TOMS RIVER, N.J. (CBSNewYork) — Nighttime is fright time for a Toms River couple who claim the house they rented is haunted.

Jose Chinchilla and his fiancée Michele Callan say they hear eerie noises, that lights flicker, doors slam and a spectral presence tugs on their bed sheets.

READ MORE: Suspect Dies After Police-Involved Shooting In Williamsbridge Section Of Bronx

1010 WINS’ John Montone reports

The couple even called in investigators with the Shore Paranormal Research Society. The group classified the activity as “paranormal” but that it did not indicate a haunting, according to their website.

EXTRA: Click Here To See Video Of The Investigation

READ MORE: New York Giants Wrap Up In-Person General Manager Interviews

Chinchilla and Callan are suing the landlord for their $2,250 security deposit claiming the paranormal activity forced them out of the home only a week after moving in.

However, the landlord believes the couple was actually spooked by the $1,500 a month rental fee and made up the ghost story to get out of their lease.

The landlord has filed a counter suit against the couple.

A hearing is expected at the end of this month.

MORE NEWS: Seward Park High School Cheerleading Squad Raises Enough Money For Trip To Nationals

Do you believe the couple? Let us know below…