NEW BRUNSWICK, N.J. (CBSNewYork/AP) — Mike Rice may have been fired as the Rutgers men’s basketball coach after a video surfaced showing him shoving players and berating them with gay slurs, but critics said New Jersey’s flagship public university still has more explaining — and maybe some more firing — to do.
A group of 13 faculty members Wednesday demanded that university President Robert Barchi resign for his “inexcusable handling” of the situation.
Some said athletic director Tim Pernetti should also be dismissed and some are questioning what Barchi knew, and when.
“He clearly knew about this tape. He knew about these actions of Coach Rice and yet, he not only did nothing, Coach Rice stayed on the payroll,” English professor Belinda Edmundson told CBS 2’s Christine Sloan.
Rutgers assistant men’s basketball coach Jimmy Martelli also resigned, Rutgers University confirmed on Wednesday.
Rice is owed a $100,000 bonus for completing the 2012-13 season, which a Rutgers spokesman said the school is contractually obligated to pay. He wouldn’t be collecting it if he had been let go back in December when the university first saw the video.
“There is an obscene emphasis on sports at the expense of education,” Edmundson said.
Alumni, lawmakers and a gay-rights group are among those calling for an investigation into why university officials took months to fire Rice after getting the video from a former basketball program employee in a scandal that touches on two long-standing issues on campus: the role of sports and the treatment of gays.
“If the roles were reversed and this was a professor and not a coach and this was a student in the classroom as opposed to a collegiate player this would be completely different. You wouldn’t say, ‘This was a first offense,'” said Glenn Articolo, a radiologist who lives in Marlton and is a 1991 Rutgers graduate. “There’s not a single employee at Rutgers University from the president to the janitor who wouldn’t be dismissed immediately. It seems there’s a double standard when it comes to the basketball coach or the football coach.”
In a statement Wednesday, Barchi, who took office in September, said he was told of the video in November and agreed that it would be appropriate to suspend Rice, fine him and send him to anger management counseling. But he said it was after he saw the video this week that he decided Rice should be fired.
Pernetti also issued a statement Wednesday, but he and Barchi were not made available to answer reporters’ questions.
Assembly Speaker Sheila Oliver, a Democrat who spoke about the topic on several radio and television shows Wednesday, is calling for legislative hearings on the details.
Senate President Stephen Sweeney has his questions, too, particularly about Pernetti.
“That Mr. Rice had to go was clear. But questions still remain as to why we are only now finding out about this and why the school’s athletic director initially defended his handling of the situation,” Sweeney said in a statement Wednesday. “Were the student’s parents informed of what occurred? Were they made aware that their kids were having basketballs thrown at their heads, being shoved around and being called disparaging names by someone in a position of authority? The very fact that Rutgers would subject these kids to this kind of behavior after the fact calls into question, yet again, what goes on in the athletic department over there. The athletic director has many questions to answer and one has to wonder whether he should pick the new coach.”
The gay-rights group Garden State Equality also called for an investigation.
Much of the anger over the university’s handling of the situation came because Rice was not fired until after the public saw the video.
“Why did they fire him? Just because the tape came out?” asked Jim Walton, a 1980 Rutgers graduate who is now a compliance and ethics manager in Philadelphia. “They already knew the truth. If he should have been fired today, he should have been fired a long time ago.”
For years, some at Rutgers, a long-time also-ran in major sports, have been debating whether it’s been worth it to spend more money and put more focus on trying to elevate the university’s football and men’s basketball programs.
The university has also dealt with how gay students are treated since Tyler Clementi, a freshman there, killed himself in 2010 days after learning his roommate had used a webcam to see him kissing another man. The roommate spent 20 days in jail last year after a jury convicted him of bias intimidation and other crimes in a case that sparked policy changes to try to make Rutgers friendlier to gay students.
“After the suicide of Tyler Clementi, I thought my alma mater would take the use of gay slurs by any member of the Rutgers community — students, faculty, administrators, or coaches — seriously,” said Debbie Hadley, a 1991 Rutgers graduate who is a naturalist in Jackson. “Clearly, Tim Pernetti did not. And yes, I believe he should be fired, too.”
Some students agreed that the coach needed to be ousted.
Alison Coopersmith, an 18-year-old first-year student majoring in political science said that if gay slurs are not tolerated by students, they shouldn’t be tolerated by professionals, either. “It’s worse when they’re in a position of power,” she said.
But on campus, not everyone was up in arms Wednesday.
Taylor Akers, a 19-year-old sophomore pre-med major, said Rice should not have been fired. “That happens all the time,” he said.
Former Rutgers player Frank Mitchell also said the punishment was too harsh based on his short time at the university.
“Based on my one year there, I would not have fired him,” Mitchell told WFAN radio on Wednesday. “Being there for the entire year, being in that gym three hours a day for six, seven months, whatever it was, I think his outrage or outbursts that you might have seen on that video were so few and far between that it wouldn’t warrant him being fired.”
Do you think Pernetti and Barchi have to go, too? Be heard in the comments…
(TM and © Copyright 2013 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)