NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — A library in Queens got a big surprise in the mail in the form of a book – a collection of Paul Bunyan stories that was checked out more than 60 years ago.

CBS2’s Jessica Layton spoke with the woman who returned it, adding a new chapter to the old book.

READ MORE: Signs Of Spring: Cherry Blossoms Blooming At Brooklyn Botanic Garden

“It was due July 10, 1957, so I would have been 10,” said Betty Diamond.

Once upon a time in Whitestone, there was a little girl who was incredibly thrilled to sign out books from her public library.

“I just remember the feeling of wonder,” Diamond said.

But there was one book, “Ol’ Paul,” that for whatever reason she just didn’t return on time.

Days overdue became months overdue, then 63 years.

“My memory is that it was overdue and I was too embarrassed to return it,” Diamond said. “So as little kids do, well then, let’s just pretend it didn’t happen.”

Diamond, 74, now lives in Madison, Wisconsin. She decided it was finally time to call the Auburndale branch of the Queens Public Library and fess up.

READ MORE: Rods, Lures, And Mid-Century Furniture? Dream Fishing Tackle Offers Unlikely Combination From Greenpoint Father And Daughter

“I was just having a conversation with some friends about making amends and it was just like, you know, it’s time. I’m going to return this book,” she said.

“It is wonderful to see a book returned after 63 years, especially pretty much in the condition that it was checked out in in 1957,” said Nick Buron, chief librarian of the Queens Public Library, which celebrates 125 years on Friday.

“Whether it’s for children’s books like this, whether it’s for learning a language … The library is here for the community,” Buron said.

When Diamond mailed back the book, she included a letter and a $500 check as a donation to the library.

“It just seems so generous. ‘Here, take a book. We trust you to return it.’ And most people do – I did, eventually,” she said.

It’s a tale that teaches it’s never too late to do the right thing. And when you do, there’s a good chance you’ll be met with kindness.

Diamond was not fined for the overdue book. The donation was too generous.

MORE NEWS: New Jersey Family Rescued On Mountain In Maine Says Hiking Trail Sign Pointed Them In Wrong Direction

CBS2’s Jessica Layton contributed to this report.

CBSNewYork Team