Supreme Court Begins Hearing Arguments On Constitutionality Of Obamacare

Justices Expected To Rule By Summer, Causing Chaos In Presidential Race

WASHINGTON (CBSNewYork) — The U.S. Supreme Court waded into the controversy over health care Monday, wrestling with the question: “is it constitutional for the government to force Americans to buy health insurance?”

It was democracy in action on the sidewalk in front of the Supreme Court. Protesters on both sides of the health care debate voiced their feelings as the nine justices of the nation’s highest court began hearing arguments about the constitutionality of President Barack Obama’s health care law, reports CBS 2’s Marcia Kramer.

1010 WINS’ Juliet Papa Hears From Congressman Jerrold Nadler

Inside the court the justices spent more than 90 minutes questioning attorneys about whether the requirement that Americans purchase health care insurance is constitutional.

Gregory Katsas was one of the attorneys asking that the law be struck down.

“There’s a requirement to buy heath insurance that’s what we’re challenging,” Katsas said.

The Obama health care bill has become a focal point of the presidential campaign, and of Senate and Congressional races around the country. If the justices uphold the president’s law it would give his re-election campaign a big boost. Republicans would benefit if it goes the other way.

A new CBS/New York Times poll on Monday found that 47 percent of Americans disapprove of the law, 30 percent strongly disapprove. On the other hand, 36 percent approve, but only 16 percent strongly approve.

A number of Republican senators were among those who were in the court for the historic day.

“This is an incredibly important moment in our history. It is pivotal and the question before the Supreme Court really has to do with our fundamental freedoms,” said Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wisc.

Those against “Obamacare” say it is unconstitutional to force people to buy health insurance. Those who support it say it’s crucial for them.

“It’s important for people to have health care and not be denied it if they have a pre-existing condition, especially in these economic times,” said Michelle Williams of the Families USA Foundation.

The Supreme Court justices will hear two more days of arguments. Some said this is the biggest case to go before them in decades.

They are expected to rule by early summer.

Please offer your thoughts in the comments section below …

  • AgreeToDisagree

    How about let NEITHER Obama nor Supreme Court decide AND let the individual citizen decide. The choice should not lie with either Obama or Supreme Court but the individual on a case by

    case basis. Pass the bill with an ‘Opt out’ option. Hegelian Dialectic again! CHOICE C – None of the above! Which means EVERYBODY wins!

  • Silberankauf

    Ihre Internetseite ist real nur zu beipflichten, ich werde mit absoluter Klarheit zum wiederholten Mal mal standhaft blicken.

  • JackXPowell

    Let me tell you one thing that the best health insurance plans has completely different set of meaning for different type of people. For those who are rich, the plan which can earn them more is best. However, those who are in the middle class have different ideas. They think that insurance plan is the best for which they will have to pay minimum premium. However, the poor person does not even know that what is health insurance? If you are one of them search online for~”Penny_Health”~and get smart about insurance.

  • The Realist

    The so-called “Obamacare” started off as “Romneycare” in 2006. Why are Republicans abandoning their own ideology?

    • Anonymous

      It’s to down Obama again. Anything he does they will down him even if it’s their own idea.

  • dakotahgeo
  • dakotahgeo
blog comments powered by Disqus
Giving Tuesday
Charles Osgood Event

Listen Live