Religious Protections At Center Of N.Y. Senate Gay Marriage Debate

If Passed, Empire State Would Become Largest State To Have Legislation

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork/AP) — There was marriage drama in Albany on Monday.

A high-powered meeting between Gov. Andrew Cuomo and top lawmakers, ended with same-sex marriage in New York still stuck at the altar, reports CBS 2’s Marcia Kramer.

Demonstrators by the hundreds — both those in favor of same-sex marriage and those opposed — jammed the halls of the capital Monday as lawmakers continued to haggle over language that will protect religious institutions and garner enough support in the Republican-controlled Senate for the bill to pass.

State troopers were called to the Senate chamber floor as the two groups started to merge and talk with each other, but there was no escalation in the jammed marble hallways that turned stifling hot from the people and TV cameras. Most were respectful of each other and kept to their own groups.

1010 WINS’ Al Jones With More On The Dueling Protests In Albany.

Groups led by clergy opposed to same-sex marriage sang hymns such as “Victory is Mine” and prayed in small circles while pro-same-sex marriage advocates countered with “God Bless America” and lined the halls and parlor outside the Senate chamber.

Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos spoke to reporters on Monday afternoon, just moments after a powwow with Gov. Cuomo and Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver.

“We have staff people and members discussing with the governor religious protections. They’re still working on it. Once they’re prepared we’ll let you know what they are,” Skelos told Kramer.

“We’re working to protect the religious protections to make sure that they’re solid and that they will stand. You could have a judge come in and knock out all the religious protections.”

WCBS 880’s Marla Diamond has the latest on the debate.

Still, the demonstrations continued to force the Senate’s hand. The Assembly has already passed the measure and is standing by to pass of the religious protections sought by the Senate as a way of making New York the sixth and largest state to make same-sex marriages legal.

A few senators — including Greg Ball of Putnam County — have said they’re still deciding how they would vote. Some of Ball’s constituents have taken to his Facebook page to pressure him to vote “yes.” Others are asking him not to rush his decision.

The outcome is of huge importance to John Mace and Richard Dorr, an elderly New York couple that wants to marry after being together for 61 years.

“Why not? Why not why complete this relationship?” Mace said. “I come from an Italian family. They’re the marrying kind.”

“The only sanctifying element in a marriage is what the two people bring to it,” Dorr added.

Former New York Giants Super Bowl hero David Tyree was in Albany to oppose gay marriage.

“I want to tell the New York senators it’s not about right and left, it’s about right and wrong. Marriage is an honorable estate not created by government but founded in nature and in God’s nature,” Tyree said.

Sources told Kramer a Senate vote is expected some time this week. Maybe Tuesday; maybe Wednesday; maybe even as late as Thursday.

Reaction on the streets of New York City has been mixed.

“I’m a Christian and I don’t really believe in that. I mean I don’t have a problem with gay people, I do have a lot of gay friends, I wouldn’t support the marriage part,” Millecher Semple, of Jaimaca, Queens, told CBS 2.

“I think they should have the same rights as every other tax paying American,” added Colin Mitchell of the Upper West Side.

Legalizing same-sex marriage has been stalled since last week, when it passed the State Assembly in 80-63 vote. Hundreds of gay rights activists rallied throughout Manhattan Sunday to push for progress on the bill.

“Injustice everywhere is injustice anywhere we need to deconstruct these laws that are unjust and create one that gives everyone the right to marry,” said Jackie Lewis, a gay rights activist.

“God made people gay, so them being allowed to marry is not only a moral right, but it’s a civil right,” Lewis added.

New York Archbishop Timothy Dolan addressed the same-sex marriage issue at Father’s Day mass Sunday.

“I know we’re sort of the David here, up against a Goliath, but we’re not going to give up. That’s what this request for prayers was all about,” Dolan said.

Dolan again stated the belief of the Catholic Church that marriage is defined by a union between a man and a woman.

“Any presumption to redefine that sacred vocabulary, I’m afraid, is at our common peril,” Dolan said.

Do you support the Marriage Equality Act? Sound off in our comments section below…

(TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

More from Marcia Kramer

One Comment

  1. Linda says:

    I am amazed that it passed a Republican Congress. Liberal Republican is an oxymoron. Check out Isaiah 5:20: “Woe to those who call evil good and good evil..” People, wake up and look at the signs!

  2. XXX says:

    The US is the most fundamentalist country in the planet. Muslims are in kindergarten compared to the PhD American Biblical fundamentalism. This is scary!!!

  3. XXX says:

    The US is the most fundamentalist country in the planet. Muslisms are in kindergarten compared to the PhD American Biblical fundamentalism. This is scary!!!

  4. XXX says:

    The US is the most fundamentalist country in the planet. Muslisms are in kindergarten compared to PhD American Biblical fundamentalism. This is scary!!!

  5. littlestar says:

    Hopefully tha Mayans got the math right ! Luv Ya !

  6. littlestar says:

    Oh cowardly and spiteful censor… let me count the ways …….. Luv ya !

  7. marcus says:



  8. marcus says:


  9. J says:

    We have the right to petition our moral and decaying government in favor or more moral decadence, perversion, filth and to tell G O D that we know better. On with perverting the sacred institution of marriage and to h e ll with morals and religious values.

    1. Rodin says:


      New York Daily News
      June 21, 2011

      New Bride Arrested for Biting, Beating Her Husband During Attack Just Hours after Their Wedding

      Bernadette Catan-Keeler was arrested on Sunday morning for beating and biting her husband during an attack just hours after they were married, police said.

      1. As with any institution, each individual marriage is not perfect, but the principles and foundations of marriage are the backbone of our country and family values. So your snarky article is meaningless.

        Marriage is between a man and woman. No number of individuals who want to force their lifestyle on the country can change the meaning of marraige. But, as I’m afraid has now happened, the sanctity and value of marriage will be diminshed for a very long time, if not forever.

        and BTW, this is not an equal rights issue as many cliam. It is about people in an ungodly, immoral lifestyle who have actually won in their efforts to silence and control those who stand on the moral, religious, and traditions of marriage. I said “won” I didn’t say “proven correct”….but unfortunately, the state of NY allowing such redefinitions of marriage have put America squarely on the downhill slide of decay.

  10. Marcus says:

    Being Gay is a Sin, Sin is Evil, God loves everyone but hates sin, so you have a choice NY Senators, Choose today who you will vote for, righteousness or evil. God is watching you . . . and he will reward you accordingly, Amen

    1. Rodin says:

      ONE MORE NUT!!!

      “Thank god I’m an Atheist!” ~ DIEGO RIVERA

      1. marcus says:

        Thank God U are an Atheist??? What business has an Atheist like U thanking God who U dont believe exists? Psalm 14:1, you look more like a CONFUSIONIST to me. One day you will stand be4 God your maker, and what will your story be? Reproductive Organs are for reproduction and Excrement Organs are for EXCREMENT, do not pervert God’s creation, God cannot be mocked.

      2. J says:

        You’re all f u c k ed up. In your own words “thank god.”

      3. Rodin says:

        Need I say more? I think I proved my case, a NUT CASE.

        “A sense of humor, properly developed, is superior to any religion so far devised.”
        ~ TOM ROBBINS

        BTW, excrete where you like, as your religion tells you. It’s fine with me as long as TOU don’t try to tell ME where or how to excrete I should.

    2. Dale Auburn says:

      That doesn’t sound like a GOVERNMENTAL argument against gay marriage.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York


Listen Live