Keidel: Derek Jeter – A Cue For No. 2

By Jason Keidel
» More Columns

The clamor over Derek Jeter is so loud and tense you expect a swordfight to ensue in a few hours.

I wrote Jeter’s baseball epitaph on this Web site last year (“September Song for Mr. November”). The piece was prescient and now you’re mad at those of us who rather reasonably predicted that the captain of the New York Yankees, a no-brainer Hall-of-Famer, no longer plays like one, and never will. The next time you’ll see Derek Jeter hit .330 is in syndication, or on his “Yankeeography.”

Show me a stellar 37-year-old shortstop who isn’t a patron of BALCO. Jeter hit .270 last year. Cal Ripken hit .270 when he was 36, and Ernie Banks hit .276, though both had better power numbers than Jeter.

The Hall of Fame is, by definition, inhabited by men who retired because they could not perform anymore. Many of these men were better than Derek Jeter, yet Jeter is somehow above the inevitable and inexorable grip of Father Time, who never lets go. But we must let Jeter go. For his sake, for our sake.

In a sense, Jeter’s decline unveils his dignity. The whispers that he never cheated have morphed into mandates, his on-field countenance and performance a walking bullhorn for respect. Respect for the game, himself, his peers, his friends, and his fans. He did it the right way.

His scripted platitudes after every game give him a synthetic persona. Honestly, there’s no need to interview Jeter after games, because you’ll get the clichés you got yesterday, and the month before that, and the year before that. But the fact that he’s too bland for the back page shows how vigorously he regarded his reputation.

Jeter went 1-for-4 last night, keeping his batting average at a very average .250. It won’t likely get better from here. But at his age and wage he will be the vortex of many verbal scraps over the next few months. Many want him to get his 3,000 hits and retire with the aged elegance of his single-digit predecessors.

Seems fair. Except that the Yankees, as I feared, slid another suitcase of cash under his door, signing him to a rather exorbitant contract before this season. It was clearly a legacy contract, a pat on the back for having the team’s back since 1996. Does he deserve it? Any answer is subjective. But the economics of athletics were never fair, as bloated as a steroid-swollen bicep.

Jeter is this generation’s gentleman icon. Perhaps our grandparents felt the same sorrow over Joe DiMaggio. But if you watched Mantle hobble around the bases as though he stepped on a landmine at first, or cringed as Mays stumbled around Shea Stadium’s centerfield, or watched Carlton get slapped around Veteran’s Stadium, you know that this happens to every mortal, even an immortal.

Jeter will leave the game, fly a private plane, and land on his parking lot. His driveway can double as a runway, leading to a mansion with its own area code, 38,000 square-feet of opulence. Jeter will retire at around 40 with nine-digits in his bank account.

And this is the man you pity because we have the temerity to cite a few facts?

The problem with the Jeter debate is it’s unfairly framed. To hear his apologists, anyone who dares to question his production is a traitor, some ungrateful, mutinous mope who wouldn’t know a baseball if it drilled them in the jaw.

Let’s be clear – we’re all for Derek Jeter. Even the most rabid Yankee detractor has no quarrel with the Captain. Baseball, more than any sport, trades on a star’s stats. But it also trades on nostalgia, and once the physical and metaphysical clash we arrive at a most awkward axis – the aging legend.

They are old when their stats don’t reflect their stardom. That’s where Jeter is today. The numbers don’t lie, nor should they. Nor should you feel sorry for him for that.

Here are some numbers. Jeter will have his retired the moment he hangs up his spikes. He’s assured a bronze bust in Cooperstown and a plaque in Monument Park, and perhaps a few national parks bearing his name, along with streets, avenues, and boulevards from Michigan to Manhattan.

For 15 years, he’s had supermodels on speed dial, and open invitations to open bedrooms we’ve only dreamed of entering. He’s still quite handsome, his retreating hairline the only hint of age. He’s had no real injuries, meaning he won’t limp toward his golden years. His wits and wallet intact, he can slide into a studio as an analyst, take a job as a coach or spring training instructor, or assume a most privileged position as baseball ambassador and eternal Yankee. It’s a rough life.

We can talk about his batting stance, his range, how he strides to the ball, or how he will stride to the Hall. Let’s just hope he saunters, not staggers, to immortality.

Feel free to email me:

Does Jeter have anything left in the tank? Fire away in the comments below…


One Comment

  1. Yankeefanforever says:

    Derek is a great player. You do not have t be the best player in the game to be great. He is one of the best players in the last decade and a half, and to argue otherwise is just plain stupid. Yes he is getting older and his production has been down, but he did hit 2 home runs today and had 4 hits. Let’ s give him another couple of months to get it together before we retire him. He will probably need to adjust to getting older and possibly eventually have to be moved down in the lineup. He is batting .276 as of today. A good home stand and he could be at .300 by next Sunday.

  2. Vic says:

    Great article, but does anyone else believe that a lot of the problems the Yanks are having may be due to the players being frustrated by management’s refusal to move Jeter from the top of the batting order? The Captain should certainly be able to see where problems lie within his own team and be willing to step down. It’s time to stop coddling Jeter and move on.

    1. Kurt Spitzner says:


      1. JK says:

        You’re a big dummy! Jeter’s still in his prime. He’ll hit .330 until he’s 60.

    2. JK says:

      Thanks, Vic. And you’re spot-on. Somehow it’s our fault that’s he’s getting old – as everyone does – and that he can’t play at his former, brilliant form. It seems we’re all idiots for telling the truth.

      1. Kurt Spitzner says:


  3. Kurt Spitzner says:

    Time not tide waits for no man and Derek Jeter is no different.Great REAL piece about a great REAL player!

    1. JK says:

      You got it all wrong, Kurt. I’m a big, ridiculous dummy who has nothing better to do than pick on poor No. 2. 😉

      1. Kurt Spitzner says:

        Some folks deal in reality and some folks don’t and you can tell which are which just by reading the various comments posted here!Are you really surprised that many have missed all your actual and factual points?

      2. Kurt Spitzner says:

        Oh,that’s right I forgot that you make all this stuff up,lol 🙂

    2. Kurt Spitzner says:

      Time NOR tide…. OOOOPS!

  4. Stiles says:

    Jason, relax you dummy. Grab a coke and smike, take 10 seconds and breathe. You have nothing better to do than bust Jeter’s balls in May? After this article is doesn’t seem like “we’re all for Derek Jeter” does it? You are ridiculous.

    1. JK says:

      Try dealing in facts, not name-calling. Oh, wait, you can’t. The numbers don’t lie. You’re allowed to keep your Jeter Snuggie, though.

  5. joey says:

    I’m sorry to say this article rings true… we all love Jeter, but I don’t see this season turning around for the better, let alone the next two. It will be interesting to see what happens, a line-up drop, a change of position, but whatever is it, his presence unfortunately hinders the Yankees’ chances at this point. He looks slow in the field, his range is just shot. I’ve only seen a handful of hit balls reach the outfield on a fly. It’s a sad state of affairs for the Captain, and the Yankees who signed his for another 3 long seasons.

  6. Mary says:

    Dererk is great ………….
    Everyone should just calm down about this season (his) so far…
    He is a grear player a great Yankee and a lot of the players
    today should be like him….

    1. Horace Clarke says:

      I am a Yankee fan and I happen to like Derek Jeter.
      That said, he has been a very good player. Great? Nah. Not great. Albert Pujols is a great player. Jeter is just very good. He is also very lucky to have stayed away from debilitating injuries over the course of his career. He will get to the hall of fame on the strength of 3000 hits. Sorry, but not great.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS New York

Get Our Morning Briefs

Watch & Listen LIVE