Latest Best of NY

NYC’s 5 Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

April 2, 2014 6:00 AM

View Comments

Slices of melted cheese between perfectly crunchy grilled bread is quite possibly one of the most comforting sandwiches known to man. Though most delis can sell you pre-sliced American on white bread, here are some grilled cheese sandwiches that are little more indulgent and worth a few more dollars. By Siobhan Wallace.

More: NYC’s 5 Best Breakfast Sandwiches

murrays cheese grilled cheese1 NYCs 5 Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

(credit: Murray’s)

Murray's Cheese

254 Bleecker Street
New York, NY 10014
(212) 243-3289

Murray’s Melts is a side counter inside Murray’s Cheese on Bleecker Street selling various delicious takes on grilled cheese, all for under $10. For the classic version, you can get the Murray’s Melt–a blend of cheeses on Sullivan Street Pullman bread–for $5, with add-ons like basil, sopressata, proscuitto or sauerkraut.

grilled cheese melt shop e1330617008306 NYCs 5 Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

(credit: The Melt Shop)

Melt Shop

601 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10022
(212) 759-6358

Tucked into a corner of a Midtown outdoor space below street-level lies the take-out window for Melt Shop. Though they offer choices of grilled cheeses filled with roast beef or buttermilk-fried chicken, you can still get an all-American classic of American cheese on white bread. But you should probably go with the maple-glazed bacon and Cheddar on sourdough.

img 3719 NYCs 5 Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

(credit: Siobhan Wallace)

The Morris Truck

Moving Target
New York, NY
(401) 440-8910

Featured Food Truck Lunch: Ricotta Meatball Sandwich from Morris Grilled Cheese

There are few grilled cheese food trucks roaming our streets, but one to definitely check out is Morris Grilled Cheese. The rotating menu has everything from gouda with pork jowl to pastrami with chimichurri. Their classic take on the grilled cheese though contains delicious New York State Cheddar with New Hampshire Landaff cheese.

308554 178854008867049 166882163397567 367152 1638770154 n NYCs 5 Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

(credit: Little Muenster/Facebook)

Little Muenster

100 Stanton Street
New York, NY 10002
(212) 203-7197

As grilled cheeses go, none of Little Muenster’s are under $7. That being said, none of them are simply cheese and bread. They use various unique cheeses like Maytag Blue, Chevre and of course, muenster in their fantastic sandwich combinations. The closest you’ll get to your classic childhood favorite is white American with tomato and bacon.

grilled cheese NYCs 5 Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

(credit: Alexandra Penfold/MidtownLunch.com)

Eggstravaganza Cart

52nd street NE (Park ave)
New York, NY

Parked on the Northeast corner of 52nd Street and Park Ave is unassuming street food cart Eggstravaganza. After they’re finished with breakfast service, the cart begins serving up lunch to the suited masses. One of their most popular dishes is chorizo and bacon grilled cheese. For just $5, it’s one of the best and most delicious deals around.


For the latest on New York City’s food scene, follow us on Twitter!
Siobhan Wallace is the co-founder of BlondieandBrownie.com.
View Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus