WANTAGH, N.Y. (CBSNewYork) – What started out as a routine fishing trip ended up with the skipper in a boatload of trouble.

Nassau Police said they arrested Anthony Marmo of Seaford for allegedly boating while intoxicated.

READ MORE: Police: Car Stolen From Chick-Fil-A Parking Lot In Suffolk County

Police said that at around 6 p.m. Sunday they received a call two men on a fishing trip were overboard in the Atlantic Ocean about a mile off of Jones Beach.

1010 WINS’ Carol D’Auria With More On The Story

Police said a 37-year-old man was thrown from the back of the boat and the other, 32, jumped in after him.

READ MORE: New York City To Hold 'Hometown Heroes' Ticker Tape Parade For Health Care Workers, First Responders, Essential Workers July 7

Police said Marmo, who was operating the boat, didn’t even realize the two were overboard until they were out of sight.

“The operator of the vehicle was in the cabin with the door closed on the cell phone, intoxicated and does not realize for several minutes that his two passengers are missing,” Police inspector Kenneth Lack told reporters, including 1010 WINS’ Carol D’Auria.

Lack said when Marmo finally looked around and realized his friends were gone, he called for help.  Lifeguards at Jones Beach spotted the men in the water and rowed out to save them.

MORE NEWS: Shocking Video: Masked Cyclist Stabs Delivery Worker In The Back With Large Knife In Woodhaven

They were not injured, according to police.