Are Dark Sky Rules Making People Feel Less Safe?

ISLIP, NY (WCBS 880/1010 WINS) – Newly imposed “dark sky” rules are getting a second look in one Long Island town.

WCBS 880 Long Island Bureau Chief Mike Xirinachs reports

Under the argument that brighter lights make people feel safer, Islip town officials are considering amendments to its newly imposed dark sky rules.

Jeremy is one homeowner and businessman opposed to the tougher lighting restrictions. He applauds the amendments.

“More light is better,” Jeremy tells WCBS 880 Long Island Bureau Chief Mike Xirinachs. “I own a landscaping business and I’ve been robbed blind lately.”

Some argue the dark sky rules are healthier for people and the environment.

“They prescribe certain light levels on the ground for safety, when you don’t have enough light you can’t see well and when you have too much light you’re simply wasting energy,” Susan Harder of the Dark Sky Society told 1010 WINS.

“I think it’s misinformation coupled with a slight amount of paranoia, you know, just a general fear of the dark,” Harder added. “It’s a shame because none of these dark sky lighting regulations produce unsafe conditions.”

The town supervisor says the amendments will be considered.


One Comment

  1. Jim says:

    Dark sky rules are not meant to turn off lights, they are meant to direct lights where they are needed, and NOT into the sky, hence the name “dark sky rules.” You can keep the ground lit and keep the sky dark. It is better for the environment and saves money at the same time.

    I’d like to hear more of how the business owner has been “robbed blind.” He is not allowed to install any of those awful “uplights” perhaps? If so, I would imagine that this represents such a small segment of a landscaping business.

    Dark sky rules are not about less lighting they are about responsible lighting.

  2. Hal Mann says:


  3. altheajj says:

    People aren’t walking at night. They are driving/riding in cars. So the amount of light needed is perception not reality. Jeremy perhaps you need to put your inventory behind lock and key?

  4. Daniel P says:

    How the heck do you pronounce Xirinachs ? !

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE