02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo
Holiday Weekend: Traffic & Transit | Travel Guide Forecast | Monuments | Listen Live: 1010 WINS | WCBS 880

News

Family Fined $300 For Having Apple, Tomato, 3 Cucumbers In Backpack At Newark Liberty

Steinbergers Had Just Gotten Off Flight From Israel, Forgot About Kid's Snack

View Comments
Newark Airport Customs

A local family was fined $300 by Customs officials at Newark Liberty Airport for not declaring an apple, tomato and three cucumbers it packed in a child’s backpack prior to a flight from Israel. (Photo: CBS 2)

NYC Is A Strange Place

MONSEY, N.Y. (CBSNewYork) — A family of four from Florida visiting relatives in New Jersey got an unwelcome surprise at the Customs gate — all because of some forgotten fruit and vegetables.

The oversight was an expensive one that has the family fuming, reports CBS 2’s Sean Hennessey.

“I don’t have to be traumatized like this. Nobody should have to be traumatized,” Suri Steinberger said.

Suri and Peter Steinberger are livid after what they call an over-reaction by customs agents at Newark Liberty Airport. They were told they had violated a federal crime — forgetting about an apple, a tomato and three cucumbers in their son’s backpack.

“For me it was like, you know, what you see on TV. I thought I was going to get handcuffed, they have my kids. So I just started to cry,” Suri Steinberger said.

The run-in with Customs agents happened Thursday at the end of a long trip from Israel. Suri packed the vegetables as snack for her boys.

“Let them eat it on the plane instead of eating garbage,” Suri said.

The problem was she didn’t sit with her husband and two boys on the flight and Peter didn’t know the produce was in the bag.

So when the declaration form came around, Peter said he “checked no on all the boxes.”

Customs officials told Hennessey strict rules are for “agricultural integrity” and that passengers have multiple opportunities to amend the Customs declaration form.

“I have no idea what they mean by that except for the fact they say you should have been looking at the posted signs,” Peter said.

While passengers were stunned at the strictness, others said it was par for the course.

“Other countries do it, too. They’re pretty strict. I travel a lot for work and I get the same thing,” said Christine Colella of North Brunswick, N.J.

Customs did say it’s up to the discretion of the officer to “destroy” the product or “fine the traveler,” discretion this family said was sorely missing given the Customs sheet showing the prohibited items and their $300 fine.

“You’re coming off a flight after 19 hours. You’re all flustered. You don’t know what world you’re on. The first thing on your mind isn’t vegetables in your backpack,” Peter said.

The family hopes what happened is a lesson to others that even an innocent mistake at customs may be a costly one.

The Steinbergers said they don’t expect to get their money back but do plan on taking the case with higher ups at customs.

Please offer your thoughts in the comments section below.

View Comments
  • kpryan

    Oh well. At least we are safe from all the terrorists who want to kill us because they are jealous of all our Liberties.

    I can’t wait until the govt puts CCTV cameras inside our homes and at all the doors and windows so they know when we come and go and what we do in our abodes. That too will make us safe from the hoards of muslim terrorists who just hate all our freedoms and want to kill us because they don’t want us to be free.

    What we really need, though, is 1 HomeSecurityOfficer per American. Then we won’t have any more terror. The Officer is required to watch you (and my officer to watch me) 24 hours a day and report back to headquarters exactly what we are doing at all times. That will really save us from the evil people who hate our Constitution.

    • JJStryder

      That’s the beauty of it. There are more of us than them. The many ruled by the few. You must believe this to stay under control. But they really could never have complete control. Ever. That is the genius of natural law. Men try, but they never are able to have complete control over the human spirit. The founders knew this. Showed how men could rule themselves. That is our weakness and our strength at this moment in history.

    • Chili

      Whew! At least we’re safe from another terrorist tomato that hates our freedom.

      “I can’t wait until the govt puts CCTV cameras inside our homes.”
      That’s what Smart Meters are for. The utility companies want to strap one on every house in the U.S. U.K. No video (yet) but it will spy on everything happening in you’re home or apartment……besides irradiate you 24 hours a day.

  • Susan See

    I live close to the Canadian border and often shop at their superstore over there. There’s nothing like watching the customs officer, when coming back from the store, dumping all your oranges lemons and ground beef into a trash can. I know we need to monitor produce, etc. because I lived in CA during the medfly invasion and we were stopped on the highway and screened for any fruit we might be carrying. That agricultural crisis tells you what can happen if we aren’t vigilant. If you want to see strict, try going into Australia with anything banned. They scare the pants off you.

  • http://tracesofevil.com lairdkeir

    “Other countries do it, too. They’re pretty strict.” Which countries? Saudi Arabia? Pakistan? China? All America’s new-found friends and allies? Thank God I live in Germany, a country that knows all too well the dangers inherit in a state where those with power over everyone else overstep their mandate to trample on the happiness, well-being and livelihood of the common man. The state looks after its people whilst allowing them to live as they see fit without undue interference. The US however seems more and more to be following a fascist route; as its influence diminishes around the world, it seeks to enforce its dominance upon its own people. There doesn’t appear to be any hope given the general decline in its education system and completely ignorant, unqualified people who run for office and are given headlines due to notoriety rather than experience and ability. What a dystopia the US has become, and we in Europe, grateful for the US of three generations ago, can only shake our heads and bemoan the loss of a former model and friend.
    http://www.tracesofevil.com

    • greg

      Wow, ease up man. I’m glad you live in Germany. My ansestors immigrated here 3 generations ago from there. Guess they were looking for something better. We can not always have it our way with politicians and governments. You above all sbould know that. But we deal with it because we have to, eh?

    • Auric Maston

      Honestly everything you said about the U.S. and this administration’s fondness for Communist despotic regimes like China and Islamists like the others you mentioned. And the troublesome trends and the sort of armchair psychoanalysis of the American frame of mind, all true.

      Now, separate from that, I’d say that you’re overlooking that as a German citizen you’re also in the E.U. and I do believe that means that all your food is generally cleared for all of the E.U. It’s like a eurorail pass. Stuff moves around inside from country to country and it’s almost like state-to-state here in the U.S.

      My two cents.

    • USA

      I live is the USA 50 years now. USA has changed in just that little bit of time from GREAT place to live to a WORSE place to live. It is getting worse and worse and who knows where it will end up.

      I feel so bad about it all since I love my country. sad but true.

    • Joe C

      I disagree with the later post. Sounds like you know what’s going here more then many of the people that were BORN here. They’ll just mock you and then go stick their heads back into the sand and pretend we aren’t on a destructive tyrannical path…

  • greg

    You guys still don’t get it. It’s all about bugs. That’s why there are inspection stations when you enter California and Arizona. Some idiot brings a peach with fruit flies and the whole state crop goes to hell. Now we have Japanese Beetles, Gypsy Moths, Stink Bugs, you name it. These creatures were all imported by someone who wasn’t paying attention or didn’t know any better. This is exactly why we have customs and Agriculture inspection stations. Have you ever tried to grow food? Do you like going hungry or paying ridiculous prices at the grocery store? I have to agree with the majority of the posts here. Figure it out, pay attention, respect our soveriegnity, or stay the hell out!

    • LarryG

      Yeah. You have Mexicans, too, and they are a far worse threat than produce blight.

      • Larry you’re a racist idiot!

        Larry you’re a racist idiot!

    • Grace

      Greg, you have to be kidding me. All if these illegals sneaking in and bringing every “bug” and disease in the world and that’s OK with you. But fine the heck out of American citizens who make a mistake with a snack in their backpack. It’s not about bugs, it is about humiliating people whenever you get the chance. It is about breaking the American spirit every chance the government sees available to do so. Don’t comfort yourself with the “official line.”

  • roger Angles

    I travel with military all over the world and our aircraft / baggage getted thoughly checked. If we are not in complaince they fine our aircraft commander….it can be as high as $10,000.00 for the aircraft. It is everyones responsibilty to insure that the foods/fruits are bagged prior to landing for disposal. The fine they got is mild…..went through China recently…..they don’t believe in PC and they don’t have problems with people breaking their rules. If we quit catering to every cry baby that comes along we could get the country back on track……besides the steinbergers probably saved that much by not buying the airline food. After about 15 hours of 19 hour flight no one got hungry? What did they eat if they packed the veggies to avoid the “garbage” the airlines served? Shut up and pay your fine.

    • Susan See

      Just a note to tell you the explanation is in the text as to why they didn’t eat it.

      • Sactalerian

        So in 19 hours she couldn’t get up and get the veggies for her kids to eat?

    • Grace

      What a buch of hooey! Play right into their hands and grovel while the Illegals are just waltzing in with all of the “bugs” and diseases in the world. WHAT A JOKE!

  • iggy

    if you are flying and have an unopened bottle of water before the gates, they just take it away from you. why didn’t the TSA just take the food and warn them for the next time they fly? why did the judge fine them? couldn’t they have just been reprimanded?

    • Auric Maston

      because a bottle of water obtained in the US is bottled water that the US gov’t says ‘hey, it’s water; thats’s no big deal’. But if it were the same thing coming into the country instead of moving around in it, it would necessitate higher scrutiny presumably and it might get treated the same as these people’s vegetables.

    • Diane Emmerich

      To all the idiots that are blaming the TSA (and I am no fan of the TSA), it was US customs that fined these cry babies. I have no doubt that they put up a big whiney drama scene at customs and so the customs agent opted for a fine instead of just destroying the stuff and leting it go at that. I work in the airline industry and have heard enough whiney “nobody told me” or “I didn’t know”s to make your head explode. They were warned and advised. They were stupid, end of story.

      • NOBODY ABOVE THE LAW

        thank you Diane, I couldn’t have said it any better.

  • anikonov

    I did not know that Florida is no longer in the US union!

    I guess it is the way how New Jersey is protecting its own market for produce…

  • ken

    They came from the middle east, who knows what they could of been bringing in on their fruit, They should of stayed there, no one is above the law, regardless who they are.

  • JoeyCiantasy

    Wow You really want to make it a case of anti semitism! I reread this article a couple of times in an attempt to find that claim! You jewish?

    • JJStryder

      So you missed the whole vegetable fine thing?

  • ProFromDover

    Customs should have confiscated and destroyed the contraband, end of story. When my sister and I returned from Rome 25 years ago with some killer Panini from Rome (and unaware it was a no-no) the Customs folks merely mildly chastised us, told us we should have consumed them on the plane, confiscated them and that was that. This generation of officials are morons who need to get out more…

    • JJStryder

      “So you should have eaten them on the plane?”. So that doesn’t bother you? Do you see the level of acceptance we have for this?

    • Sactalerian

      Yes, they confiscated it and that was that. It also happened to me once, “and that was that”. But with this people its obvious that that wasn’t that. They more than likely threw a hissy-fit and that’s why they got fined.

      I mean, look we are reading about it in the news, how do you think that came about? They obviously weren’t done with their hissy-fit and called the news.

      Read the last paragraph, it says they’ll continue with their hissy-fit and contact the “higher-ups” at customs.

      • JJStryder

        BAAAAAH!

  • Jim

    Too bad, they should have packed a lawyer in there as well. Seems with all the BS the air industry and government is coming up with these days, a person should hire their own attorney to travel with them wherever they fly! When did we stop thInking for ourselves and allow common sense to die? I guess right after personal responsibility died, it’s sister, common sense was the next to go!!

    • JJStryder

      Now what?

  • B. Hans

    When i travelled to Taiwan, I had eaten all my fruit but, out of habit, stuck my apple core in the plastic sandwich bag the apple had been in. and then forgot about it. While awaiting my luggage, a Taiwanese police woman asked very politely is she could look in my carry on bag because her little beagle was trying to hump it. She found my apple core and just said that she had to dispose of it. Then she praised her dog and gave it a dog bone award. She praised in in English so as to not be so impolite as to leave me out of the conversation.

    • JJStryder

      Nice of her wasn’t it?

  • Paula W

    And we have a $200.00 fine.
    And people jump up and down throwing fits over this also.
    If you do the crime, then do the time…

    Do you know how many peole say….’oh I forgot’
    Just like people who drive without a seat-belt..’Oh I forgot, please do NOT fine me’
    I am SO innocent

    • JJStryder

      Too bad we couldn’t get this level of security at our own southern border. Are you that strident when it comes to illegal immigration? Just asking!

    • Martha

      If they forgot, then they are somewhat innocent. What is your point?

  • Paula W

    Time to grow up and get a life, and stop throwing the toys out of the cot.
    You wold NOT be allowed into New Zealand with food produce either, and there are sign up everywhere explaing why we have a green clean country to protect.
    For those who REFUSE to obey the rules then do not travel.
    If you cannot rerspect another countries rules and regulations to protect its citizens and safety of its much sort after produce, then do not come here, we do not want you.

    • JJStryder

      You have many good points. But Come on! A $300.00 fine? You don’t find that troubling?
      P.S. “Toys out of the cot.” haven’t heard that before. What the hell does it mean?

  • Annoyed

    Are these people career veggie smugglers? $300 is over the top.

    They have every right to be angry, p*ssed off, highly upset. But “traumatized”? Get a grip, folks.

  • abominable

    The law is there to protect all of us. Whenever one comes back from overseas, the ban on fruits , vegetables, meats and cheese are there on the custom form. It is their responsibilities to check all their carry ons for contrabands. If they were careless, they had to take responsibilities for their own action. There were not singled out because they were Jewish. They were fined for infraction of the law, over and out.

    • YES IS ALL TRUE!

      YES IS ALL TRUE!

  • liz

    so anyone can forget about anything were all human-why should they get such a large fine for an honest mistake!?

  • Nicole

    Diseases and pests can be carried in produce causing millions of dollars in damage to American farmers. People think they know better. People are stupid. We’ve got problems now in the states because people bring in animals and vegetables that shouldn’t be here. Enter the kudzu vine in the south or the flying fish in the great lakes. Better yet, ask someone in Florida about the big snakes they have because exotic pet owners thought their “pets” were too big for their homes.

    • aubreyfarmer

      For the first time I am seeing the Chinese stink bugs and they have destroyed every piece of fruit on my pear, peach and plum trees. I read that they were released accidentally. By who? And what was done about it? Why were these pests brought to the US in the first place? You can bet it wasn’t an individual but some big agriculture corporation. You or I get nailed to the wall for minor mistakes, but big business can turn our whole world up side down and not face any criminal prosecution. How many hundreds of millions of dollars in damage will be done by the stink bugs. Who reimburses me for all of the damage? No one, that’s who.

  • angel

    What happens if you get low blood sugar, or your diabetic ?

    • Frank

      What happens if you can’t determine the difference between your and you’re?

      • dismissive boor

        What happens if you’re anal retentive about another’s English usage while avoiding his question?

    • pitbullzandhandgrenades

      What happens if it was an A and B conversation? You should C your way out of it!!!

      • mathgenius

        What happens if I can’t do math?

  • bodog

    Give ‘em the chair!

  • Takb

    American is now POOR. Customs will have to make money so that they could get paid on time. Same thing with parking tickets to run the government in New York. ZERO tolerance otherwise; do not expect next pay check. Alas this country would not have gone for Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

    • Diane Emmerich

      Your post is illogical and stupid. what does Iraq and Afghanistan have to do with bringing potentially harmful pests, bacteria or fungi into the US that could harm our agriculture? DUH

  • US_Traveler

    Sometimes they give apples as part of veggie diet airline food.
    Are these also prohibeted entry?
    Even in pre 9/11 time US ICE
    (then called Customs and INS) was the most barbaric in the western world. Now ICe is completely out of control and of common sense.
    .

    • Keisha

      That is an idiotic question.

      • jeff

        Serves ‘em right. They should be locked up and water boarded. How they they disrespect the TSA rules.

  • Jenny Lee

    mary lou, there is nothing anti semitic when it’s about complying with the Law. everyone for years received the same treatment even when they did it without understanding it’s illegal, yet they had to pay the fine and had their produces detained and detroyed and didn’t go to complain to a News channel, why should the Steinbergers receive preferential treatment? Customs have this written to prevent bugs and infections to be introduced by fruits or vegetables in the U.S. for your and my health benefit. their long flight and having kids doesn’t make them an exception of complying with the law.

    • Takb

      I still think that it was over-reaction by the customs. The family was carrying it for personal consumption and surely not going to affect any ones health.

  • Kiss Freedom Goodbye

    Since we do not live in a free country any longer, and the USA now resembles the USSR more than anything, I am surprised they weren’t sent to the gulag.

    • Sage

      You can’t be serious. Don’t you know anything about agriculture and pest control? This has nothing to do with your freedom, Einstein.

  • mary lou

    I think that this is an outrage and these customs agents should apologize for their anti semitic behaviors.

    • Sue in soCal

      I did not realize that confiscating contraband produce was anti-semitic. I do think the fine was over the top.

    • Diane Emmerich

      When logic fails you, just bring out the race card

      • Mohawk

        Exactly, RACE CARD the ACE IN THE HOLE!!! ;-/

1 2 3 9
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video