02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

Business

Blue Donkey Bar Gives Up Fight, Shuts Down After One Man’s Complaints

View Comments
Excerpt from a letter at The Blue Donkey on the Upper West Side - New York, NY - Aug 9, 2011 (credit: Alex Silverman / WCBS 880)

Excerpt from a letter at The Blue Donkey on the Upper West Side – New York, NY – Aug 9, 2011 (credit: Alex Silverman / WCBS 880)

Alex Silverman Feature Image

Reporting Alex Silverman

NEW YORK (WCBS 880) - In the words of one Upper West Side bar owner, “the quickest way to end the war is to lose.”

WCBS 880′s Alex Silverman In Manhattan


Inside the Blue Donkey Bar on Amsterdam Avenue, they were boxing up the tap handles and pulling the TVs down off the wall on Tuesday.

A letter posted at The Blue Donkey on the Upper West Side - New York, NY - Aug 9, 2011 (credit: Alex Silverman / WCBS 880)

A letter posted at The Blue Donkey on the Upper West Side - New York, NY - Aug 9, 2011 (credit: Alex Silverman / WCBS 880)

“Never been treated so shabbily and so horribly,” said owner Jim Goldsmith, who posted a letter in the bar’s window explaining why it is closing down.

It talks about a man named Tim Tomlinson, who was generating a large volume of complaints to 311, Community Board 7, and even the City Council, for eight years.

“[We] closed the patio at 10 o’clock at night willingly,” Goldsmith told WCBS 880 reporter Alex Silverman.

But Goldsmith says his neighbor kept at it and last week the police shut him down.

Goldsmith says he’s still in shock.

“Potentially having my own business was an idea in the city, but now I want no part of it,” Mishi Torkerov, a manager at the Blue Donkey, told Silverman.

“We accept defeat,” ends Goldsmith’s note.

There has been no comment from Tomlinson.

View Comments
  • Jack Daniels

    So… How much money did Tim Tomlinson make from this place closing?

  • Stephen Guy

    There’s a huge back story on the Blue Donkey owners.

    http://valleyvipers.com/

    It turns out that they’re rich schmucks.

  • Disgusted

    One miserable bully can close down a business?

  • Nick

    It’s a TIM. Ever know a TIM who’s not a stupid F*cking Prick?

  • Ant928

    F*cking Prick!

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Follow CBS New York

Like us on foursquare

New York City Guides

Tornado Help
Tornado Relief
How to help the residents of Moore, Okla., after the deadly top-of-the-scale EF-5 twister.
 New York City Guides
Food & Drink
The latest on New York City’s diverse dining scene: Restaurant openings, the best meals, and fun takes on food.
 New York City Guides
Nightlife & Bars
From events to the latest cocktail creations, all you need to navigate the extensive NYC nightlife scene.
 New York City Guides
Family & Pets
Plan a weekend getaway with the kids, share tips with fellow parents or find a groomer that suits your pooch.