Long Island Community Still Reeling, Hopes To Have Closure Soon

RIVERHEAD, N.Y. (CBSNewYork) – David Laffer, the suspect charged with killing four people at a Medford pharmacy in June, is expected to plead guilty on Thursday.

1010 WINS has learned that the 33-year-old will plead guilty before a judge in a Suffolk County courtroom.

His wife Melinda Brady, who is charged with robbery and obstruction, is also expected to plead guilty on Thursday.

LISTEN: 1010 WINS’ Mona Rivera reports

“I was told that both of them would be pleading guilty,” said Daniel Taccetta, brother of victim Jamie Taccetta.

Jamie was one of four victims killed in the execution-style murders at Haven Pharmacy on Father’s Day. Also killed were Raymond Ferguson, Jennifer Mejia and Bryon Sheffield.

Relatives have been told to be in court on Thursday. Taccetta says he’ll sit silently even though he feels like lashing out at Laffer and his wife.

“Tomorrow will be just a very emotional day. We are going to see what happens in court with Laffer and Melinda Brady,” Daniel Taccetta told CBS 2’s Jennifer McLogan.

“It’s going to be hard to hold back,” he said.

PHOTOS: Medford Pharmacy Massacre

Laffer is charged with five counts of first-degree murder and four counts of criminal use of firearms. He pleaded not guilty to those charges back in June.

He was originally charged with only one count of first-degree murder and resisting arrest.

The five first-degree murder counts are for the deaths of the four victims and an umbrella charge for multiple murders, according to the indictment. Laffer and Brady were arrested on June 22 in connection with the murders. Police say Brady drove the getaway car. She, too, had pleaded not guilty in June.

In a police statement, Brady said that while she and her husband plotted the robbery at Haven Pharmacy, she did not know the plan involved killing.

Still shaken by the heinous crimes, Medford residents told CBS 2’s McLogan they just want to put the entire ordeal behind them.

“He needs to hang. He needs to hang, his wife needs to hang,” Medford homeowner Lisa Santiago said, adding when asked what the massacre had done to the community, “he destroyed it. He destroyed it.”

“We went to school together. In high school, he dated a few of my friends. He was in ROTC. He was a good guy back then,” homeowner Dorothy Quinn added.

“You have to get on with your life. You can’t just lay down and let people like David Laffer take over,” fellow resident Linda Ratto said.

LINK: Read The Felony Complaint Against Melinda Brady

Laffer faces life without parole on the murder charges and up to 25 years on each weapons charge. Brady faces up to 25 years in prison. The district attorney is expected to sit down with the families before the court session Thursday to give details on the guilty pleas, and explain why Brady is not facing the same charges as her husband.

What do you think? Sound off below in our comments section…

Comments (14)
  1. Omar says:

    You are a troll and your comment is not recognized as legit.

    1. Scmoking Lovely says:


  2. Justice Served says:

    Now, this POS and his wife should not be executed. They should stand as the poster children of addiction to LEGAL drugs. This war on drugs seems only aimed at cocaine, marijuana, heroin. etc the natural drugs that can’t be patented by big pharmaceutical companies. . We need a war in drugs for all these so called patented legal drugs. Too many are dying because of them. No one has ever died because of smoking a joint.

    1. Big Pharma says:

      Hey, HEY! That’s crazy talk. Ignore above post.

  3. Vito says:

    You’re entitled to your opinion, but would you have the same opinion if 4 members of YOUR FAMILY were needlessly executed in a botched robbery?

  4. Bridget says:

    Hopefully he never see’s the light of day ever again.

  5. Bob says:

    Here in Florida, they both get the death penalty.

    1. Bridget says:

      Sorry Bob, in Florida they would get acquitted.

      1. IgnoranteElephante says:

        Where do you come up with such a statement? In Florida, they would have been executed and rightfully so.

        Oh, I know another Casey Anthony discontent. Get over it! There was no real evidence that she killed her kid. The only evidence was that she was a horrible mother who cared more about partying than her child. That plus raw emotion and outrage mixed with dopey Nancy Grace and her poisonous rhetoric don’t prove guilt. Gut feelings and hunches, while sometimes reliable, don’t qualify as evidence of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

      2. Justice Served says:

        I agree with IgnoranteElephante. What evidence was there that Ms. Anthony killed the child? None. There was no evidence even of how the child died. I understand that the actions of Ms. Anthony make her look less than innocence but this is America. Looks are not evidence.

      3. steve says:

        I totally agree with Bridget…i

  6. mcullough says:

    It is the best outcome to a horrible situation.

    1. Justice Served says:

      The Best outcome would be an eye for an eye,

Leave a Reply