Off-Duty Police Officer Arrested, Suspended After Altercation With Subway Conductor

Chaos Erupts On J Train After Conductor Pulls Emergency Brake

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) – An off-duty NYPD officer was arrested and suspended by the NYPD Wednesday, after an altercation with a conductor caused chaos on the subway on the Lower East Side.

As CBS2’s Christine Sloan reported, the incident left people trapped in a subway car with no idea what was going on. Some people were breaking windows to get out.

The incident took place at around 9:15 a.m. on the Brooklyn-bound J train as it was leaving the Delancey Street-Essex Street station.

The conductor — identified as Kiyya Rivera — opened a train door, which struck off-duty police officer Tremel Davis, prompting an argument, according to police.

Kiyya Rivera

MTA subway train conductor Kiyya Rivera was allegedly attacked by an off-duty police officer on a J Train on Wednesday, Sept. 14, 2016. (Credit: CBS2)

Davis, 33, then pushed her back into the conductor’s cab, knocking her to the ground and injuring her head and arm, police said.

The conductor pulled the emergency brake, halting the train with one car still in the station, according to the Metropolitan Transit Authority.

Davis was taken into custody at the scene. The conductor was taken to an area hospital complaining of pain to her head and arm. Her injuries are not considered to be serious.

Davis has been charged with assault. Since he was already on modified duty stemming from a prior off-duty misdemeanor arrest, he was suspended by the NYPD and is no longer reporting for duty.

He was also stripped of his badge and gun.

CBS2 has learned the officer was already on modified duty when the incident occurred.

The melee prompted a panic among passengers, some of whom ripped out subway windows in an attempt to escape.

“Nobody knew what was going on, even until the end,” passenger Rosario DiSalvo told Sloan. Somebody was screaming “that they were killing her,” DiSalvo said.

DiSalvo was on the train but had no idea the conductor was being attacked, Sloan reported. Some passengers heard the word “fire,” and others thought there was a bomb on the train.

So passengers took matters into their own hands.

“Me and two other guys broke the window and we started pulling people through the window onto the tracks,” DiSalvo said. “Everybody fell off the tracks. We ran off the tracks. Ran through the tunnel, people got stuck.”

The scene was captured on video in another car.

People on the platform tried to reassure those still on board that help was on the scene, CBS2’s Valerie Castro reported.

“The cops are down on the other train car wherever the problem is,” one witness said.

The MTA said it has received no substantiated reports that customers on the train entered the tracks. The agency said the train operator walked through the entire train within six minutes of the incident.

The train then backed up and police were on the scene, DiSalvo told Sloan.

“Some kid was arrested and they were looking for another guy on the tracks,” he said.

The train operator made announcements and walked through the entire train informing customers car by car, according to the MTA.

The incident caused delays on almost all the subway lines, Sloan reported.

The MTA says if you find yourself in this kind of situation, you should:

  • Stay calm and not leave the train on your own because in most cases the tracks are still electrified and other trains may still be in motion around you.
  • If you’re unable to stay in the car you’re currently in, the MTA urges you to walk calmly to another car that is not impacted by the emergency.
  • Don’t try to leave the train without instructions or help from the crew or other MTA employees.
  • If an evacuation is necessary, crew members, other MTA employees and emergency responders will help with the evacuation.

One man told Sloan he was stuck on an M train for 90 minutes.

Comments

One Comment

  1. Zev Stern says:

    The NYCTA is always telling us NOT to pull the emergency cord because it delays help from reaching the train. So why did that female conductor (conductrix?) pull the cord when the emergency was on board the train and not in front of it? Or did I answer my own question?

  2. The Facts says:

    Low standards for cop hiring these days. Affirmative action seems to be more important than merit. This is true throughout all government now.

  3. Yakoshiba Ugazaki says:

    It is not smart to assault a train officer!

    1. The Facts says:

      Conductors are not officers and have no law enforcement powers whatsoever. Their job is only to open and close the doors of the train.

      1. Yakoshiba Ugazaki says:

        Facts!

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

WFAN Football Cruise Drip
1010 WINS Special
WCBS 880 Breakfast

Listen Live