Hungerthon 2015: AboutDonate Today | Bid On Great Auction Items | Listen Live: WFAN | WCBS | 1010 WINS

Police Still Searching For Missing Jersey City Mom Randy ‘Amanda’ Lehrer

JERSEY CITY, NJ (CBSNewYork) — Police in Jersey City are still looking for Randy “Amanda” Lehrer.

Lehrer, 32, is the mother of a 10-month-child. She was reported missing a week ago by her husband Steve Acuna after he said the they had an argument.

Wednesday night, dozens of people gathered in Jersey City to put up fliers, hoping to for leads.

Police say Acuna took three days to file a missing person’s report and has not been cooperating with investigators.

“We have been delayed because of a lack of cooperation on his part,” said Chief Tom Comey of the Jersey City Police Department. Acuna’s behavior “has forced us to seek court orders, subpoenas and warrants to do our job,” Comey added.

Donna Scocco works with Leherer at Tommy’s Restaurant. CBS 2’s Tony Aiello asked Scocco if she believes Lehrer would leave her baby behind. Her answer was succinct.

“Never in a million year. No way. Nope. No,” Scocco said.

Neighbors say they often heard the couple fighting on their home on Charles Street.

“They would argue a lot and I remember actually seeing her last week, and she kicked him out, she told him don’t ever come back I don’t want to see you,” said neighbor Janaya Henry.

Anyone with information about Amanda Lehrer is urged to call police at (201) 547-JAIL (5245).

Lehrer was last seen wearing a black Ed Hardy t-shirt. She has a tattoo on her right shoulder that reads “Laugh Now, Cry Later.”

What do you make of the disappearance? Sound off in our comments section.


    I think he’s has something to do with her disappearing,follow up investigation bye pulling his phone records indicating his last were about’s, plus if he took her look for scratches she may well tried to protect herself, and his past record……….she also be missing a phone …..just things I would look for but just reading he’s for sure responsible………

    • Bklyn mom

      I think the police know how to investigate a crime and what to look for, thank you. But I agree, the husband is definitely the main suspect here.

      • Joe

        Have you ever met a Jersey City cop? They are not the brightest people you will ever meet.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Charles Osgood Event

Listen Live