CBS2-Header-Logo WFAN 1010WINS WCBS tiny WLNYLogo

Latest Best of NY

NYC’s 12 Best Burgers

September 18, 2012 6:00 AM

View Comments

What is it about ground beef, heat, and a bun that produces such alchemy? Few foods are as a perfect at satisfying a simple, deep craving. The burger: we salute you. Even more so today, on National Cheeseburger Day. Here is a list of where to get some of the best in town. By Jesse Zanger.

bestburgersandshakes NYCs 12 Best Burgers

The Best Burgers burger is like the one you’d make in your back yard, if you had one. (Image from http://www.bestburgersshakes.com)

Best Burger And Shakes

416 W 46th St
New York, NY 10036
(212) 489-2992

This hole-in-the-wall isn’t much by way of decor (it has only 10 seats), but it has one of the best delivery burgers in the city. Why? Because it is pretty much identical to what most people would make at home, if they could: a classic back-yard burger. Plump, round, big-as-your-fist, juicy burgers that are cooked perfectly. The fries and rings are very disappointing, but the juicy burger is excellent. If you’re looking for delivery in Midtown, it’s the winner.

the palm NYCs 12 Best Burgers

(credit: The Palm)

The Palm

Multiple Locations, check website
New York, NY

Get ready for a massive meat bonanza. The Palm is a classic American steakhouse – it opened on 2nd Avenue in 1926, and has since franchised out across the country. The Bozzi Burger, named for one of the Italian immigrants who founded the restaurant, is a huge monster of a meal. It usually has a terrific, faint coating of char that adds a certain, delightful mmph to the flavor. Once you bite into it, get ready for a flood of juices. Afterward, you won’t need to eat for about a week – that is, if you finish it.

burgerjoint NYCs 12 Best Burgers

The peerless Burger Joint burger and fries. What else needs to be said? (Image from http://www.parkermeridien.com)

Burger Joint at Le Parker Meridien

119 West 56th Street
New York, NY 10019
(212) 245-5000
It would be impossible to do a round-up of the best burgers in NYC without including the triumphant Burger Joint. At or near the top of almost everyone’s “Best Burger” list, everything about this down-to-Earth place (in the midst of a highfalutin’ hotel) just works. Lines can be extremely long, especially in the middle of lunch hour, but if you can get one of the tables in this small, square reproduction of your college bar, sit down. Enjoy pitchers of brew and perfectly prepared, fresh and flavorful burgers. The fries and shakes are also no joke. One last point: unlike many of the burgers on this list, the Burger Joint burger isn’t too big. It is a small, delightful portion.

cornerbistro NYCs 12 Best Burgers

The Bistro Burger with cheese and bacon, known to some simply as “joy.” (Image from http://www.cornerbistrony.com)

Corner Bistro

331 West 4th Street
New York, NY 10014
(212) 242-9502

This West Village institution, which touts itself as one of the last bohemian bars in the area, is well known for the burger that lurks within its small, dark confines. The low-key neighborhood bar has retained its classic charm in the midst of a fast-changing, high-priced neighborhood. That said, it can get quite busy. The Bistro Burger is pretty cheap – now clocking in at a whopping $6.75. It is tender, juicy and delicious. Do yourself a favor if you go, though: don’t bother waiting for a cramped table in the back. Gently elbow your way to the bar, take a seat, and get your burger there while slurping down McSorley’s Dark for a mere $2.50 a glass.

donovans pub NYCs 12 Best Burgers

(Credit: nycfoodguy.com)

Donovan's Pub

5724 Roosevelt Avenue
Queens, NY 11377
(718) 439-9339

Reviewers lavish praise on Donovan’s, some calling it the best burger in the city. It is a huge, pub-style burger, lauded for its juiciness and perfect preparation. Chase it with a delicious pint of Guinness, enjoy the thick-cut steak fries, and you’re in for a great experience.

fivenapkinburger2 NYCs 12 Best Burgers

The dripping, juicy Five Napkin Burger. (credit: Jesse Zanger/melikeeat.com)

Five Napkin Burger

Multiple Locations, check website
New York, NY
Here is the simplest way to understand the 5 Napkin Burger: onion soup. Imagine, if you will, a bowl of the piping hot concoction. Now, retain the flavor, but swap out everything beneath the gooey cheese and replace it with fresh ground chuck. Voila – that is essentially the 5 Napkin Burger. It is dripping with juice (hence a “five napkin burger”) and slathered with melting gruyere cheese, onions and rosemary aioli. It started out as an item on the menu of Nice Matin, an Upper West Side restaurant, but proved so popular the owners broke it out into its own restaurant franchise. It’s wonderful.

j g melon NYCs 12 Best Burgers

(Credit: greenolivemedia.blogspot.com)

J.G. Melon

1291 3rd Avenue
New York, NY 10021
212-650-1310

Upper East Side stalwart J.G. Melon has been producing wonderful, juicy burgers since it opened in 1972. There’s a lot of things about the place that work: it’s unpretentious bar atmosphere, the dining room in the back. The round cottage-fried potatoes are also a treat, perhaps a bit too easy to keep popping down. Good thing the portion size – both of the burger and the fries – isn’t too large.

peterlugerburger NYCs 12 Best Burgers

Trust us, the Peter Luger burger won’t look like that for long. (Image from http://www.peterluger.com)

Peter Luger

178 Broadway
Brooklyn, NY 11211
(718) 387-7400

What is there not to love about Peter Luger’s steakhouse? Arguably the best in steakhouse in town also makes a serious burger, naturally. However, it is only available at lunch. It’s over a half a pound of delicious meat – what else would you expect from such a lauded institution? It is an open debate, however, whether it is worth getting the burger after going through the effort to get to the foot of the Williamsburg Bridge. After all, if you’ve gone that far, you may as well get their peerless porterhouse steak (not too mention the unreal bacon appetizer). But burger-lovers will hear the call of the Luger’s burger and sample it to their great delight. It crumbles into a medium-rare mass of meat.

pj clarks NYCs 12 Best Burgers

(credit: P.J. Clarke’s)

P.J. Clarke's

915 3rd Avenue
New York, NY 10022
(212) 317-1616

In some ways, the Clarke’s burger is definitional. It’s not too big to grab hold of, with a slim, but very choice, patty. There’s a slice of raw onion tucked underneath the bun, like a buried treasure waiting for you. The Clarke’s burger is so popular, and so well respected, that they now have four satellite locations throughout the city. The original on Third Avenue is the classic locale, retaining its historic, 19th century charm.

primeburger NYCs 12 Best Burgers

A Prime Burger with bacon. (Image from http://www.primeburger.com)

Prime Burger

5 East 51st Street
New York, NY 10022
(212) 759-4730

Set in the shadow of St. Patrick’s Cathedral, the Prime Burger is a throwback to an era of diners and “greasy spoons” that have mostly been priced out of the city. It feels a bit like a coffee shop. The Prime Burger has a lunch special that will particularly appeal to burger-lovers: the Prime Burger deluxe ($10.95, $11.95 with cheese). The deluxe comes with two burgers and fries, so you better be hungry, or willing to share. While the meat of the burger is no great shakes, the key is the relish, which when slathered on gives them extra juice and a hint of sweet, red pepper.

shake shack NYCs 12 Best Burgers

(credit: The Shake Shack)

Shake Shack

multiple locations, check website
New York, NY

Much has been made of Danny Meyer’s Shake Shack. It burst onto the scene in Madison Square Park in 2004 and became an instant sensation. Lines at the park can be very long, especially during lunch, and those same lines can also be found at their satellite locations. The Shake Shack is essentially New York’s answer to the legendary West Coast institution In ‘N Out, which much to many a burger-loving New Yorker’s chagrin does not franchise here. The Shake Shack provides a high-end, fresh variant of the “fast food” burger type.

wollenskysgrill NYCs 12 Best Burgers

Charred perfection from Wollensky’s Grill. (credit: Jesse Zanger/melikeeat.com)

Wollensky's Grill

49th Street & 3rd Avenue
New York, NY 10022
(212) 753-1530

Not enough can be said about perhaps the most underrated, high-profile burger in town. There’s an excellent combination of crunchy char and rich flavor with a marvelous “close-to-the-bone” note. The atmosphere at Wollensky’s Grill is raucous, filled with the after-work business crowd, and the hospitality of the hosts there, who make an effort to get to know you and treat you well, is also part of the experience.

View Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus