IT IS WAY TOO SOON TO SPEAK!! All of you are judging based on bits and pieces that were scraped together….keep your panties on. Time will tell; if and when it reaches trial…….

All media exist to invest our lives with artificial perceptions and arbitrary values. This man is innocent. Story sounds too far fetched.

To find out how meaningless a confession may be, read the NON FICTION book by John Grisham “The Innocent man”. You will be shocked that this story recently happened in the U.S.

I believe that this man has been framed. Just because he admitted to committing the crime does not mean he did it. He did not have a lawyer present and the cops could have forced him to admitting to it. All nassau county cops know how to do is give tickets. After the whole marvin situation they do not want to seem too stupid so they’ve arrested this poor individual to keep their name. I’m sorry but the first woman who was kidnapped was in the car with him for 30 minutes which means she should know clearly what his face looked like, yet the sketch is off. Why the heck would he kidnapp a woman in great neck, where he lives? It does not add up

Haven’t any of you people seen the film my cousin vinny, a confession does not mean anything, they could have had him confess to jaywalking, and then somehow tie that into this crime.

You cannot judge someone, that is upto g-d. And nobody has all the facts here, not you, not me. Lets give this guy a fair trial, and see what comes out of it.

For all the idiots who say 100% guilty, that is sad, and I would not wish someone judging you without a fair trial. i would not wish it upon my worst enemy.

Everybody deserves the benefit of the doubt, and have the ability to prove their case. That is one of the best liberties we have as Americans that very few other countries have.

Respect the process and please reserve your judgement for now.

The Torah never said that it is legal to marry your uncle just like it never said you can’t eat shrimp or pork. That man is disgusting and 100% guilty!!!!!!!! he is a pig just like anybody who thinks he is not guilty!!!!!!!

To all these people saying they don’t believe he did it, there’s evidence and a confession. Two innocent women picked him out of line up. He confessed.
Most people who live near or who are family of serial killers say the same things. Oh he was so good or no I don’t believe it. The truth is many sick individuals hide behind having a wife and kids. He just got away with it until now. Great police work.

Innocent until proven guilty and until I hear him charged as guilty with legitimate evidence in front of a judge then I believe sirus to be nothing but innocent. I know him personally and there has never been an incident for me to see him as anything other than an honorable man.

Hey R since u know so much abt this case I wanna know did the cops find a gun with their search warrants???

If he did it he is sick! Why wouldn’t the judge let him out on 2 million $$$ bail???

Oh and to all the Mashadis on here.. I can’t believe you’re all not in agreement with each other??? Time for a community meeting ;-P

Why the hell didn’t they catch Marvin this fast???? He actually raped a 2yr old in texas and almost killed a women in LIE! He is a very dangerous criminal, I don’t know if this mashad Siruis is guilty or not but atleast he isn’t an attempted murderer like Marvin!!! He didn’t leave anyone to die so can the cops please go start looking for Marvin and not get sidetracked by petty perverts!!

there are sick people in every society…mashadies included. What is very troublesome for me to view him innocent till proven guilty is his confession. attorney or no attorney present the man said I did it…. At least he has a concious. Problem is that in our comminuty we do not have any type of support for people with these issues. There are no support groups, no one speaks about these things. But if he has admitted, case of mis identity is far fetched…..marrying cousins or nieces does not make a person good or bad.

Great neck police are the most overpaid pieces of $hit in America. They deserve no honor or respect? Their work is pathetic and entire essence is shameful.

yo maryam and sam, are you blind? if you read what it says.. it will tell you that Mr. Kashimallak”s NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOR says what a nice man he is and what a good family he comes from, so I’m guessing they might have some sense in mind of who this man actually is. so if you’re not sure of something, don’t just open your mouth like that because you’re only ruining yourself by doing that. I’m pretty sure that by what you’re saying that you might have some of your own problems with Mr. Kashimallak and maybe even his family… but that has nothing to do with this case, so calm down.

I find it very very very hard to bealive that this man did this crime its like saying my father the person i love the person i look upto did this crime thats how unbealiveable it is

this is just a mis identity or scam for someone trying to get back on mr kashi

Innocent until PROVEN guilty.
I know mr. kashimallak and he is a descent and honorable man.
“confess” doesnt mean anything.

i agree with your statement. i do not know the kashimallak family, i have only seen it on the news, but i do know from personal experiences that what “annon” is saying is true.
to maryam and sam, you should go find lives rather than stalking the lives of this kashimallak family unless you want something that is theres. i know people like you from my case and i can say that you will end up in hell. i AM jewish, and marrying your uncle IS NOT a crime. to Annon, Kalati, Tommy, and David, i can truly tell that you guys have very nice souls. may God help the Kashimallak family to find the REAL person who has did this crime. thank you.

stupid maryam and idiotic sam,
1- wtf does being a mashadi or not being a mashadi has anything to do with all of this???? (maryam if u r so ashamed to be a mashadi please do us all a favor and leave!!!)
2- marrying ur uncle is not a crime and totally legit according to the TORAH! do you find yourself wiser then our TORAH?????
3- you dont have a life and dont have all the facts. not everything u hear from the press is true (sam). u both should be ashamed of talking behind some1s back!!!
seems to me (maryam) that u have personal issues with the kashimallk family and it all translates to jealousy since u r SO exstatic that 1 of them is in trouble!!!! G-d haelp u!

THE POLICE HAVE NOTHING TO DO IN GREAT NECK.
THEY SHOULD INVESTIGATE PROPERLY BEFORE THEY
CONDEM A MAN. I AM SURE YOU HAVENT HEARD THE GUYS SIDE OF
THE STORY… I SAY TO SIRUS …. THE ONLY DUMB MOVE YOU MADE IS NOT
HAVING A LAWYER. THE COPS DON’T CARE ABOUT TRUTH ANYMORE..
THEY LOOK AT EVIDENCE AND JUST CHARGE..
G-D WILL LET TRUTH COME OUT.. AMEN.

Dear Maryam,

I don’t know who you are but you make me sick to my stomach the way you speak about an individual. You sound like you must have had personal issues with Mr. Kashimallak, and you are the definition of an animal with no sense of what is wrong or right in life. Please keep your derogatory statements to yourself, and may you see no happiness in your life because of saying this.

Shame on you maryam! How dare you judge an entire family who has nothing to do with you like that!! who someone marries is none of your business.

Maryam…keep your racists comments to yourself and never judge if you’re not sure. This could easily be a case of Mis-identity. It happens all the time.

doesn’t sound like sex abuse more like loneliness. Kidnapping is not the answer to have friends though. Glad they got this guy off the street.

Another happy story from Long Island