they drop all over the place. When nobody else is around, I make the idiot eat it.

  • Dale Auburn

    My right to pollute your air outweighs your right to breathe. Deal with it.

    • Luna Tique

      My right to punch you in the face outweighs your right to have teeth. Deal with it.

      • Gerald Waldman

        @ Luna Tique — That;s assault and can get you jail time. Do it to ME and I WILL file charges against you, you idiot.

  • David George

    OUTSIDE GIVE ME A BREAK. That is ridiculous..

  • David George

    Liberals in pursuit of ruining the American ideal.. Power Freaks. But “,it’s for the children”.

  • kendra

    they need to band smoking altogether cause it makes me very sick personally and causes me internal problems.

  • nyc

    Hopefully the nicotine police won’t open fire ,with live amo on the demonstrators !

    • badman

      that would be awesome

1 2 3
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video