NEW YORK (WFAN/AP) — When Terry Francona left the Red Sox, he said they needed “a new voice” in the manager’s office.
They’ve certainly chosen a brash one.
Right, Mets fans?
As manager of the Amazin’s from 1996-2002, Bobby Valentine was known to clash with general manager Steve Phillips. In April 2000, he criticized the team’s front office and some players, including Bobby Bonilla and Rickey Henderson, while speaking to students at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business.
And famously, after being ejected from a game in 1999, he returned to the dugout wearing a fake mustache and sunglasses. Major League Baseball fined him $5,000 and suspended him for three games.
“He can be polarizing, there’s no question about that,” Phillips told Boston’s WEEI Radio on Wednesday. “But he’s also one of the best students of the game. He’s a great teacher. I came across Bobby when I was a minor league player in the Mets farm system, and he was the most impactful coach I ever had contact with.”
He added: “I think he’s going to do a terrific job, I really do. I know that he and I had our battles at times, but he’s a very, very bright baseball man, and somebody that can handle both veteran players and and young players.”
So just two months after a record collapse kept them out of the playoffs, the Red Sox have picked Valentine to be their next manager. The sides are working to complete a contract, according to multiple reports.
“I think he’s going to have immediate success,” said Phillips. “He was eight years in Texas, seven years in New York. I have no reason to doubt that that range is at least within his grasp.”
An announcement could come by Thursday.
“He’s got it. I just spoke to him a little while ago,” Hall of Famer Tommy Lasorda, who managed Valentine in the minors with the Los Angeles Dodgers, said in a telephone interview with the Associated Press.
Blunt, cocky and sometimes controversial, Valentine is quite a departure from Francona, a player’s manager who rarely went public with criticism of players or internal team problems.
More recently, the 61-year-old Valentine has been working as an analyst for ESPN, where he has commented on several Red Sox players, saying pitcher Josh Beckett should work faster and left fielder Carl Crawford should close his stance.
Valentine’s style can be abrasive, sure, but few question his baseball acumen. He guided the Mets to consecutive playoff appearances, culminating in a trip to the 2000 World Series, where they lost to the Yankees. He went to Japan and managed the Chiba Lotte Marines to a championship in 2005.
“Bobby’s a fixer,” said Phillips. “That’s how I looked at him. The challenge will be his sustaining it for the long term. That’s been the area where we weren’t able to do together in New York. He had some level of success in Texas but didn’t sustain it for the long term. He had some success in Japan but it wasn’t a long term.”
Valentine also managed the Texas Rangers from 1985-92. His last big league managerial job was with the Mets, and he managed in Japan from 2004-09.
He was in Japan this week and said he was about to take off on a flight when he sent the AP a text message at 9:48 p.m. Tuesday saying he had no comment on “the Red Sox situation.”
The manager’s job has been vacant since Francona parted ways with the Red Sox on Sept. 30, saying he wasn’t getting through to the players. The team didn’t pick up his option for 2012.
That ended an eight-year run in which Francona led the Red Sox to World Series titles in 2004 and 2007.
They led the AL East for much of last summer but went 7-20 in September, wasting a nine-game lead in the wild-card race and finishing out of the playoffs for the second straight year, one game behind Tampa Bay.
That was followed by reports of starting pitchers drinking beer and eating fried chicken in the clubhouse during games in which they weren’t scheduled to pitch instead of staying on the bench to support their teammates.
“I trusted them explicitly and things weren’t getting done the way I wanted it in the end,” Francona said at the news conference where his departure was announced, “and I was frustrated because of that. If that’s letting me down, maybe it is.”
With a fresh, forceful voice at the helm, maybe the players will become better listeners.
Valentine interviewed on Nov. 21 with general manager Ben Cherington and other members of Red Sox management.
Asked at a news conference that day about his philosophy of discipline, Valentine said, “Discipline is not 30 whacks with a whip these days. But I think everyone likes discipline. I think everyone likes structure. Everyone likes to be acknowledged when they do things properly. Discipline and rules and things like that — it’s just about right and wrong.”
Not since Kevin Kennedy left as manager after the 1996 season have the Red Sox had a manager who seems to enjoy the spotlight as much as Valentine. Jimy Williams, Joe Kerrigan and Grady Little followed Kennedy and preceded Francona.
A native of Connecticut and a former roommate of Bill Buckner’s, Valentine wasn’t on the Red Sox original five-man list of candidates. That group included Gene Lamont, Dale Sveum, Torey Lovullo, Pete Mackanin and Sandy Alomar Jr., all major league coaches.
Sveum was hired as manager of the Chicago Cubs by former Boston GM Theo Epstein.
Lamont was the only one in that bunch who had managed extensively in the majors, and the Red Sox expanded their search to include Valentine.
On Nov. 3, he and Red Sox president and part owner Larry Lucchino took part in Hartford in a program put on by the World Affairs Council on the global rise in the popularity of baseball.
At the time, both said they hadn’t discussed the job with each other.
“He’s a great man and a great manager and he has a colorful and successful history, so his name inevitably comes up in this day and age,” Lucchino said then.
After his interview 2½ weeks later, Valentine said if he got the job, “I would feel like it is Christmas.”
The son-in-law of former major league pitcher Ralph Branca, Valentine has a 1,117-1,072 record as a big league manager but has never finished in first place in 15 seasons.
He could have a chance to do that in 2012 with a team that was a popular preseason pick to reach last season’s World Series.
“I’m happy for him,” Lasorda said. “I think the Red Sox got themselves a good manager. In all my years, I’ve never seen a guy prepare a team for a game like he does. That’s what makes him unique.”
Yankees, Mets fans: How do you feel about Bobby V managing in Beantown? Be heard in the comments below…
(TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)