02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

Business

Is Walmart Trying To Buy Its Way Into New York City?

Bloomberg Fires Back At Reporter's Question About Retailer's True Intentions

View Comments
Walmart (file / credit: Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

Walmart (file / credit: Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

kramer

Reporting Marcia Kramer

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) – Is it a genuine gesture or an attempt to buy the city’s good will?

The question was posed to Walmart spokesman Steve Restivo as the giant retailer pledged $4 million to the New York City’s summer youth employment program.  Restivo said there are no strings attached to the pledge.

WCBS 880′s Marla Diamond In Brooklyn


Walmart is seeking approval to build its first New York City store in Brooklyn.

“[It's] no secret that we’re looking for locations across the five boroughs — store sizes small, medium, and large. We don’t have any announced projects yet. We don’t have any leases signed in the city,” Restivo said.

Later, CBS 2′s Marcia Kramer attempted to get Walmart representative Michelle Gilliard to answer the following question: would the retail giant’s generous pledge to create summer jobs for city kids soften resistance to its stores being built here in New York City?

That set Mayor Michael Bloomberg off and what followed was an at times terse back and forth with Kramer.

Mayor Bloomberg Quipped Back When Asked About Walmart’s Intentions. 1010 WINS’ Stan Brooks Reports.


“It won’t with me. This city’s open to everybody, period, end of story,” Bloomberg said.

Hizzonor was so agitated that he at first wouldn’t let Gilliard answer the question.

“I answered it for you. We’ve had enough,” Bloomberg said.

And away they went:

Kramer: “Mr. Mayor, I don’t understand why you’re not allowing Michelle …”

Bloomberg: “I’d be happy to allow Michelle … she says no.”

Kramer: “This is a press conference. We would like an opportunity …”

Bloomberg: “If Michelle wants to speak she’s welcome to speak.”

Kramer: “But you’re basically answering the questions.”

The mayor eventually let her take the floor, but Kramer couldn’t get an answer to the question.

Kramer: “Do you think that this donation of $4 million will help you or help your company on its attempt to build a store here?”

Bloomberg: “Let me answer that. I hope so. Why would anybody not hope so? You’re telling me that your company’s philanthropy doesn’t look to see what is good for your company?”

Walmart’s $4 million pledge should allow the summer jobs program to expand by up to 3,400 jobs.

“We’ve given close to $13 million in the last four years alone. So, today’s announcement really was a continuation of what our foundation has done over the past several years,” Restivo said earlier.

Walmart has been tight lipped about where it wants to build. One potential site is on Gateway Drive in Brooklyn. The location is just a few miles from the Pitkin Avenue Business District where local store owners are worried about their survival and furious at Mayor Bloomberg.

Mark Tanis, the general manager of Shopper’s World on Pitkin Avenue in East New York, Brooklyn, told Kramer it’s clear to him why Walmart made the donation.

“I feel that Walmart is trying to buy its way into the community,” Tanis said. “I don’t know why the mayor would want to infringe on the small businesses. We are everyday small businesses, mom and pop trying to make it.”

Walmart said the city donation is part of a $25 million program to help kids have a better summer.

Do you think Walmart is trying to buy its way into NYC? Or do you think its intentions are genuine? Please offer your thoughts in the comments section below.

View Comments
  • Manhattan Man

    As a native New Yorker, why WALMART, as we always had every product imagineable to us. As long as they would have UNIONIZED workers, then it might be beneficial. I know that this would only be a pipe dream as Republicans are notorious for being for corporations and the upper wage earners and not the average American. So, if no union, then keep your store where Americans lack good hygiene..

  • Compton

    Perception is Reality. Regardless if Bloomberg won’t admit that Walmart just bought him and the whole New York City – all for the sake of the “children”. Coincidentally in the neighborhood that Walmart has been actively eye’ing to claim. Gee, it’s probably Walmart’s cheapest PR campaign, yet.

    How can WE, New Yorkers, help Brownsville’s community fight to uphold their wishes and plans to create a main street and a city center on the lonely field?

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/reverend-billy/field-of-change_b_838980.html

    – No wonder Walmart snubbed City Council twice in the past 7 months. They had a Bloomberg in their pocket.

    • Addiscott

      I don’t understand why it is that Unions are being blamed for this. Why is it so bad that people would like to work for an honest wage, safe working environment, decent health benefits and a secure future? The Labor Movement was started because of unfair labor practices, unsafe work conditions and the atrocities committed against the hard working middle class. Only 1% of the US population is considered Upper class. The rest are middle class and the poor. If it weren’t for the Unions, there would be no middle class and sadly, we are heading stead fast down that road. To the person who called us ‘Union Thugs’ I will accept that title and carry it as an honor! If being a ‘THUG’ means I am standing up for my rights to a safe work environment and a fair labor wage then I would rather be a thug over mere follower any day! The current mind frame of those who don’t believe in Unions is ‘Why should you make more money than me, you should be getting the same as me or lower.’ This mind frame needs to change. It needs to be ‘Why am I getting less money than you an hour? I should be paid a higher wage than I am now and step up to your level and be your equal.’ Why would anyone want to take a step down, we should all want to take a step up! And for those who think that Unions are full of people who want to do less work for more money, you could not be more wrong! We are begging for the work and would gladly accept more hours to support our families.

1 2
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Follow CBS New York

Like us on foursquare

New York City Guides

 New York City Guides
Food & Drink
The latest on New York City’s diverse dining scene: Restaurant openings, the best meals, and fun takes on food.
 New York City Guides
Nightlife & Bars
From events to the latest cocktail creations, all you need to navigate the extensive NYC nightlife scene.
 New York City Guides
Family & Pets
Plan a weekend getaway with the kids, share tips with fellow parents or find a groomer that suits your pooch.