Keidel: Derek Jeter Is Mr. 3000

By Jason Keidel
» More Columns

I was supposed to discuss four topics with Lori Rubinson during our weekly Sunday evening chat on WFAN, but after taking our whacks at the LeBron piñata, we only had time for three.

The fourth – and perhaps most interesting – is why Derek Jeter’s march toward 3,000 hits isn’t getting New York nearly as juiced as we thought it would. There are several reasons for this.

It didn’t take a Mensa member to deduce that Derek (if he stayed healthy, the eternal proviso for any record) would swat 3,000 hits. His consistent career arc of 206 hits per season, nearly slump-proof batting average of .312, sans splashy power numbers, make him a low risk for missing the mark. And, before yesterday, he hadn’t been on the DL since 2003.

And thus it gives his record the feel of formality. Since we knew he’d be here, his arrival surprises no one.

3,000 hits aren’t sexy, even when the sexiest players hit them. Chicks still dig the long ball, and always will. A singles hitter, even one as handsome as Jeter, is still a singles hitter.

Tyler Kepner recently wrote a piece in The New York Times about the cool reception Roberto Clemente got after his 3,000th hit in Pittsburgh against (of course) the Mets. After getting the big hit against Jon Matlack, a whopping 13, 117 fans freckled Three Rivers Stadium, barely saluting the immortal, who tipped his cap at second base and moved on. The scene was so muted that half the Mets didn’t even know Clemente was that close to the milestone.

David Maraniss, who wrote a biography about Clemente, told the Times that there were several reasons beyond the statistical boredom of 3,000 hits, including the town’s dedication to college football, the ascending Steelers, and perhaps some latent bigotry toward the first team to field an entirely black and Hispanic baseball team. (I have a problem with the final assertion, but that’s for another time.)

Jeter will surely get more love from a team and a town in love with him since 1996, but it won’t even match the blizzard of confetti LeBron James and Dwyane Wade got in Miami before they played a single game together. It’s just hard to get fired up over a base hit.

And it’s not like the Yankees have been a woeful franchise for the last century and Jeter’s achievement serves as a distraction from stumbling squad. The Yankees are supposed to have all the records.

You could argue that the Yankees have fielded the five greatest players in history. (You’d lose the argument, but you could make it and not be laughed out the building.) And since Jeter isn’t one of them his feat doesn’t fly among the myriad memories and pennants. The fact that no Yankee has done it doesn’t speak to Jeter’s superiority over Babe Ruth, but rather to an astonishing aberration that the greatest team in the history of team sports doesn’t have a hitter with 3,000 hits. (And if the number were that important, why doesn’t a Yankee have it?)

And if you think about it, Jeter’s not even breaking a record. Indeed, he will join Clemente at No. 28 on the all-time hit list. So it makes you wonder what the big difference is between 2,999 and 3,001. Sure, baseball trades on stats, but we tend to pay more attention when it means more.

Finally, the feat feels incongruous. What do we love about Jeter? What does the marquee flash over his silhouette?


Jeter isn’t about 3,000 hits anymore than he’s about 500 home runs. Jeter was never judged, in any strict sense, by statistical bona fides. Jeter is about his head-first leap into the stands in 2004 (I was at that game, oddly enough), gathered by and propped up by his grateful and faithful fans, climbing back into fair territory with his face bloody, swollen and scarred. Jeter is about the flip in Oakland in 2001. Jeter is about running right, spearing the ball, and his leaping pirouette as he slings the ball back to first.

Jeter is about getting praise from Curt Schilling (who never has nice things to say about anyone) and the rest of Red Sox Nation. Jeter is about, if you believe in these things, being a True Yankee. He’s about timing, and the Gods, knowing he wouldn’t reach his mark at home pinched his foot and put him on the shelf, where he may resume his quest on June 29, perhaps getting 3,000 at Citi Field, a de facto home game, particularly with Yankee fans gobbling up tickets from fed-up Mets fans whose mantra, “Wait ‘til next year” is becoming a yearly refrain.

For some players, the 3,000th hit is their portal to Cooperstown. But Jeter was getting into the Hall of Fame with 2,500 hits. He is, in the spirit of his single-digit predecessors, about bling, the rings and trophies. So since we’ve argued that Jeter is measured in nuance, we can’t now redefine him 16-years deep into his career. And Jeter is so publicly sterile that he expresses no emotion over the mark. And if he doesn’t care, why should we?

No doubt more than one man cave has Derek Jeter memorabilia lathering its walls, but never in Jeter’s halls. That is part of his charm, why No. 2 is No. 1 to so many.  He’ll get his big hit, tilt his helmet to his fawning fans, greet his adoring teammates as they drip onto the field, and the focus on stealing second. There will be a game to win.

Feel free to email me:


One Comment

  1. lydia says:

    You see him getting 4,000, dude? That would mean more than the years left on his current contract. Possible, but I doubt he’d do it as a Yankee when you consider the dip in his productivity.
    I am a 27 years old doctor, mature and beautiful.and now I am seeking a good man who can give me real love , so i got a username Andromeda2002 on—–S’E’EK’C’OU’GA’R.C óM—— .it is the first and best clu’b forwealthy people and their admirers. e…you don’t have to be rich ,but you can meet one there ,maybe you wanna che’ck it out or tell your friends !

  2. Paul D says:

    Disturbing film. But Marcia Gay Harden lit up that screen. She was looking mighty fine.

  3. Paul D says:

    If he had admitted his violation to the world when he had the chance at first, all would have been forgiven. But he was stubborn. It’s ironic, but he acted like Cobb in that respect. He was too prideful and has paid dearly for that.

    1. JK says:

      Prideful and stubborn and stupid. And yes, much like Cobb if we’re to take Tommy Lee Jones’s portrayal of him as fact. Brilliant performance. I assume you’ve seen the film.

      I’m not sure he would have been allowed to manage again in any case because he violated the sacred rule. But the HOF would have been a cakewalk.

  4. Paul D says:

    Just makes you realize what an accomplishment it was for Rose to pass Cobb. Now, please no socio-political rebuttals. Rose dug himself that hole he’s in. I understand that. I’m just talking about pure drive- that intangible something that seperates history makers from the rest.

    1. JK says:

      Which goes back to our discussion last week, Paul, about the HOF for Rose. He belongs. And had Giamatti not died – and thus the subsequent push to keep Rose out to honor the former commissioner – Rose would long have been inducted.

  5. Good article. says:

    uh.. He won’t be anywhere near 4000 hits. He has seriously declined offensively. Low 3’s

    1. JK says:

      I concur. Even 3,500 seems like a stretch at this point.

  6. Paul D says:

    this is a legitimate number, not like the team record. Don’t get me wrong, passing the Iron Horse is quite an accomplishment. But 3000 is league wide. I think he’ll reach 3600. But he was a walk-in even before this.

    1. JK says:

      Agreed, Paul. I really don’t see him reaching 4000, particularly since his fall in production feels permanent.

  7. Kurt Spitzner says:

    He’s not done yet so maybe the proper accolades will come when he retires pushing 4000.Why celebrate when its not time yet?

    1. JK says:

      Wow. You see him getting 4,000, dude? That would mean more than the years left on his current contract. Possible, but I doubt he’d do it as a Yankee when you consider the dip in his productivity.

      1. Kurt Spitzner says:

        I don’t think he will hit that many,only that the way he seems to be he will not take anything into account until he is done and then look back.The old thing where you don’t count your chips while they are still on the table cuz theres a plenty time to count them all once the dealing is done.When he is done his career and the way it was conducted will speak for itself!

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE