02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

News

Family Fined $300 For Having Apple, Tomato, 3 Cucumbers In Backpack At Newark Liberty

Steinbergers Had Just Gotten Off Flight From Israel, Forgot About Kid's Snack

View Comments
Newark Airport Customs

A local family was fined $300 by Customs officials at Newark Liberty Airport for not declaring an apple, tomato and three cucumbers it packed in a child’s backpack prior to a flight from Israel. (Photo: CBS 2)

NYC Is A Strange Place

MONSEY, N.Y. (CBSNewYork) — A family of four from Florida visiting relatives in New Jersey got an unwelcome surprise at the Customs gate — all because of some forgotten fruit and vegetables.

The oversight was an expensive one that has the family fuming, reports CBS 2’s Sean Hennessey.

“I don’t have to be traumatized like this. Nobody should have to be traumatized,” Suri Steinberger said.

Suri and Peter Steinberger are livid after what they call an over-reaction by customs agents at Newark Liberty Airport. They were told they had violated a federal crime — forgetting about an apple, a tomato and three cucumbers in their son’s backpack.

“For me it was like, you know, what you see on TV. I thought I was going to get handcuffed, they have my kids. So I just started to cry,” Suri Steinberger said.

The run-in with Customs agents happened Thursday at the end of a long trip from Israel. Suri packed the vegetables as snack for her boys.

“Let them eat it on the plane instead of eating garbage,” Suri said.

The problem was she didn’t sit with her husband and two boys on the flight and Peter didn’t know the produce was in the bag.

So when the declaration form came around, Peter said he “checked no on all the boxes.”

Customs officials told Hennessey strict rules are for “agricultural integrity” and that passengers have multiple opportunities to amend the Customs declaration form.

“I have no idea what they mean by that except for the fact they say you should have been looking at the posted signs,” Peter said.

While passengers were stunned at the strictness, others said it was par for the course.

“Other countries do it, too. They’re pretty strict. I travel a lot for work and I get the same thing,” said Christine Colella of North Brunswick, N.J.

Customs did say it’s up to the discretion of the officer to “destroy” the product or “fine the traveler,” discretion this family said was sorely missing given the Customs sheet showing the prohibited items and their $300 fine.

“You’re coming off a flight after 19 hours. You’re all flustered. You don’t know what world you’re on. The first thing on your mind isn’t vegetables in your backpack,” Peter said.

The family hopes what happened is a lesson to others that even an innocent mistake at customs may be a costly one.

The Steinbergers said they don’t expect to get their money back but do plan on taking the case with higher ups at customs.

Please offer your thoughts in the comments section below.

View Comments
  • dghattierdc

    It is a serious problem to being in fruits and veggies that could carry pests, the feds could have just destroyed the stuff and said move along. Instead they fine.

    Since we are so good about keeping illegal vegigies out of the USA how bout the illegal immigrants? Dont they bring in diseases and cost us a huge amount of money taking care of their problems? How bout just deporting all of them, since we are so hard on veggies?

    Fair is Fair.

    • Thomas

      Answer–Veggies don’t vote.

      • Slam1263

        And criminal aliens don’t vote Republican.

      • Josh

        Obama – Biden 2008! Enough said….

    • Will the farmer

      The toughest part in cooking vegetables is getting the wheelchair in the oven.

    • Angry Aggie

      I see an attitude problem here. Ever hear the old adage, “ignorance of the law is no excuse? . By the way, the family is probably lying….In Israel, security asks everyone if they knew what was in their bags….If they said they didn’t know it was in their luggage they are full of it.
      To all the ignorant folks out their who wonder why the USDA and CBP sanction fines against morons like these…To teach the traveling public a lesson in protecting our valuable Agricultural and Natural Resources.
      I agree, 300.00 is a bit steep; but not compared to the hundreds of millions of dollars in potential damage a plant or animal disease can cost in lost trade revenue and eradication costs.
      So, if you insist on being an ignoramus, you’re better off not crossing borders.
      The traveling public must act in an intelligent and responsible manner. Stupidity Kills!

  • Tyrone

    The reason we have laws governing bring in vegetables is the threat to the food supply of new plant diseases and pests being introduced into the US. These people got exactly what they deserved.

    • k-dog

      As an ex-CBP Ag Officer passengers are given the opportunity to 1. Amend their customs declaration and 2. Given the opportunity have items destroyed prior to entry into US. It’s sounds like these passengers from Israel innocently forgot about the fruits and veggies, but possibly wanted to make a stand/statement against the government. This happens every day in airports and seaports and customs made the right decision. +1 US CBP Ag!

    • ron

      your an idiot

      • Tim P

        you’re an idiot…

      • Jerry Gold

        It’s YOU’RE an idiot, Ron…so, you’re the idiot.
        (Hate when people don’t know proper syntax)

      • Sam

        “Ur an idiot .” Thats all three ways you can spell “UR”.

    • Bill in Tennessee

      And yet they don’t stop the bigger pests from streaming across the border from Mexico. Hmmm, amazing.

      • John not in Tennessee

        Ha. That coming from someone in Tennessee!

      • walljasper

        Haha! Good ‘un.

      • Big Mack

        Apparently, John Not in Tennessee has not attempted to read the numerous Spanish language billboards that adorn the shoulders of the highways in, and around, Nashville and Chattanooga.

    • Anthony Sood

      We have a serious problem in this country with over criminalization. There are more laws on the books now than anyone can keep track of, and can you tell me for sure you are not breaking a law even right this moment. Do you, or does anyone know all the laws on the books? I doubt it. Maybe someone should follow you around and fine you everytime you break a law. We need less criminalization in this country. By the way, I also would decriminalize drug abuse.

      • John

        All a passenger entering the U.S. has to do is READ the form you have to fill out. It is not that difficult

    • A

      Tyrone is a plant. No normal person thinks this way. Pesticides exist in most of our domestic fruits and vegetables…no outcry or fining there even though it’s causing health and cancer epidemics on levels the world has never seen albeit plagues. This is big government and regulation at its worst. $300…another tax for government “revenues”.

  • Rachel 2

    You’re an idiot. Probably a lib that can’t afford to go anywhere cause you sit at home and wait for the gov’s money.

    • Rachel Leah

      Your a dooky-face!

    • kms

      Just for your information: Customs and Border Protections Agriculture Specialists are required to have a degree in agriculture related field.
      So much for the High School drop outs.
      If you do not understand the implications of introducing foreign pest and diseases perhaps you should educate yourself.

      • njconnie

        We can stop people from bring in food that may have pests. But we do nothing to stop illegals coming into our country and testing them for any diseases they may be bringing in. What hypocrites.

  • sudha

    agree. the way in which you react makes a big difference

    • UNREAL!

      Are you saying that these Jewish travelers misbehaved???????? UNREAL!

  • Bill Fisher

    Yet another failure and abuse by the DHS run Customs agency. Their total disregard for travelers is evidenced by TSA and their abuses and extends to every facet of DHS operations. Napolitano is a criminal and needs to be prosecuted for criminal malfeasance by the next Administration.

    They could have just as easily destroyed the fruit and allowed the family to proceed unimpeded. This was clearly a simple oversight with no criminal intent. Just another example of Government clerks taking the regulations to the extreme and abusing their authority. DHS needs to be dismantled.

    • Keisha

      NO ABUSE. They broke they law and were fined, plain and simple.

      • Bobby

        That’s right. The agents have to fine people at least a minimum amount wach day in order to pay their salaries. If they let everyone off without a fine, the country would go broke… Oh that’s right; the country is broke. How silly of me.

  • Ben

    It’s silly since millions of people infiltrate the USA every year through the land borders and by landing ships all along the coasts.

    • Eric Swinson

      yes but those people come here to pick our vegetables not to bring their own.

      • Me Myself

        Yeah, well some bring worse than veggies…

  • R Smith

    From Israel? There had to be an argument over the vegetables and fruit. This law prevents diseases from infecting American crops.

    • Fun_jumper

      Nonsense

      • Mohawk

        Really Fun Jumper cause mediterraining fruit flys don’t piggy back..

      • Mohawk

        mediterranean** FLIES** damn IPHONE…

    • Joe C

      Well Said !!!!! I never could understand that. We import this bug to kill THAT bug and when that bug becomes an infestation, we import yet ANOTHER bug to kill THAT one. Aside from that, that’s why they are cracking down on dairy farmers and such are selling “natural” farm items…you know, stuff people have been eating for thousands of years with no ill effects? Why don’t they want someone to buy natural milk from an Amish farmer? Cuz there isn’t any of the garbage they add to it. Same goes for our seed manufacturers.

    • SpanishInquisition

      And what about all the chem trailing occurring all over this country ???

    • Cynthia

      Touche !

    • SockRayBlue

      Like Monsanto GM seeds only working with Monsanto pesticides? Sounds like Monsanto is building a closed or fixed customer base.

  • nam_vet6869

    If she did not sit with the Husband and boys why did she not just tell the husband the snakes were there. Every time you go into or out of any country you hjave the declaration form, as long as it is on that form, you may not bring it in but you are not in trouble either.

    • Patrick

      They didn’t have snakes in their bag… it was fruits and vegetables.

    • mdlr

      I hate snakes, specially on planes

      • Sty

        snaaaaakes … why did it have to be snakes?

  • MeFailEnglishThatsUnpossible

    Another example of quality journalism. “They were told they had violated a federal crime…” Seriously? Doesn’t anyone check this garbage before you publish it? Perhaps the crime beat was on vacation, and they had to ask people from the sports beat to fill in. This whole report reads like a “What I did on my summer vacation” paper written by a high school football player.

    • ericfromnewyork

      Besides the bad English, the word “crime” is completely inappropriate for this trivial misdemeanor, and trivial fine. This is only getting play because of the justifiable upset with TSA, but Customs is a different outfit entirely.
      There is a problem with way too many federal violations actually being “crimes,” But this is just a stupid article. On par with: “man runs stop sign, claims to police he ‘didn’t see it.”

  • Scunnerous

    What is it with those commenters and their “do the crime – pay the fine” attitude? The custom agent is ALLOWED to confiscate and destroy which is what happened to us once when my daughter of 3 had a half-eaten apple, which she was still eating. The regulation makes sense but the manner of application, with the $300. fine, is absurd. I’m sick to death of the insolence from little bullies that we have to put up with just to travel by air now. If nobody protests about this, they’ll just get worse – creeping ever-increasing intrusions into our lives.

    • sw2

      Bully? It sounds like they used discretion and let you go. What’s your complaint? These people probably argued why they should keep the fruit and got fined for it.

      • Larry

        What kind of sick and twisted mindset is that? “Used discretion and let you go”?

        Let’s all be thankful that the almighty federal agent showed us mercy and let us go when we violated the holy federal law!

      • Mike Lee

        So the 300.00 fine they paid kept the bugs from crawling off the fruit, traveling to where ever it came from and infecting what ever kind of tree or bush it was? How does letting you keep the infected fruit and paying a fine protect us?

    • George

      Two years ago I was flying from Shanghai to Miami and the flight was delayed 12 hours. They gave us apples in the airport. i put mine in my carry on. Fell asleep on the plane. Upon Arrival in Miami they had the drug dogs search us. I laughed so hard until the dog came for me. I opened my bag and there was the apple. I had no idea the apple were considered contraband. They took me into another room and searched all my bags. I was in China for a month and had a lot of souvenirs. Eventually they let me go and would not let me eat the apple. I had no idea I could have been fined

  • Elizabeth Brown

    What we all must remember is that harmful insects, with no natural enemies have been transported innocently into our country and have wreaked havoc on our crops and forests and even water ways.. There are reasons why there are strict laws about bringing fresh produce into our country.

    • Demsvoteblindly

      They could have just confiscated it….

  • randimbaserd

    didn’t know what world their in? how about the real world!

  • Marilyn

    When I worked on the Mexican Border, we never fined people for something this insignificant. We just confiscated it and it was picked up later by someone from the Mexican Orphanage in Tijuana. Now, 50 pounds of pork was another thing, especially if it was hidden. That’s worth a fine.

  • Tom Davidson

    If you want to bring vermin in to the US, then the government says you’ll have to do it at the Mexican border.

  • Karen Jones

    There is a lot of infestation in D.C. It’s about money and they are getting where-ever they can.

  • kickk

    How do you spell indiscretion – government!!

  • Dahlia Balir

    I am a gardener and a frequent flier. This isn’t about the dangers of introducing foreign pests. It’s about the lack of discretion of a customs officer. They could have simply destroyed the fruit. As another commenter pointed out, these people were not smugglers or repeat offenders. If you weren’t there you don’t know how they behaved; don’t assume the family reacted with a “hissyfit.”

    • sw2

      Good point. You’re a gardener and frequent flier so you can clearly tell from this article that it had nothing to do with foreign pests. You say not to assume the family reacted poorly…just after you assume the customs officer didn’t use discretion. Brilliant logic. Did you use your gardener deduction skills for that one too?

    • Mohawk

      What SW2 Said….

  • Black Eagle

    Probably a Jew-hating custom’s officer. But really, thank you Prez Clinton for imposing these new custom’s laws as revenge because Europe blocked importation of American GMO crops and hormone-laden beef products. We have too many fat and overpaid bullies running the government.

  • B Dixon

    That California agricultural station has its roots in the great depression and the dust bowl.. They were set up to keep Okies out of California First they sent Los Angleles police to the border to turn back refugees from Oklahoma but that was illegal so they put state agricultural agents on the job to put a stamp of legality to it. Like all government institutions they never ended the operation even when the need for it was gone.

  • Bruce

    This has nothing to do with the TSA, read the article then open your mouth.

  • Marvin

    We fly as a family internationally all the time. We are used to things that are or are not allowed. Part of the trip is getting through security to board, the rest is focused on getting off and through customs and imigration. Could there possibly be more to the reason the inspector took such a harsh position?

  • Louis Emery

    How about a food irradiator at airports and at ports? Irradiation will kill bugs, bacteria, fungus (read the wiki on this subject). There’s already many types of X-ray machines at the airports, though an irradiator is much more powerful. Thus travelers can bring any food they want across borders. The food flavor, texture and nutritional value is unchanged.

    I once had a airline-provided ham sandwich confiscated when entering US at ORD. It was hard to imagine what kind of pest I was introducing to U.S. or (perhaps more likely) financial hardship to local ham-producers I was causing.

    • nobama2012

      Why not just pack only what you intend to eat and throw out the excess. Why make it so complicated? KISS

    • AS

      potential for classical swine fever, most likely, depends on where the meat came from, a few other possibilities. How many times in between flights have I ever wondered what it would be like if we had a major epidemic outbreak. Agriculture Specialist.

  • Sage

    The fine is harsh, but this is just a matter of common sense. Mrs. Steinberger should have known that there are restrictions about bringing produce into the United States. I packed fresh fruit for a long flight to Hawaii. There were announcements on the airplane and there were warnings at the gate when we arrived and trash cans were provided for everyone who forgot they had produce in their carry-on bags. It was Mrs. Steinberger’s responsibility to toss those items. She was the one who packed the produce.

    • NOT FOLLOWING RULES

      Simply said, she thought she could get away with it simply bc….

  • Mike McLurg

    How to win friends and influence more tourists….

  • roger angles

    Lairdkeir,
    That comment coming from a guy who lives in country that has spurned two world wars and murdered countless millions…..it to say the least a cheap shot.
    I guess it is a matter a time before our boys scounts turn to secret police and all is lost. As I remember some of your elected officals weren’t so bright either. I will agree with you that the decline in my country is bad and our elected officals are a joke…..but we are not rioting and burning cars every night because we don’t have anything better to do. I guess since we finished rebuilding Germany we have lost our way.

1 2 3 4 9
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video