Ann Pettway Pleads Guilty In Decades-Old Harlem Kidnapping Case

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — A North Carolina woman charged with kidnapping a newborn baby from a Manhattan hospital nearly 25 years ago pleaded guilty in federal court Friday afternoon.

Ann Pettway turned herself in to the FBI last January and was charged with felony kidnapping after admitting to abducting Carlina White in 1987.

Joy White, the biological mother of Carlina White, had angry words for Pettway stemming from the traumatic loss of her daughter.

“It was cruel. She was so mean,” said Joy White on Friday. “This is really too much for me right now.”

White was just 16 when her daughter Carlina was kidnapped from Harlem Hospital.  Baby Carlina was taken by Pettway who raised the girl in Bridgeport, Conn. and gave her the name “Nedjra Nance.”

Joy White said she would never forget Pettway’s face. She saw her when she was posing a nurse, telling her that her sick baby would be alright, even as she plotted to run off with the child.

“She knew what she was doing at the time, and she preyed on me,” said Joy White.

Carlina White had suspicions of her mom since they didn’t look anything alike, and Pettway couldn’t produce any of White’s birth records when she became pregnant as a teen.

LISTEN: 1010 WINS’ Juliet Papa Reports

White’s fears were confirmed when she found her own baby picture next to a computer generated image from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.

The center tracked down her real mother, and White, having solved her own cold case, found her way home.

Prosecutors said Pettway admitted to the kidnapping after suffering several miscarriages, and was desperate to be a mother. Pettway said she was sorry and acknowledged she caused a lot of pain.

“I went to the hospital.  I took the child and raised her as my own.  It was wrong,” Pettway said in court.

As part of her plea bargain, prosecutors agreed to recommend between 10 and 12 1/2 years in prison for the 51-year-old, though she faced up to 20 years.

But White’s family said she should serve 23 years, the same amount of time their girl was missing.

Pettway will be sentenced on May 14.

Share your thoughts in the comments section below…


One Comment

  1. Esmerelda says:

    No winners here.
    Its sad all the way around.
    Biological parents sqaundered the money, Pettway will be spending 20 years
    behind bars, the girl is a teen mother…. goodness, all losers.

  2. Sorry says:

    sorry title was a carryover from another post

  3. goldielois says:

    I agree,they should throw the book at her.The girls real mother has lived through hell for all these years so why does she only get a slap on the wrist?

  4. Kathleen Tandy says:

    This PIG should be put away for the rest of her life.

    She took that baby from a good home and kept it with her among her family filled with jailbirds and assorted ghetto animals. She’s destroyed this girl!

    And for that, she should be put away for the rest of her disgusting, miserable life.

    1. What planet are you from says:

      So right. Then the girl who was abducted tried to get money for her biological parents because they recieved a settlement from the hospital in the case. When the parents did not have any money she had a falling out with them.

      1. goldielois says:

        just proves what a great job Pettway did in raising her. Hang the bitch.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE