By The Numbers: All-Time AL NYC Vs. All-Time NL NYC — Who Would Win?

By Father Gabe Costa
» More Columns

Perhaps the last two installments of By The Numbers stirred up some strong sentiments as to whether New York City is more of an American League metropolis or a National League stronghold.

I thought I would round out this discussion by choosing all-time teams: one comprised solely of Yankees and the other with players from the New York Giants, Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Mets.

BY THE NUMBERS: IS NEW YORK A NATIONAL LEAGUE OR AMERICAN LEAGUE CITY? (PART 1) 

BY THE NUMBERS: IS NEW YORK A NATIONAL LEAGUE OR AMERICAN LEAGUE CITY? (PART 2) 

I made my selections and evaluations using the following guidelines:

  • I took the liberty of moving some players to a different position (ex: putting Joe DiMaggio in center field while stationing Mickey Mantle in left field).
  • I considered players’ records for only the years they played in The Big Apple (1903 through 2013). For example, Sandy Koufax would make an all-time Los Angeles Dodgers team, but not its Brooklyn counterpart.
  • I gave the “edge” to one player over another only if I felt it was clear that he was truly superior to the other.
  • I picked two catchers for each team.
  • I chose a pitching staff comprised of five starting pitchers and one reliever.
  • At the end I give a prediction of which team would win in a best-of-seven series.

 

Prediction: Because of superior hitting and Mariano Rivera, the Yankees defeat NYC NL 4-2 in the seven-game series.

Who do you think would win?

You May Also Be Interested In These Stories

 

Comments

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

BUY TICKETS NOW
Get Our Morning Briefs

Listen Live