02Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

News

Parents Furious Over Apparent Use Of ‘Scream Rooms’ Inside Middletown, Conn. Elementary School

Father: Kids Hitting Their Heads On Walls, Urinating Inside 'Time-Out' Room

View Comments
Farm Hill Elementary School

Farm Hill Elementary School (Photo: CBS 2)

MIDDLETOWN, Conn. (CBSNewYork) – Parents in a Connecticut suburb are outraged over disturbing disciplinary actions at a local elementary school.

They claim students are being locked in unsupervised “scream rooms,” where some children have harmed themselves, reports CBS 2’s Hazel Sanchez.

The Middleton School District is on the hot seat as furious parents are demanding to know what’s going on behind closed doors at Farm Hill Elementary School.

“My daughter is telling me that there’s kids being taken out in ambulances, by stretcher,” parent Sean Archer told CBS 2’s Hazel Sanchez on Wednesday.

Disturbing allegations have surfaced of teachers locking students in closet-sized concrete “scream rooms” for punishment.

“Kids come home and they cry, because they’re afraid to go to school. And it’s often,” parent Brian Robillard said.

“She can hear the kids screaming at the top of their lungs, while she’s trying to read and she asks her teacher what’s going on and they never give her an answer. They tell her to ignore it,” said Liz Archer, the sister of one Farm Hill student.

Parents said their children have witnessed teachers placing unruly students into the tiny “time-out” rooms to calm down.

“From what I heard it’s more traumatizing for the child than it was as a help,” parent Jeff Daniels said. “Kids were hitting their heads on the concrete wall. Kids were urinating in the room.”

School Superintendent Michael Freschette said allegations of children harming themselves in the timeout rooms are not true. However, the Board of Education is investigating. The chairman spoke to CBS 2’s Sanchez by phone Wednesday night.

“We certainly are concerned with these allegations and I’m looking into every single one of them to be certain that our staff is providing a safe environment for our students,” Gene Nocera said.

Two “time-out” rooms were implemented two years ago for special needs students. But with growing community concern about their use, the school district drafted a new support plan to deal with students who act up.

“I can tell you, students across the board in that school are not safe right now. They’re not learning,” parent Tricia Bielan said.

While the school district has proposed a support plan to handle student behavior problems, it does want parents’ input. Parents can voice their opinions at a meeting at the school Thursday night.

The state Office of Protection and Advocacy for Persons with Disabilities and the state Child Advocate are now investigating the school’s use of “time-out” rooms.

Please offer your thoughts in the comments section below. …

View Comments
  • warbaby

    Schools are what they were designed to be. A place to send your children under the disguise of education so the govt can take more of your money in the form of taxes and expose your kids to teachers who just like other humans that are drunks, pill poppers, sadistic, just plain not qualified. This is just the tip of the iceberg as to what is going on in schools. No child wants to fail the system assures this will happen. Parents need to seriously wake up and demand to know what is going on in the schools. The system has made it very convenient for parents to be free of the responsibility of educating your own children. Some good reading on how the system destroys your child’s mind is ” Crisis In The Classroom” by Charles Silberman. There are a lot of good books out there exposing the horror of the educational nightmare. The Angels weep.

    • Geno

      I hope you are volunteering in your school to try and make it better. This system does not make parents abdicate their responsibilities – it is the VICTIM of that!

    • Scott Whiddon

      I know about other states, but in Texas, if a child is emotional disabled, then parent knows ahead of time and has approved the use of a time out room. It is strange that so many people are trying to “protect” these violent screamers and not considering how dangerous it is for the other kids around them that are being verbally assaulted and physically assaulted with desks, chairs, sharp pencils and scissors. What do you propose, evacuate the school all the classrooms in the hallway until they calm down (HOURS LATER)…now that’s good learning for you.

  • lda

    I’m 65 and our nursery school would put you by yourself in a dark empty room with your nap rug if you talked during naptime. In elementary school, our principal spanked with a wooden swatter and even put masking tape over a kid’s eyes for awhile for throwing rocks to demonstrate how it feels to be blind. In my opinion, none of this hurt anyone. I’d hate to be a teacher today…

    BTW, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with kids picking our crops either.

    • KareemAfweet

      From another Senior Citizen, well stated Ida.

    • KareemAfweet

      When you and I were kids, misbehavior in school resulted in double punishment, first at the hands of the Principal and then at the hands of your parents at home when they found out about it. My solution to the problem of misbehavior or disruption in today’s schools would be to call the parents if there was an incident involving their child and give them one hour to retrieve the child from school. If they weren’t there in an hour, child protective services should be called and the parents could deal with the situation on that level.

      • we r doomed

        Sounds like a good plan.

    • American Patriot

      I had a sadistic asshole for a principal like that in elementary school. He was eventually fired and drank himself to death.

      • rufus levin

        you are NOT an American Patriot…you are a smart mouthed idiot.

  • Scott

    Ok, so let me see if I have this straight. The teachers place theses “unruly children” in a concrete room alone and unsupervised and then lock the door. If a parent did this, they would be jailed for child abuse. But because they change the terminology to “screaming room” its legal???

  • TheChairman

    Let’s lock teachers and administrators in these rooms… for 24 hours of ‘time out’.

    • Scott Whiddon

      we are often tempted to go in there voluntarily!!! :-)

  • Ghostsouls

    Ok first of all I am gonna say right up front the concept of this “scream room” is BS!!! But I would like to know what to do with all the unruly, belligerant and violent children in our schools today??? You can’t put them in a room, you can’t spank them, you can’t hold them down, you can’t detain them, you can’t call the police on them, you can’t kick them out of school and deny them an education, you try to call the parents and they don’t want to be bothered or won’t even answer the phone because they know why you are calling, you can’t sit them in the principal’s office all day every day, some are medicated and it doesn’t work or the parents don’t consistently give it to them….. so what do you do? Our schools are getting more and more of these children EVERY year, it is probably already an epidemic of these type of children. Some are from mental illness, some are from neurological problems, some are from bad parenting or NO parenting, but what ever the reason they are making so the OTHER children who deserve an education, doesn’t get one either. There needs to be a coalition put together to do something, this is happening in every state, every school. Something needs to be done. Instead of demanding no tolerance, parents to actually parent, medication actually to be given, promote responsibility of the parents and children, and conformance in school to get an education… they lower the bar, no more PE, no more home work, no striving to be better everyone is a winner, no one loses… this is part of the problem that needs to be dealt with now. Get rid of the Dept of Education and put real scholars onto this problem.

    • Paul Revere

      Privatize the school system, parents send to the schools that work, the schools that dont work, fail. Churches have plenty of money to operate schools in poor neighborhoods for folks who cant pay tuition. The information they learn is free, the tuition simply goes to pay for overhead and labor. Money is never an excuse for not receiving a solid baseline education.

      • Geno

        How much are you willing to pay for this privatized system? LOL. Get ready to pay MUCH more for quality. Your church comment is so unrealistic it is laughable.

  • Midge Martin

    “The aim of public education is not to spread enlightenment at all; it is simply to reduce as many individuals as possible to the same safe level, to breed a standard citizenry, to put down dissent and originality” ~ H. L. Mencken

    http://911essentials.com

  • Joseph McLinden

    If their parents would teach their children NOT to scream in school and would monitor their children’s behaviors, teachers and administrators would not have to lock them up like animals. No school is looking for trouble. However, with Classroom Management now a primary prerequisite among ALL public school teachers, it almost seems fitting that the problem-kids have a opportunity to have a good scream where it won’t bother anyone.

  • SandyLester

    Well, that’s what happens when you try and main stream special needs kids.

    • B

      I wen to high school with an autistic boy in the early 70′s. He did pretty well considering all of the harassment he got at the hands of the other boys. He was a good kid, but occasionally he had to be brought back within the same limits that we all had to live with.

      I should add that his parents did everthing they could to give him a normal childhood. Seemed to have worked.

  • SandyLester

    Its what happens when you try and main stream special needs kids.

  • Haelly

    Wow, nice to see so many helpful comments written by adults.

  • Paladin

    Most distressingly, virtually everyone here is missing the point. I agree with what posters say about government schools and leftism, but their (rightful) hostility towards those things has blinded them to the obvious. Namely, how bad does the parenting have to be to breed children who would behave so manically in the first place? If you had locked me in a room in elementary school, I can assure you that I wouldn’t have screamed at the top of my lungs or beat my head against the wall. And, quite frankly, that’s psychotic behavior.

    The main story here shouldn’t be that kids were isolated. After all, if they were behaving that way, they likely needed to be (or would anyone prefer that they harmed another child?). The story should be that we’re breeding children who behave like asylum inmates.

    Wise up, folks.

    • A Teacher from the Bronx

      We are dealing with little children here. Granted, they probally have problems at home and/or do not recieve the proper discipline at home. This however does not constitute the use of such a room. You place a child (5,6,7,8) in a tiny room, its going to scare the heck out of them. I fail to see the benifits from this type of discipline. It is borderline child abuse (if not torture in their minds). Children know to play, communicate, learn, love and express themselves in various manners which will provide the insight into their personal lives, have compassion people. I know it is hard being a teacher, but we need to come up with a better method than this.

      • Jennifer

        OK so you read Michael Savage’s book, congratulations for being a good little parrot!

        Try to remove the ideological blinders and absorb what Bronx Teacher is saying…the children who were locked in the scream rooms were special needs children. Did you know that conservative parents also give birth to special needs children? Maybe you would understand their plight better if you knew it was Rush Limbaugh’s kid, or Sarah Palin’s little Piper locked up in that room, banging her head against a concrete wall. Maybe then you would be able to feel a little compassion.

        (Even Michael Savage, with his background as a scientist would easily identify this treatment of children as sadistic torture.)

        • Paladin

          Sorry, Jenny, but you’re wrong. And guess what? When some of these unruly brats aren’t isolated when having a meltdown and seriously injure another child, maybe that child will be yours. I wonder what you’ll say then.

          As for “special-needs” children, why is it that we didn’t have these problems when I was in elementary school? I grew up in the Bronx, I should mention, in a working-class neighborhood, and we NEVER saw such behavior. No meltdowns, no gross disobedience. Hmm, I guess we were genetically different back then.

          It is you, young lady, who are the parrot. You’re parroting the spirit of the age without even asking yourself if the theories in question make sense. Clue: If a given problem was infinitely rarer in an earlier time, it indicates that it is a function of upbringing, not genetics.

    • Mike

      Unfortunately many of these children are this way because the parents abused drugs and alcohol. Not only do these kids have neurological problems, but because of the parents own problems, the kids come to school with no social skills, and no preschool learning. It is quite sad and quite apparent these kids are being raised by video games and tv. The school staff hands are tied as they cannot touch the children or discipline them. And the numbers of these kids increase each year.

      • Jennifer

        Actually thei school staff’s hands are not tied, you say they cannot touch the children or discipline them? How do you think the children get into the concrete locked room, they just merrily skip and hop their way into the torture chambers?

        An adult – or two or three, of necessity needs to touch the child in order to place him in the room.

        So no, the school staff’s hands are not tied. If they were, no children would be locked in a scream room or tied in a duffel bag.

        • Ghostsouls

          yes they are tied, the newspaper is FULL of stories about teacher who held, children trying to calm them, teachers who were violently attacked, but tried to protect themselves then got in trouble for it, police who were called and then got in trouble for it… apparently you don’t read the news online. Just touch one child and their parents will have you fired or sue the school so quick it will make your head swim. AND might I just add, the reason we are here on this forum is because this school TRIED to control these children, but now a lawsuit will follow and teachers and educators will probably get fired… so get a dose of reality Jennifer. You sound like one of those child therapists, that have no children.

  • A Teacher from the Bronx

    Heads need to roll for this. This type of behavior by the school is unacceptable and is completly an abuse in power. I have 25 years in the public school system in NYC (P.S 46 Bronx) and I have never seen a case where this type of discipline would be acceptable and I taught in the BRONX !! Parents need to sue and personnel need to be relieved of their positions.

    @Cat- Its a good thing you don’t teach anymore, I would have fired you the second you mentioned a “time out” room. The abuse you inflict onto your kids is a reflection of your poor parenting skills and is probally why you no longer teach. You said you taught for 5 years lol, teachers aid in a daycare doen’t count. Allow A TEACHER to comment, not a 5 year baby sitter who could not hack the job and neglects disciplining her own children and abuses them by locking them in their room.. Your childhood must have been horrible.

    • Jennifer

      It had to be said.

  • jimonthebeach

    Cat, I don’t know where you taught, but in Florida putting a child in a “closet sized concrete scream room” is called “caging” and it’s a felony child abuse charge. There’s a very fine line between your form of discipline and false imprisonment. Be careful you don’t step over it. I really don’t think NPR is an authoritative venue for finding “the latest tantrum research” information.

    • American Patriot

      I think it’s allowed as long as the child is not white.

  • L. Buren

    http://fisherman209.blogspot.com

    If that is actually taking place, the school needs to be shut down pending a full investigation and teachers fired. And as a parent, if it were my kid and it took place, some teachers would be receiving a real good ass whooping.

  • mameshki

    Sounds good to me given the treatment nuns and teachers of yore meted out to unruly kids. God forbid a teacher look cross ways at little Johnny or bratty Mary-Keyrist, just look at the parents. In some cases one cant tell the difference between the parent or child. I like it when the parent calls the kid “hey dude”. No wonder we have such morons coming out of schools these days.

  • shocked

    cat, you are a loudmouth who abuses her children with cruel liberal punishments. My children have never once needed a time-out and if some government teacher placed my child in a box I’d punch their lights out. Sounds like you just have tantrums and lock your kids up when you can’t handle your responsibilities.

    • dog

      amen

    • Jennifer

      Clearly an anger-management case, as is evidenced by the inability to communicate without virtually screaming at total strangers.

      (Allcaps is the blog equivalent of yelling).

      cat: you’re uncontrollable! We’ve decided to lock you in a concrete closet!

  • Joel L.

    Yet another reason why my children will never step foot in a filthy, dangerous government school or be exposed to incompetent liberal union teachers and administrators. Its pathetic what passes for an education in this declining country.

    • Homeschooler

      I couldn’t agree more Joel. Notice that the parents continue to send their children there regardless of the dangers. If they didn’t have somewhere to dump them during the day they couldn’t afford the payments on their new SUV and the mortgage on their McMansion.

      • Jeff Campbell

        You make a valid point, however Parents pay Taxes out the Nose and deserve a better public system than this, but the trouble is Parents have very little say so as to how thier Schools operate, in fact I’m an old guy and a I remember the school did what the parents voted for them to do and no one in Washington dictated them like they do today. Also I would liike to point out that , like you, I homeschooled some of my children and I’m glad I was able too, but in many districts that I have spoken to, Schools make it very hard for parents to Home School by means of regulations, Social Workers etc.

    • Geno

      Most public school operate quite well each day. Millions of students and teachers interact in safe, exciting learning environments where students are not only cared for but tolerated. I think we’re all glad with your haughty and ill-informed attitude that you are your children are not in public schools as well. Not all teachers are liberal and not all are unionized. You are rude…and wrong.

  • MrLogical

    Frechette and a host of others need to be removed from their positions and the rooms shut down. This idea of ‘mainstreaming’ so-called”special needs” kids is yet another aspect of liberal claptrap that is destroying our schools and our children. These students should be placed in special clinical environments and the cost should be borne by the parents, or by their insurance companies.

  • oldbat

    they are being put into schools in the charleston, sc area, a new one in the college park area i know of for sure

    • cat

      GREAT!!! They should have it in ALL SCHOOLS!!!

      Wow, now parents are opposed to time out and think it’s not safe? What’s next?

  • Kris

    It blows my mind that anyone would voluntarily place their children into these government-run re-education camps. These sick institutions are run by greedy, self-serving unions who have proven over and over that they only have their own interests in mind. The only thing they teach these poor kids is dependence, servitude, and that expressing your individuallity will earn you a severe punishment. Thinking outside of the box is stricktly forbidden. Everyone should read a book titled “Dumbing Us Down” by John Taylor Gatto.

    • cat

      Sounds like you’ve been dumbed down. You teach for a month. You’d be eaten alive.

      • RCR

        On behalf of all children everywhere please allow me to thank you sincerely for NOT teaching.

      • Kris

        Doesn’t sound like you’re accustomed to debate or even intelligent conversation, so I’ll try to make this simple: Your inane comment only reinforces my point. Teachers get eaten alive because they’re trying to force free spirits into preassigned boxes according to narrow measurements of their worth (a grade of A, B, C in the study of math, etc.). This is unnatural and indeed has little bearing on how the real world functions. There’s a whole list of reasons why children act out in school, and nearly all of them pertain to the structure of “schooling” itself. Humans will naturally reject forced servitude and conformity, and that is what lies at the heart of a teacher’s struggle.

        • cat

          One of my eighth graders, while pregnant, got into a fight with another girl in class and started ripping out her hair. Now, a small room for her to calm down in would have been safe for her, the baby, and would have kept the entire class safe.

          Go see what it’s like.

  • george

    Government schools . . . bringing the fun experience of Gitmo to a small suburb near you.

  • brad

    The teachers are probably using the rooms to have sex with each other or the students.

  • retired teacher

    Remember all the teachers’ union tell us all thatbthey seek& do is for the children. Not!!

  • Lori

    totally disgusted by this. this is not ok for any child., special needs or not. it is abusive and the principal and teachers should be brought up on charges. if it was my kid put in there i’d go up there and lock them in the room. and i agree- these teachers should not be teaching!!!!

    • cat

      YEAH!!! IT IS SO BAD AND EVIL TO HAVE A CHILD SIT IN A QUIET ROOM TO CALM DOWN and no longer draw attention to himself when the student had been disrespectul to a teacher or disrupted the learning of a class and the parents have failed to teach a child how to respect authority and behave!!! THE NERVE!!!!

  • mrstag

    That is a disgrace. What do they think these kids are animals?? Even animals shouldn’t be treated like that. If these teachers are not able to deal with these kids, then they shouldn’t be teaching there. Maybe these kids need to be in a special school where there are teachers that are educated in teaching them and know how to handle them.

    • cat

      Or maybe parents should discipline their kids. Why would you be okay with it for the special needs kids and not the regular kids. YOU TEACH FOR A MONTH!!!! I DID IN NYC FOR FIVE YEARS!!!!!!!!!! Kids need isolation to calm down. Get off your high horse.

      • dog

        Calm down. Can you say…special needs? Special needs drequire and deserve special care.

      • BarrysHypocrisy

        Yeah, OBVIOUSLY the whole “kids need isolation” is working wonderfully in this case. Time outs don’t work.

        • Jennifer

          in “cat”‘s world, being taken out of school in a stretcher is evidence of a successful outcome.

1 2 3 5
blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

Latest News Video