Hartnett: Why Grady Sizemore Makes Sense For Yankees

Sizemore Would Provide Competition At Corner Outfield & DH

‘Hart of the Order’
By Sean Hartnett
» More Columns

Once considered to be one of the brightest young players in baseball, Grady Sizemore suffered through three consecutive seasons of ‘injury hell.’  His significant upside is attracting many free agent suitors despite him missing 276 games over that three-year stretch.

According to ESPN, eight MLB teams have expressed an interest in Sizemore and are examining his medical reports.  Those teams are understood to be the New York Yankees, Philadelphia Phillies, Boston Red Sox, Texas Rangers, San Francisco Giants, Colorado Rockies and Sizemore’s previous employers the Cleveland Indians.

Sizemore could turn out to be a perfect fit for the Yankees considering their need for competition in both corner outfield spots.  Brett Gardner’s numbers took a tremendous slide toward the end of 2011.  Gardner was batting .286 with a .366 on-base percentage in mid-August and finished the year with a .259 average as his OBP fell to .345.

Gardner’s statistical drop-off could be attributed to playing a demanding workload of 159 games and his ‘all-out’ style of play.  Having a healthy Sizemore around would allow Joe Girardi to keep Gardner fresher in 2012.

Nick Swisher needs to begin next season strongly after yet another dismal postseason but at least he is a consistent .370 OBP batter.  If Swisher’s playoff struggles seep into 2012, a player of Sizemore’s ability could wrestle away playing time from Swisher in right field.

Brian Cashman has stated a desire to shift the Yankees roster to one of greater flexibility.  The DH position could be a revolving for spot without a full-time righty or lefty option.  Acquiring Sizemore plays into that philosophy.  It’s all about options for Cashman and the modern Yankees.

With Jorge Posada’s days with the Yankees over, Sizemore could provide capable a left-sided designated hitter.  Sizemore is a career .288 batter against right-handed pitchers with an impressive OBP of .376.  Eric Chavez is mulling over retirement and it’s unclear whether the Yankees would consider bringing back Chavez if he intends to play in 2012.

Jesus Montero and Eduardo Nunez are the only remaining DHs on the Yankees’ roster and they’re both right-handed and unproven.  It wouldn’t surprise me if Montero is dealt if the Yankees feel he isn’t a capable of becoming an adequate-fielding catcher.  The raw Nunez will continue to develop defensively and allow Alex Rodriguez and Derek Jeter more chances to be given ‘half breaks’ at DH.

Utilizing Sizemore as a role player would give Gardner, Swisher and Curtis Granderson rest when needed and fill the Yankees’ need for a left-sided DH.  In 2011, the Yankees went with a ‘buy-low philosophy’ by signing veteran free agents Chavez and Andruw Jones.  Both players turned out to be successful part-time Yankees and I wouldn’t be against re-signing Jones as a right-sided DH, occasional corner outfielder and key pinch hitter.

Sizemore has a lot to prove regarding his health but is a tantalizing buy-low free agent target.  If his medical reports are encouraging, the Yankees or any of their competitors would benefit greatly by having someone of Sizemore’s class.

Yankee fans – is Sizemore a risk worth taking?  Share your thoughts and opinions below.  Sean Hartnett will be covering the Yankees’ hot stove all winter long.  Send him your tweets @HartyLFC.

  • Stevie K

    Also forgot to mention with Gardner there’s not much upside…I think what you see out of him you’ll get….Sizemore has the upside no doubt and should Sizemore go down to injury (that’s why you don’t break the bank for him) I’m sure the Yankees have a lton of internal options…worth the risk for a slightly above reasonable offer which the Yankees are always good for :)

    • hartylfc

      Whether or not Gardner hits, he’s still a tremendous fielder and baserunner. He definitely has value on the trade market but I don’t think the Yankees would include him in trade talks. – Sean Hartnett

  • Stevei K

    He makes sense…he’s a low risk high payoff option and if he stays healthy could make a very attractive outfield. If he should regain his form the Yankees would have another speed/power guy to compliment Granderson. Why not dangle Brett Gardner in a trade? I’m sure there are many teeams interested in him. You still have the speed and Gold Glove defense in Sizemore with the potentioal for power. Sign Sizemore and Andrew Jones to platoon…trade Gardner. But Sizemore’s not competing with Swisher…People like to jump on Swissher for his playoff failures but this guy brings the most intangibles to this team which is important…That’s why the Yankees picked up his option immediately even when you have Carlos Beltran looking to be signed. Think the Bleacher Creatures out there would have as good a time with Beltran out there? Swisher IS a Yankee…he’ll give you close to 30 hrs and 100 rbis and might surprise you with his average…he goes on two to three week tears and carries the team. Remember Tino Martinez sucked in the playoffs for a while then suddenly you saw yoj a clutch homerun hero in the World Series. Gerdner is the guy and him ALONE that could do well with some compettiion for potential comeback player of the year Grady Sizemore. Id take a Sizemore/Jones platoon and include Garder in a trade that will bring the Yanks pitching. There’s a reason why so many teams are intrested in Sizemore…but I wouldn’t break the bank for him that some dopey team like the Nationals could do…then you can have him!

  • pmg

    I disagree. What is needed is not another bench player who may or may not make it through the season healthy. A rod and Teichera need to be productive but they are liabilities especially hitting 3rd and 4th. DO NOT give up Montero. If he is the bat all the scouts are raving about he will eventually fit into the cleanup spot. The Yankees do not score in the clutch they need that extra bat.

  • http://toosoxy.wordpress.com toosoxy

    I don’t know… I think he’d be a great Red Sox… let the bidding war begin!

blog comments powered by Disqus
Giving Tuesday
Charles Osgood Event

Listen Live