NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) – An online date ended with a crime instead of a kiss.

A man, nicknamed “Gooch” went on a date with a New Jersey woman he met through OKCupid and that’s where things went bad.

Police say the man stole his date’s car keys and car, a red Toyota Solara with vanity New Jersey tags saying “Jrsygrl.”

After searching for the suspect, the Waterford Township Police Department announced Saturday night they arrested Gerald Tietz in Cherry Hill, NJ. Police said a witness spotted the stole car and called authorities.

The suspect gave the name Gennaro Aladena and also used the name Mike Rossman.