Queens Man Details 5 Years In Jail After Being Falsely Accused Of Murder

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — Spending time in jail is a nightmare for anyone, but being incarcerated for five years only to be eventually acquitted is even worse.

That is exactly what happened to now 20-year-old Ryan Dufort, of Queens. He spent the last five years behind bars for a murder he didn’t commit. He said the experience taught him a lot about himself.

“I believe what doesn’t kill you always makes you stronger,” Dufort told CBS 2’s John Slattery.

Dufort was a 15-year-old sophomore at Bayside High school when he was arrested at a karaoke club in Flushing in October of 2006. Inside, a fight broke out involving bats and pipes. One man was killed and another was injured.

Dufort admitted he was at the club when the beatings took place, but didn’t know what happened because he was in another room. Dufort was arrested with others and charged with murder and gang assault. He was jailed through 37 adjournments.

“I basically grew up in jail,” he said.

When his case finally came to trial, he was acquitted. Dufort’s father, Joe, said the evidence against him was almost non-existent.

“The only witness ID’d him by clothing, not by his face,” Joe Dufort said.

Ryan Dufort’s attorney said that a female witness’ testimony was not made known to the district attorney until late in the case.

“She said her identification was based on clothing…That could have been a surprise to the district attorney as it was to me,” defense attorney Christopher Renfro said.

According to a statement from the Queens District Attorney’s Office, “(Dufort) was observed on the video placing a pipe in his sweat shirt sleeve while running towards the location where the attack was taking place and then proceeding to move into the group of individuals, surrounding the victims as they were being attacked.”

Ryan Dufort admitted he had armed himself, but only after the attack when he was exiting.

But now, five years later, he’s a free man.

“It was a weird feeling that I never felt before — actually walking out and feeling complete freedom,” he said.

Dufort was one of five men tried. The other four were found guilty of various charges.

Share your thoughts on this story in the comments section…

More from John Slattery
  • Cynthia McClendon

    He is moving forward with his life, and heading to college. This is commendable. He knows his father really well, and they are rebuilding his life on a firm foundation. Looks like the past could have been harmful, if he allowed it to be, since he is stronger and growing up it is a better choice.

  • Barre Flynn

    The friend of a fool will suffer harm but the friend of a wise man will become wise. Proverbs 13.20. Choose your friends wisely and stay away from people places and things that might get you in trouble. a 15 year old should not be in a club. This is in no way suggesting that he got what he deserved but it is suggesting that he put himself in a vulnerable position. Hopefully he will catch up with his life.

    • doc in NJ

      my mom always told me “show me who your friends are, and tell you who YOU are.” same sentiment, different semantics. It’s a travesty of justice, but ultimately, was bound to happen. Sad.

    • Tracy

      The nightclubs of New York City make the city full of excitements. It really is not a matter of age. If Ryan was an adult, would he socialize with his friends in a club more reasonable? I guess not. It could happen to you or your loved one.

  • laughing at NYers

    Its a common practice for the prosecution to shred any man of his dignity and honor, separate loved ones, convicting innocent men. I’m glad NYC is going to have to pay.



blog comments powered by Disqus
Giving Tuesday
Charles Osgood Event

Listen Live