CBS2-Header-Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

News

One Idea For Protecting NY, NJ From Powerful Storms: Man-Made Islands

View Comments
Artist rendering of artificial islands plan. (credit: WXY/West 8/Stevens Institute of Technology)

Artist rendering of artificial islands plan. (credit: WXY/West 8/Stevens Institute of Technology)

TRI-STATE NEWS HEADLINES

From our newsroom to your inbox weekday mornings at 9AM.
Sign Up
Superstorm Sandy

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork/AP) — The federal government will be evaluating some bold ideas for how to prevent damage from another Sandy-type superstorm.

As WCBS 880′s Jim Smith reported, one of the proposals would build a string of man-made islands off the coasts of Long Island and New Jersey to absorb the impact of another powerful storm.

The “Blue Dunes” proposal is part of Rebuild By Design, a competition sponsored by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development to come up with novel ways to protect against the next big storm. It is one of 10 projects that will be evaluated and voted on next week, but there’s no guarantee any of them will receive funding.

“One of the things we did with the Sandy bill is provide money not to actually do it, but to do the research, the study, the proposals — what do we do to prevent another Sandy?” Schumer told Smith.

The artificial-islands plan was created by New Jersey’s Stevens Institute of Technology, along with the WXY architectural firm and West 8 Urban Design and Landscape Architecture. It is designed to blunt the worst effect of Sandy: the storm surge that pounded the coast. From Maryland to New Hampshire, the storm was blamed for 159 deaths, and New Jersey and New York alone claimed a total of nearly $79 billion in damage.

It would cost an estimated $10 billion to $12 billion. The islands 10 to 12 miles off the coast would be uninhabited, though day trips for surfing or fishing might be allowed, said Alan Blumberg, a professor at the Stevens Institute.

A gap would be left between the New York and New Jersey island groups, mainly to allow water from the Hudson River to flow out into the ocean.

“How do you protect New Jersey and New York at the same time from the storm of the future?” Blumberg asked. “Our idea is to build a chain of islands, like a long slender banana. The wave action and storm surge will reflect off these islands and go back out to sea rather than hitting the coast. Barnegat Bay would not be pounded, nor would lower Manhattan or Hoboken.”

Blumberg also said computer modeling has shown such islands would have produced vastly lesser damage during Sandy, Hurricane Donna in 1962 and the destructive December 1992 nor’easter.

Other ideas include building sea walls around cities, re-establishing oyster colonies in tidal flats to blunt wave action and creating water-absorbent nature and recreational preserves.

Steve Sandberg, a spokesman for U.S. Sen. Robert Menendez, D-N.J., said funding for at least some of the proposals is already available as part of the $60 billion in Sandy aid that Congress passed last year. Other money could come from disaster recovery grants as well as public and private-sector funding, according to the Rebuild by Design website.

Aside from the formidable cost, many other obstacles remain. Stewart Farrell, head of Stockton College’s Coastal Research Center, said numerous government agencies would have to cooperate.

“The sand borrow sites always run into strong objections from the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service: ‘Something might live there,’” he said. “Next in line would be the historical preservationists: You can’t cover up Captain Kidd’s treasure ships, no way! And every 19th-century coal barge is an historical treasure. Then there are abundant submarine cables, lines, pipes and rights of way.”

Surfers aren’t stoked by the idea.

“This would forever change the Jersey shore,” said John Weber of the Surfrider Foundation. “Bayfronts are very different from oceanfronts, and this would change oceanfronts into bayfronts. People that spent all that money to live on the ocean would be facing something very different. And this does nothing to address rising sea levels; we’ll still have homes that will still get flooded due to rising sea levels.”

George Kasimos founded the Stop Fema Now grassroots campaign against higher flood insurance rates after his Toms River home was flooded during Sandy. He welcomed the attention on coastal prevention but said the money would be better spent on building or strengthening dunes along the existing shoreline.

“Anything to help protect our coast,” he said. “All we need to do is build a proper dunes system, sea gates and sea walls. It seems like $10 billion to build something 12 miles out is overkill. Typical government overkill.”

Blumberg acknowledged the obstacles but added that Sandy showed the need for new approaches to protection.

“This is innovative thinking,” he said. “It’s 2014; it’s time to think differently.”

You May Also Be Interested In These Stories

(TM and © Copyright 2014 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2014 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

View Comments