Palladino: Eli Owns Packers In Playoffs

‘From the Pressbox’
By Ernie Palladino
» More Ernie Palladino Columns

Ernie is the author of “Lombardi and Landry.”

Lambeau Field used to be the place where playoff teams went to die.

Until Eli Manning showed up.

From its erection in 1957, Lambeau was 11-0 in playoff games up there until the Falcons beat them in the 2002 wildcard round. Since then, they had never lost to the same team twice.

That’s over now.

Since Manning’s stalked around up there, twice in the last five years, he’s 2-0 against Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers in postseason games. That first one, you may remember, happened in the 2007 playoffs, a 23-20 overtime win that put the Giants in the Super Bowl against the then-undefeated New England Patriots.
The second time was Sunday, a dominant 37-20 victory where the defense had Rodgers’ high-octane offense reeling and out of sync, and where Manning and his unit produced a tidy 420 yards of offense and three passing touchdowns. Among the offensive carnage were seven catches by big-play guy Hakeem Nicks, including a heart-stopper of a Hail Mary grab at the end of the first half to give the Giants an improbable 20-10 lead.

Nicks’ sure-handedness, agility, and ability to get open had a lot to do with the Giants’ success, as did a defense that has apparently cured all its ills over the past four weeks. Just ask Osi Umenyiora, whose two sacks, including a third-quarter strip sack, went as only part of an effort that dropped Rodgers four times.

But it was Manning who put his throws right on the money where his receivers could get them. He did throw one interception, but the defense forced a fumble that turned into a field goal three plays later. Other than that, he was cool in the pocket during the infrequent times the Green Bay pass rush did elude an efficient offensive front.

The Packers dirtied his uniform only once, that coming when linebacker Brad Jones dropped him to force a fourth-quarter field goal that made the score 23-13.

So why does Manning have this hold on the playoff Pack?

We might start with the raw passing numbers. In two games, he’s gone a cumulative 42-of-73 (.561) for 581 yards and three touchdowns. Perhaps a hair short of elite figures, but strong enough to win.

But more than that, it’s his overall maturity, the same quality that helped him produce a career year in 2012. He’s a more patient guy, now unwilling to try to force a ball into the end zone or into a tight spot and risk an interception. Instead, we saw him take his only sack on third-and-6 from the Packers’ 14, aware that he could give the five yards and still afford Lawrence Tynes a relatively easy 35-yard field goal.

That kick stretched the lead to 23-10, a deficit that all but did in the Packers.

It doesn’t hurt, either, that Manning has a better receiving corps than he did back then. Oh, Plaxico Burress was there, and Amani Toomer. But neither of those guys possessed the game-breaking ability of Nicks and MetLife folk hero Victor Cruz. Even on a rather quiet afternoon, while Nicks was grabbing all the headlines, Cruz caught five passes for 74 yards and converted third-and-5 and third-and-11 in the fourth quarter to keep two scoring drives — 10 points in all — going.

Manning’s accuracy was the reason Nicks and Cruz could do their thing. And his guidance of the offense is the reason the score eventually got out of reach. Anything less would have given Rodgers a chance, and that’s all he usually needs to do in a team.

With a running game that sputtered all year, and gained just 95 yards Sunday — it’s only that high because of Brandon Jacobs’ 14-yard touchdown run that ended the scoring — the weight has been on Manning to produce all season.

He has. And nobody knows it better than the Packers.

Or maybe we should call them Manning’s personal playoff souvenir.

How great has Manning been this season? Leave a comment below.


One Comment

  1. Michael Jones says:

    well, if the playoffs were included in MVP consideration, then mr championship belt and mr breesy in da big easy might have just lost it to the Mann 🙂

    overall grats to a giants team that makes all of its fans proud to sport the lowercase ny.

  2. Angelica says:


  3. Lance says:

    The Giants will WIN the Super Bowl ! WHY? Right now they have the best Offensive Coordinator in the game. This person is one the best of All Time. He knows how to prepare an offense to score. His work ethic is no way compared to others. He’s a film junkie, just ask his co-workers.They scratched their heads in amazement how he KNOWS the game. His mental toughness transpires to everyone involved, So all you New York Fans should be happy. You should be Thanking Him. And who is this Great Offensive Coordinator? ———PEYTON———– As that OLDIE SONG goes—–HE’S MY BROTHER.

  4. bill araneo says:

    umenyiora’s play on rodgers has only been half acknowledged. after the strip on rodgers, osi went to ground and slapped the ball from under the belly of a packer leading to the recovery. how has this been missed ?

  5. EM10 says:

    And major kudos to the Giants Defense. Defense and QB. Watch out.

  6. EM10 says:

    Absolutely no one was talking about Eli Manning in the playoffs. It was all Brees, Rodgers, Brady, and, unbelievably, Tebow. And now, people are praising Brady’s obnoxious 6 TDs against…the Broncos (lol) while Eli Manning led the Giants into Lambeau field AGAIN and took down the defending champions and the “legendary” Aaron Rodgers. Eli Manning, kudos to you young man. You are one hell of a leader.

    1. chess says:

      So people shouldn’t commend 6 td passes in a game. Who’s the obnoxious one? Last I checked the Broncos had a pretty good defense.

  7. Joseph Pillot says:

    Unbelievable, the “Road Warriors” do it again!

  8. JP says:

    Strive to be the best. Achieve Greatness.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Listen Live