CBS2-Header-Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

Tale of the tape

Week 1: New York Giants Vs. Dallas Cowboys

Super Bowl XLVI Dallas Cowboys v New York Giants

Giants

Cowboys

Eli Manning is coming off his second Super Bowl MVP season, and completed the season sweep of the Cowboys last year. His big-game ability is unquestioned, but he could be more consistent during the regular season. Quarterback The heat is on Tony Romo to up his performance level this year. Jerry Jones has run out of patience with him and if Romo is not a playoff winner this year, his career in Dallas will come to an end.
Victor Cruz should be able to pick up from where he left off because he is explosive and is much stronger than he appears. Hakeem Nicks is nearly as good and the Giants will get much more from running back Ahmad Bradshaw than they did a year ago. Offense The Cowboys have a nice looking receiving crew led by wideouts Dez Bryant and Isaac Austin along with tight end Jason Witten. The Cowboys need better play from the offensive line to get more out of the running game.
The Giants have the best front four in the NFL and Jason Pierre-Paul should be unstoppable this season. Throw in Justin Tuck and Osi Umenyiora and it's a quarterback’s nightmare. While the secondary is decent, the linebackers are just ordinary. Defense The hangover from last year will not be easy to get past. However, they have perhaps the best defensive player in the league in DeMarcus Ware. The Cowboys need more from Ratliff, who made the Pro Bowl on reputation a year ago.
Special teams played a huge role for the Giants in their championship run during the postseason. Steve Weatherford gets excellent distance and hang time on his punts. Special Teams The Cowboys were pleased with their coverage teams a year ago, and they also have confidence in placekicker Dan Bailey. The return game is below average and that’s not likely to change if Bryant doesn’t get a chance to return punts.

The winner is

Super Bowl XLVI
Giants
4 out of 4

The Giants didn’t look like a championship team until the final two weeks of the regular season last year. Tom Coughlin wants to see them get off to a much better start. The Cowboys are desperate to take charge in the NFC East and this would be a great time to assert themselves. Both teams have equal motivation, but the Giants have better weapons.

More Tales of the tape

  1. (Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images) (Photo by Ronald Martinez/Getty Images)
    National Championship Matchup: #8 Kentucky Vs. #7 Connecticut

    No. 8-seeded Kentucky stunned No. 2-seeded Michigan in the Elite Eight and shut down Wisconsin’s Frank Kaminsky and the Badgers offense in the Final Four.

  2. (credit: Andy Lyons/Getty Images) (credit: Jeff Gross/Getty Images)
    Semifinal Matchup: #8 Kentucky Vs. #2 Wisconsin

    Wisconsin—who was overshadowed by other top Big Ten teams in the tournament in Michigan and Michigan State—is now the last man standing and hoping to win it all with the likes of big man, Frank Kaminsky.

  3. (credit: Elsa/Getty Images) (credit: Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
    Semifinal Matchup: #7 Connecticut Vs. #1 Florida

    It was three years ago that Jim Calhoun led the UConn Huskies to the college basketball national championship. That Final Four included two of the teams in this year’s Final Four in UConn and Kentucky

See all Tales of the Tape