NEW YORK (CBSNewYork/AP) — Michael Conforto and the New York Mets rallied just in time to keep their faint playoff hopes alive, beating the Miami Marlins 5-4 in 11 innings Tuesday night.

Three outs from postseason elimination, the Mets tied it 4-all in the ninth when Conforto clocked his second two-run homer of the game, connecting off José Ureña for his 33rd long ball of the season. Brandon Nimmo won it by working a bases-loaded walk in the 11th against rookie Jeff Brigham.

READ MORE: Suffolk County Officials Urge Residents To Check Out 'Smart 911' App To Help Emergency Responders Save Lives

Michael Conforto #30 of the New York Mets celebrates his two run home run in the bottom of the ninth inning to tie the game against the Miami Marlins at Citi Field on September 24, 2019. (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)

After wins by Washington and Milwaukee earlier in the day, the Mets needed a victory to stay in the playoff race. They are tied with the plummeting Chicago Cubs, five games behind the Brewers for the second NL wild card with five to play.

New York’s only hope of seeing October now rests on winning their last five games and the Brewers losing out to finish their season.

Conforto drew a leadoff walk from Adam Conley (2-10) in the 11th, and Brigham hit Amed Rosario with a 97 mph fastball. A wild pitch advanced both runners before Todd Frazier was intentionally walked.

One out later, Nimmo walked on a 3-1 pitch to force in the winning run. He sprinted to first base, where he was greeted by teammates and doused. Pete Alonso ripped off Nimmo’s jersey, leaving him soaked in a blue undershirt.

Paul Sewald (1-1), the seventh Mets pitcher, struck out two in a perfect inning for his first major league win in his 118th appearance. New York’s bullpen permitted one hit in six scoreless innings.

Miami prospect Isan Díaz homered early and hit an RBI single off Noah Syndergaard, who gave up 10 hits for the second consecutive start. Leadoff batter Jon Berti had three hits, an RBI and four of the Marlins’ six stolen bases — four against Syndergaard.

Miami was 6-for-6 until catcher Wilson Ramos, who didn’t start, threw out Harold Ramirez trying to swipe second for the final out of the 10th.

Tomás Nido was behind the plate for Syndergaard, who expressed to the Mets his preference of pitching to backups Nido or René Rivera rather than Ramos. The big right-hander lasted five innings and allowed four runs for the fourth outing in a row. He hasn’t gone six innings in any of them.

READ MORE: Boil Water Advisory Finally Lifted For 4 Northern New Jersey Towns

Regardless of his catcher, the right-hander has a poor 5.20 ERA in five September starts.

New York was 40-51 and all but forgotten after dropping its first game following the All-Star break. But the Mets made a surprising push and closed within two games of a wild card by finishing a four-game sweep of Arizona on Sept. 12. They’re 82-75, their third winning season in five years following a six-year drought.

Conforto went 3-for-4 in his sixth career multi-homer game and second this season — both against Miami.

Díaz became the first rookie to homer off Syndergaard and Mets ace Jacob deGrom in the same season.


2B Robinson Canó returned to the lineup. He received a scheduled rest Monday night, one day after getting hit by a pitch on his left big toe.

RHP Robert Gsellman (lat) would probably like to throw more live batting practice, manager Mickey Callaway said, and LF Dominic Smith (foot) could take swings against Gsellman again. But there’s no guarantee the team would activate either one of them off the injured list before the season ends.


Bidding for a second straight NL Cy Young Award, deGrom (10-8, 2.51 ERA) makes his final scheduled start this season. The right-hander entered Tuesday leading the league in strikeouts with 248 and WHIP at 0.99. He ranked second in ERA and fourth in innings (197). And he’s been finishing strong in September, with consecutive outings of seven scoreless innings the last two times out. He has pitched seven innings in seven straight starts and 11 of his past 12.

MORE NEWS: Ribbon Cutting Marks Official Opening Of NYC's Newest Pride Health Center In The Bronx

(© Copyright 2019 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)