Watch CBS News

Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show: First-Ever Obedience Winner Selected

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork/AP) — Sidestep in perfect pace with someone who has fewer feet than you. Sit properly in front of a crowd, while your favorite person walks away. Sort through a pile of identical items to find the one that belongs to that person — by smell.

Can you do it? Heart can. And she's a 3-year-old Labrador retriever.

PHOTOS: Inside The 2016 Westminster Dog Show

Heart won the Westminster Kennel Club dog show's first-ever obedience competition Monday with a crowd-pleasing, tail-wagging display of canine deportment that included fetching a few heart-print pillows.

"She is just amazing," said owner and handler Linda Brennan, of Columbia, New Jersey. Plus, "we had the cute factor."

Heart bested 33 other dogs in the first obedience event of any kind at the nation's premier dog show since a non-competitive demonstration in 1956. The contestants ranged from a toy poodle to a powerful Rottweiler (mixed-breeds were eligible, but none competed.)

At this level, it's no simple sit and stay. In fact, it can seem unimaginable to an everyday dog owner.

"My dogs would not have even made it in the ring," spectator Todd Eubanks, who has two hound mixes at home in Redding, Connecticut, said with a chuckle as he watched.

The dogs that did get in the ring had to sniff out and fetch a dumbbell their handlers had touched from a pile of otherwise identical dumbbells, for instance. The crowning challenge: sitting in a group while their handlers circled the ring twice without them.

The dogs had to do it all in front of hundreds of people. The handlers couldn't use treats. Points could be deducted for something as subtle as sitting crookedly.

And that was just the first round.

The 10 finalists did elaborate six-minute routines, sometimes spinning, walking backward and weaving through their handlers' legs. One dog fetched sections of board its handler pieced together to form a heart. Second-place finisher Smartie, a Belgian Tervuren, stacked water bowls with her mouth.

"She really loves figuring out the puzzle of obedience," said owner and handler Julie Hill, of Mandeville, Louisiana. She also handled Smartie to a finalist finish in Westminster's agility competition Saturday.

The third-place obedience ribbon went to Chase, a golden retriever owned and handled by Pauline Hosenfeld, of Columbus, Ohio. Wyatt, a Lab owned and handled by Cat Perry of Mauldin, South Carolina, came in fourth.

Obedience exercises are meant to represent good dog manners, safety needs (like stopping on command before running into the road) and certain herding or hunting skills.

The sport dates to the 1930s in the U.S., and the number of obedience contests sanctioned by the prominent American Kennel Club has grown in the last five years, from about 2,500 to 2,650 annually. But some other canine sports, such as agility, are growing faster.

"It's maybe not as flashy as agility, but it really cements the relationship between the owner and the dog" as they work out signals and read each other, said Dr. Merry Fitzgerald, a Lake Grove, New York, veterinarian who competed with Margot, a Doberman pinscher.

Most competitors train for at least a little bit almost every day. Handlers note that training methods have changed over the decades to emphasize rewards over punishment, and they say they strive to make training fun.

And yes, even obedience dogs sometimes can be mischievous.

"We often allow our dogs to be a little bit naughty in real life," Brennan said.

VYING FOR TOP DOG

The Best in Show will be named Tuesday night at Madison Square Garden.  This year, more than 3,000 dolled-up doggies from 197 breeds will be competing for the coveted title.

Some use enough hairspray and handlers to make a Kardashian jealous.

"You use the best products you can find (for your particular dog's coat)," said dog owner Maxine Rabinowe.

And who are the favorites to win Best in Show? It depends on who you ask.

Rumor, a 4-year-old German shepherd from Edgerton, Wisconsin, is among them. She was the No. 1 winning show dog in the country in 2015.

"She's a really good performer. She's built very well. And she's aesthetically very beautiful to look at," said Rumor's owner, Kent Boyles.

Regina Keiter, whose briard, Izzy is competing, said she's been coming to Westminster practically her entire life.

"This is always our World Series, our Super Bowl," she told 1010 WINS' Steve Kastenbaum. "This is it."

Dogs that make it this far are already outstanding examples of their breeds, so the judging becomes subjective.

"Everybody has their own opinion, and everybody interprets the standard differently, and everybody can look at the same dog and view it differently," Keiter said.

Anna Stromberg said for the dog owners this is a labor of love. There are no cash prizes.

"This is only costing us money," she said.

(TM and © Copyright 2016 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2016 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.