New Jersey’s 6 Best Cupcake Shops

Because of their versatility, cupcakes have taken the nation by storm. Specialty bakeries dedicated solely to cupcakes are springing up throughout New Jersey, all with their own gourmet twist and creative design for the delectable dessert. CBSNewYork takes a look at the highlights. By Emily Tamburri.

See Also: NYC’s Best Desserts | Best Chocolate In New York | NJ’s Best Wineries

Editor’s Pick: Confections Of A Rock$tar

Confections Cake Pops

(credit: Confections of a Rock$tar)

550 Cookman Ave.
Asbury Park, NJ
(732) 455-3510

MORE: The Jersey Shore’s 5 Best Restaurants

This isn’t your mama’s bakery! Owner Kimmee Masi, rock drummer by day, baker by night, combines her two loves in this Asbury Park bakery: Music and dessert. When you first walk into Confections, you might be fooled into thinking you’re in a music shop — with instruments adorning the walls and rock videos playing on the TV, but that will instantly change once you see the display case. There you’ll find a variety of aptly-named cupcakes like the “Oreo Speedwagon” (a vegan chocolate cupcake with Oreo frosting), the “Don’t Be Cruel” (Banana cake with peanut butter frosting topped with honey-dipped bacon) and “Strawberry Fields” (Strawberry cake with lemon buttercream frosting). Confections also offers cake pops, cake shots, cookies and custom theme cakes made to order for any occasion. They also have a dog-friendly cupcake “The Hound Dog” for your four-legged friends that is sure to please (my dog devoured it). Kimmee and crew are always coming up with new flavors, so I strongly suggest you stop by if you’re ever in Asbury Park. Or make a special trip – you’ll be glad you did. They make cake rock! – Billie Rama, Managing Editor,

Sweet Avenue Bake Shop

Sweet Ave Bake Shop153 Park Avenue
Rutherford, NJ 07070

For vegetarians, vegans and carnivores alike, Sweet Avenue’s vegan cupcakes are spectacularly sweet and far from bland. The eccentric cupcakes are on a rotating menu, so you’ll be sure to have a new surprise selection each time you visit. Offering both mini and regular-sized sweetness, these cupcakes run the gamut from traditional, to filled to specialty picture-screened toppings. Recent pop culture-oriented favorites have include Super Bowl XLVII cupcakes, the Steve Jobs Apple Cupcake, The Charlie Sheen Tiger Blood Cupcake and the Harry Potter Butterbeer Cupcake.

Mr. Cupcakes

mr cupcakes1 New Jerseys 6 Best Cupcake Shops

(credit: Mr. Cupcakes/Facebook)

1216 Van Houten Ave.
Clifton, NJ 07013

With three different locations in Clifton, Oradell and The Riverside Square Mall in Hackensack, your sweet tooth can’t hide from Mr. Cupcakes! These little cake morsels are astonishing, not only for 40+ varieties offered every day, but that the flavor comes from baking the ingredients right into the cupcakes—no filling here! Varieties like French Toast, Fruity Pebbles and Strawberry Shortcake are just some of the creative creations that line the Mr. Cupcakes shelves year round, with others such as S’mores and Tiramisu making a temporary menu appearance, so get them while they last!

Gimmee Jimmy’s Cookies and Bakery

gimme jimmys cookies and bakery New Jerseys 6 Best Cupcake Shops
27 Utter Ave,
Hawthorne, NJ 07506
1-800-4JIMMYS (454-6697)

Tucked away in a little corner of Hawthorne, NJ, Gimmee Jimmy’s cupcakes and multitude of other baked goods can be shipped wherever your cravings reside. These gourmet cupcakes are larger than the average, however remain moist and delicious. Gimme Jimmy’s cupcakes are not only fresh baked daily but are certified Kosher, as well as all of their other popular desserts.

Cupcakes by Carousel

classic pastel by cupcakes by carousel New Jerseys 6 Best Cupcake Shops

The Classic Pastel Cupcake (credit: Cupcakes By Carousel/Facebook)

192 East Ridgewood Ave.
Ridgewood, NJ 07450

Beautifully decorated with the freshest ingredients, Cupcakes by Carousel’s menu spices up classic cupcakes with every sugary sprinkle, candy, frosting and cream filled combination to take even simple vanilla to a whole new level! With precise and spectacular design, Cupcakes by Carousel creates works of art out of delectable little cakes that taste as heavenly as they look. As if these fancy little treats weren’t a good enough on their own, Cupcakes by Carousel also showcase specialty cupcakes that have a portion of their sales donated to charity—does it get sweeter?

Petite Café

petite cafc3a9 New Jerseys 6 Best Cupcake Shops

(credit: Petite Cafe)

503 Franklin Ave.
Nutley, NJ 07110

These stuffed cupcakes out of Nutley, N.J., were such a hit that, you can now find them in high demand at many retail locations throughout New Jersey, New York City and greater New York. The Petite Café offers the best stuffed cupcakes you can get your hands on, and are filled with every type of gourmet frosting, crème, chocolate and fruit. With quirky names and simple decorating techniques, The Petite Café’s cupcakes have enough options to satisfy every eater’s taste buds!

  • ITIL certification

    certainly like your web-site but you need to test the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling issues and I in finding it very bothersome to tell the reality then again I’ll definitely come again again.

  • אינדקס מתחתנים

    You realize thus considerably when it comes to this topic, produced me individually believe it from so many various angles. Its like women and men are not fascinated until it’s something to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs excellent. At all times handle it up!

  • catherine is to die for its the BEST!! cupcake are so out its all about the push up cake and she will deliver NY/NJ

  • Clara

    Link to Bella’s Bakery cupcake menu:

  • Clara

    I aa cupcake fanatic! The best cupcakes by far that I’ve tried (though I haven’t tried the stores below) is Bella’s Bakery in Millburn, NJ. All of their cupcakes are nut free and they even offer vegan treats. They also have a unique variety of flavors such as Chai Tea Latte (one of my favorites!). The red velvet is just heavenly. Their cupcakes are simply amazing. ‘Nough said.

  • Judy

    I second Blue Sheep Bake Shop in Greenbrook on Rt. 22. Awesome cupcakes and they are coming out with new flavor combinations all the time.

  • Sam

    The best cupcakes in NJ are at the Blue SHeep Bake Shop in Green Brook NJ, Blows the competition out of the water And they do specialty cakes like the ones you see on tv. They’re awesome! check out their website –

  • Natalie

    The best cupcake for me is Posh Pop Bakeshop because I am Gluten Free! they’re also soy free i think. All i know is they have the BEST and cutest cupcakes. My favorite is the blackforest. I ordered apple pie and cookies from them too because my daughter has celiac as well and she fell in love with them!

  • Rick Ross

    The Best Cupcakes on Earth are at Bucu in Paramus
    Scratch-Made cupcakes and cookies every day



  • Stella

    Not actually a cupcake store per say but BUCU on Route 4 in Paramus makes the best cupcakes I have ever tried. The cupcake store in Riverside Square and in Xlifton is awful.

  • Tina

    A’La Cupcakes in Glen Rock is better then the top 5 listed above! They all taste great but one of my favorites is the chocolate chip cookie cupcake!!

  • John

    You, by far overlooked the best cupcake shop in NJ, SUGARUSH in Red Bank!! They have a cupcake bar where you can dress any cupcake, any way you want and they have daily specials that are to die for! Next time you need to expand your search below North Jersey…or just say Best Cupcakes in North Jersey. (:

    • John

      PS – it is a quick trip to Red Bank via ferry and/or NJTransit from NY in under an hour.

  • Anthony Pepe

    cupcakes suck. eat a slice of cake and be done with it.

  • Patty

    best for gluten-free cupcakes is Fallon’s Glutenfree bake shop in Fords, NJ

  • Sara

    Sweet Indulgences in Dumont by far best cupcakes in NJ.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Giving Tuesday
Charles Osgood Event

Listen Live