Nina In New York: More MTA Shenanigans! And by Shenanigans, I Mean Nudity.

A young professional’s take on the trials and tribulations of everyday life in New York City.

By Nina Pajak

Another day, another horrifying video of mental illness writ large on the New York City subways.

This week brings us a three-part series of a half-naked (the really naked half) woman perfunctorily attending to her “down there” washing up on the uptown 2 train. (The videos are not embedded here, due to their graphic nature and the likelihood that you’re probably drinking your coffee as you read this and we can’t be held responsible for damages caused by spilling or exaggerated spewing reactions). But I trust you in all your online resourcefulness that, should your curiosity best your ability to reason, you won’t have much trouble finding them. I have sacrificed my own breakfast in order that you may read my words and spare yourself a rather dehumanizing (not to mention icky) viewing experience. Suffice it to say that she leaves no crack unscrubbed. No! Geez! Sorry, I meant to phrase that more euphemistically. No stone unturned. Okay? Got the picture? Also in the third video, something questionable is going on with an empty gallon jug. Some YouTube commenters seem to think she’s relieving herself. Honestly, I couldn’t tell and I feel pretty good about never knowing.

Frankly, what’s more upsetting than the fact that she sits her bare bottom down on a seat (just reinforces my paranoid instinct to remain standing on all subway cars) is the fact that I wasn’t actually that upset by watching these videos. Sure, they’re gross and disturbing. And sad, of course, though really our Bronx-bound express bather didn’t seem in the least bit of distress. She sort of looks like she could break into a round of “Rubber Ducky” at any second. But watching made me realize just how numb I am and so many of us are to these types of things. And I don’t believe that’s due to the fact that we’re jaded, insensitive New Yorkers who see stuff every day that would make a Nebraskan run for the hills (or plains?). No, I’m pretty sure it all boils down to the Internet.

Think about it: who is creepier than a person so sick she casually washes her privates on public transportation? That’s right: the person who sits, watches, and videotapes the whole thing in order to load it onto YouTube for all the world to see (and those of us who couldn’t help but click). Without a doubt, that person bore witness to a pretty incredible story, and I’m sure the desire to share the unreal experience with others was undeniable. And hey, here’s a phone with video capability, and hey! there’s a platform built for readily and immediately sharing such gems with the public. I can’t blame this person for anything he or she did. It was pretty normal behavior, by today’s standards. A classic “only in New York” example just begging to be captured and disseminated. Check and check.

Except that by now, we’ve viewed so many psychotic tirades, so much public nudity, so much shoe-licking and crying and fighting and screaming and all-around whacked out behavior online that not only are we disillusioned New Yorkers (as is our right), but the rest of the world is too! What good are our stories of they can’t shock anyone anymore? Can’t make people laugh or blush or act surprised? What do we have if all of our best material is already yesterday’s meme? Our “only in New York” adventures aren’t only in New York anymore. They’re all over the damn place. And its watering down the little moments that make living here so… uh… charming.

Let’s keep our lunatics local for a little while and work on rebuilding our cred. It won’t be easy, but think of how we can wow ’em at that family wedding in Oklahoma next year! Hey Aunt Hazel, did I ever tell you the one about the guy who eats his own toenails? I’m sure you’ve all got plenty of your own.


Dear Readers: While I am rarely at a loss for words, I’m always grateful for column ideas. Please feel free to e-mail me your suggestions.

Nina Pajak is a writer and publishing professional living with her husband on the Upper West Side.

The Nina Archives:

Thanks But No Thanks, Holiday Travel

What Exactly Is A ‘Stowaway’ Anyway?

Back At The Gym, And Paying The Price

I’m Back, And I’m Not Going Anywhere. Until I Go On Another Trip.

Peace Out (For A Week)

Time For New York To Step Up And Commit Already

Let’s Drop This ‘Rehab’ Thing, Shall We?


One Comment

  1. linda says:

    America take examples from Europe,
    they do have public toilets and showers and why not

  2. Rugbyball says:

    to add to my comment, if site manager does not take action then the manager is at fault not the writer

  3. Shortysmom says:

    It’s common sense! If the MTA or the city would provide public toilets, people wouldn’t “relieve” themselves in public!!!! Yes, it’s wrong, but so is making someone hold it in for long periods of time. That is pure torture! Take it from someone who has bladder problems. It is almost impossible to find a subway station with public toilets. Most restaurants don’t allow you to use thier restrooms either unless your a customer.

    1. Rugbyball says:

      Many decades ago the MTA had public restrooms, but in the depressed years of late 60’s, 70’s they where stalls of horror. You can’t place security cameras in Public Restrooms and the thugs and drug addicts knew that.
      NYC was flat broke and couldn’t hire attendants for each and every public restrooms to secure them. So you would get caught with your pants down, literally, and get mugged or worse if you used them. Drug addicts used the stalls as shoot up parlors. Homeless would sleep in the stalls or floors, junkies where found dead in many a stall by the NYPD. It was horrid. And you would gladly go in your pants before you risked the Subway restrooms. The newer automated stalls they test tried in NYC above ground and in some other cities here in USA and abroad seem to be a better fit, they are able to tell how long your in the stall and if you are in over a set amount of time they can issue a recorded warning and also report to a command center. If deemed necessary they could send a police officer to investigate. But this is NYC and our homeless seem like some of the smartest and would get around the system some how.

  4. Rugbyball says:

    Now as far as the Internet making us callous to the mental illness we see around our city, I can assure you this all went on and worse in the 70’s 80’s and 90’s (pre-public internet 90’s) in NYC. They are doing more for these troubled souls now than they did in the past decades, maybe not enough still; but more non-the-less.

  5. Miranda says:

    That’s utterly disgusting … yet plenty of readers (including yours truly) will probably search for the video after reading this column!

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE