NEW YORK (WFAN/AP) — Three more overtimes, four Big East teams standing.

And there’s plenty still to come at Madison Square Garden.

Syracuse, Cincinnati, Louisville and Notre Dame advanced to the semifinals of the nation’s most exciting conference basketball tournament on another day of March Madness in the city that never sleeps.

The 23rd-ranked Fighting Irish capped a hectic Thursday by outlasting South Florida 57-53 in a game that went to overtime and ended just before midnight. Hours earlier, Yancy Gates and the Bearcats got past No. 13 Georgetown 72-70 in double OT.

No. 2 Syracuse rallied for a 58-55 victory over defending champion Connecticut in the first quarterfinal, and Rick Pitino’s feisty Louisville team ran away from No. 9 Marquette, 84-71.

Jim Boeheim and the Orange face Cincinnati in one semifinal Friday night, followed by Louisville against Notre Dame.

The Irish advanced this far the past two seasons as well, but they’ve never gone further. They are 0-4 in semifinal games since joining the Big East for the 1995-96 season.

“I really believe this group, of all my teams, is most equipped to get to Saturday night,” coach Mike Brey said. “It’s something we talked about in our program for a while. It’s the next step. I think our program has been extremely consistent and solid in the Big East, but playing on Saturday would mean a lot, and I think this group has really digested it. Of course, we play the same guys who stopped us from getting there last year in Louisville.”

That game went to overtime as well, before the Cardinals emerged with an 83-77 win.

And hey, it figures.

Three games have gone to OT already in this year’s Big East tournament, matching 1998 and 2011 for the most ever. Perhaps that bodes well for the third-seeded Irish (22-10), who are 3-0 in overtime games this season after edging No. 6 seed South Florida (20-13). They won 67-65 in double OT at Louisville on Jan. 7.

“Every time we play them it’s never regulation. The last six, seven games. It’s unbelievable,” Brey said.

Gates scored 23 points in his back-and-forth, big-man duel with Henry Sims, including two baskets in the last 2 minutes of regulation as fourth-seeded Cincinnati (23-9) fought back from an 11-point deficit with less than 8½ minutes left against No. 5 seed Georgetown (23-8).

The senior was such a force that the Hoyas swarmed to him on the Bearcats’ final possession in the second overtime, freeing Cashmere Wright to bank in a runner for the winning shot with 7.6 seconds to go.

“This is my last shot at it, so you don’t want to just play one game and go home right away,” Gates said. “I’ll never play in the Garden in the Big East tournament again, so just trying to push and fight and stay here as long as possible.”

There were seven ties and 18 lead changes in the first multiple-overtime game at the Big East tournament since Syracuse beat UConn 127-117 in six OTs in the 2009 quarterfinals.

Then, in the semifinals last year, Connecticut beat the Orange 76-71 in overtime.

Their rematch Thursday ended in 40 minutes, but it was pretty tense just the same.

The top-seeded Orange (31-1), expected to be a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament as well, won their 11th straight game overall. This was their first game after earning a double-bye into the quarterfinals.

“I hate sitting around all week, and it’s very difficult,” Boeheim said. “We haven’t played that many games and we need to play again. Tomorrow’s game will help us, but this was a tremendous comeback. This team has been very good down the stretch all year, and that was the case today.”

The game again pitted Boeheim against fellow coaching great Jim Calhoun — though both have been dealing with off-the-court problems this season.

Boeheim, whose program has weathered the child sex-abuse allegations against fired associate head coach Bernie Fine and recent allegations of former players in the program failing drug tests, earned his 887th win, second on the career list.

“This was reported five years ago, and we’re waiting for them to finish the process,” Boeheim said when asked about the drug tests. “If things were bothering us we wouldn’t be 31-1. Nothing bothers us. We come ready to play. That’s what you should do in life. Everybody gets bothered. Everybody has problems. I’m much more concerned about my wife being mad at me than I am anything else, to tell you the truth.”

About 3 hours after Boeheim spoke at the news conference the NCAA released a statement clarifying the time frame.

“The NCAA enforcement staff received a self-report from Syracuse University on October 27, 2010,” the organization said.

Boeheim even took the time to give his thoughts on the Peyton Manning free agency frenzy.

“I think Manning should really come to the Jets,” he said.

Calhoun and the ninth-seeded Huskies (20-13), last year’s national champs, had their 13-game postseason winning streak snapped.

Pitino’s defensive-minded team has been perhaps the most impressive in the Big Apple so far. After a pair of losses last week knocked the seventh-seeded Cardinals (24-9) out of The Associated Press Top 25, they shut down Seton Hall in the second round Wednesday and then forced No. 2 seed Marquette (25-7) into 26 turnovers, one shy of the tournament record.

“They kept hounding us,” Golden Eagles star Darius Johnson-Odom said. “I think we had an idea that they were going to pressure us. I didn’t think it was going to be at a high level like that.”

Who will win the Big East tourney? Make your prediction below…

(TM and Copyright 2012 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2011 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

Watch & Listen LIVE